More intelligence causes decrease in congressional oversight
Boyd 10 [“Improving U.S. Congressional Oversight of Intelligence Services: A Comparative Policy Approach”; Vol. 28, No. 1 of American Intelligence Journal, pp. 29-39; DOA: 6/23/22; https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/44327128.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A65d8e7be9fc9021eaf55b6ecf1242f28&ab_segments=&origin=; Lowell-ES]
When in the 1970s the Congress created the two committees dedicated to the oversight of intelligence, the overall goal was to achieve awareness of intelligence activities." Since then, the Intelligence Community size, budget, and capabilities have grown exponentially, increasing the challenge of maintaining this awareness and conducting oversight. Many of the advantages and disadvantages of the three courses of action above relate to the ability of the Congress to effectively maintain accountability of the intelligence services rather than increased transparency to the public. All three involve trade-offs with regard to the cost of conducting oversight, measured in dollars, hours, and trees (to create paper). A strong argument can be made that, despite the criticism of the 9/11 Commission, academics, and the press, U.S. Congressional intelligence oversight is among the best in the world. Oversight is occurring and there has been greater accountability and transparency in the past three years in particular. Because effective oversight is occurring, option one, maintaining the status quo of a strong oversight mandate, is the most acceptable option. Option two is not recommended because there is likely never to be sufficient political will to adopt a joint intelligence oversight committee. However, if the Congress does want to make a change and still keep its strong oversight committees, option three is unique in that it creates a central point of contact into Congress to liaison directly with the public. This type of position may fill a gap that may grow wider in the post-9/11 world—the gap between the public and its government that is best bridged through accountability and transparency. Despite the best intentions of the government, its actions can be flawed in practice and a law can be the cause of inequity or injustice. The German Bundestag model of a Petitions Committee can serve as a central point of contact for citizens to contact Congress with a complaint or suggestion for legislation. This can be a bold new way for Congress to express its commitment to transparency and accountability and mitigate growing concerns, in particular, regarding the activities of our intelligence services.