Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Oversight solves NATO effectiveness. Congress improves burden sharing and trust.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay, senior editor at Politico Magazine, where she focuses on foreign policy and global affairs. She is a 2021 graduate of the Harvard Kennedy School, where she received a Master in Public Policy. While at the Kennedy School, Usha was a Belfer Center student fellow, working as a research assistant to Prof. Fredrik Logevall and the Belfer Center Cyber Project. Her paper “Revitalizing NATO: A Role for the U.S. Congress” was the co-winner of the Robert Belfer Award for Best Policy Analysis Exercise in International and Global Affairs. Usha is the creator and host of the War on the Rocks podcast series “A Most Terrible Weapon.” Prior to graduate school, Usha was managing editor of War on the Rocks, and has also been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost. She started her career as a Herbert Scoville, Jr. Peace Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation. Usha graduated magna cum laude from Columbia University, where she majored in political science and history; "Revitalizing NATO - A Role for the U.S. Congress"; Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School; Published: 9-2021; Accessed: 6-24-2022; https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf; KL]

Congress’ defense of NATO against the Trump administration’s efforts to undermine the alliance illustrates the direct and indirect ways in which lawmakers can push back against the executive-branch. Congress inserted language in the National Defense Authorization Act to block withdrawal of U.S. troops from Germany, while the House passed a resolution prohibiting the use of U.S. funds to withdraw from NATO. In a highly symbolic move, Congress invited NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg to address the legislature.50 In addition, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi led a delegation to the Munich Security Conference, a prominent transatlantic policy conference, where members emphasized Congress’ involvement in foreign policy to counteract allies’ fears about Trump’s behavior. 51 Congress’ active efforts during this period affirm the broader proposition of this report – that Congress does play a role in foreign policy issues like alliance management.52 The question is whether lawmakers will be willing to play that role in future administrations when alliances are no longer seen as being under threat.

“Bad cop” for allies. The function of critiquing undesirable actions extends to foreign nations. Congress frequently serves as a useful source of pressure on other countries, drawing attention to problematic behavior and opening the door for the executive branch to follow up with negotiations or other measures.

When it comes to NATO, Congress has played the “bad cop” most frequently in the area of burden-sharing. Members routinely put pressure on allies to increase their contributions to the alliance, which gives executive-branch negotiators political cover to make the same demand because they can claim Congress is tying their hands. NATO expert Stanley Sloan is worth quoting at length on the history of congressional involvement in burden-sharing:

From the very beginning, the congressional partner regularly raised questions about the persistent burden-sharing issue. This questioning began with the initial debate in the Senate on whether it should give its advice and consent to the Treaty. The administration of President Harry Truman reassured senators that the European allies would contribute to their own defense and that the United States would not end up carrying a disproportionate share of the burden. As the European states recovered from the devastation of World War II, some senators argued that the Europeans had become capable of defending themselves. Montana’s Senator Mike Mansfield (D) famously promoted resolutions from the mid-1960s into the early 1970s that sought to force administrations to begin withdrawing US forces from Europe. While US administrations—Democratic and Republican—sought to contain the financial burdens and to get the Europeans to compensate the United States for some of NATO’s costs, the established pattern persisted into the post– Cold War years. Over all these years, Congress did most of the complaining while successive presidents of both parties urged allies to do more but largely defended the alliance and its costs as necessary for US national interests [emphasis added]. 53

Interviewees with experience in the executive branch repeatedly told me that congressional “complaining” or “needling,” sometimes seen as unproductive grandstanding, is actually a useful way to pressure allies and get issues on the agenda.54 To be sure, congressional critiques can also cause headaches for the executive branch if they create diplomatic friction. Interviewees emphasized the need for useful congressional pressure that is coordinated with the executive and stops short of disrupting fragile bilateral relationships.

Spotlighting rights abuses abroad. Congress is similarly well-suited to draw attention to violations of human rights and other illiberal behavior in foreign countries. In addition to the reasons above, Congress has an advantage in this area because it interacts directly with issue-based advocacy groups, which frequently lobby members to take action on issues like arms sales and human rights.55

Members can target other countries’ bad behavior in a variety of ways. They may bring resolutions, circulate “Dear Colleague” letters, or condemn the behavior in floor statements or in the media. One of the most common tactics is also the most controversial: sanctions. The experts I interviewed were nearly unanimous in their agreement that Congress over-relies on sanctions. As American University’s Jordan Tama told me, “It tends to be a way for Congress to be able to demonstrate that it’s doing something without an issue without being particularly costly. You don’t have to spend money to impose sanctions, so there’s no need for appropriations.”56 Indeed, sanctions may have become a go-to tool precisely because they are one of the few things that are still easy for Congress to do in today’s climate.

Sanctions have proved especially frustrating in the case of Turkey, which is subject to U.S. sanctions due to its purchase of the S-400 missile system from Russia. Interviewees expressed concern that Congress would not be able to unwind the sanctions on Turkey even after it came into compliance with U.S. demands, and worried more generally that Congress had over-involved itself. 57 In this way, a congressional effort to punish bad behavior by an ally may have overstepped its bounds and crossed into the territory of undermining a delicate relationship.

In general, Congress’ strength lies in calling attention to bad behavior and getting it on the bilateral agenda – but then stepping aside to let diplomats negotiate with the problematic partner, a process that is often delicate. One former Senate staffer invoked the common saying that “Congress is a hammer, not a scalpel,”58 while a current staffer similarly described the role as that of a “sharpener.” “Our job,” this staffer argued, “is to take the plans and policies of the executive branch and improve them. That is where we can add the most value, especially in foreign policy.”59

Influencing the executive agenda and shaping the narrative: A third set of strengths has to do with Congress’ ability to put priorities on the executive branch’s agenda and generally shape the domestic and international narrative around particular issues.60 These strengths, which are closely related to the “calling out wrongdoing” idea, similarly stem from Congress’ status as the representative of the American people, which endows its priorities with a unique legitimacy.

Narrative-shaping through hearings and more: Congressional attention to a given foreign policy priority can significantly influence the debate over that issue at home and abroad. Interviewees who have worked in the executive branch and with NATO agreed that both actors pay close attention to what happens in Congress. As Fontaine and Schulman argue, “Congress can play a vital role in encouraging, convening, and organizing public and alternative sources of information.”61 For instance, they argue that congressional hearings can uncover new issues or new ways of thinking about old issues. 62 Nicholas Burns, former U.S. ambassador to NATO, told me that calling a hearing “shines a bright light on a big issue...It’s a convening power to ask members of the administration to appear before Congress and to engage in conversation and debate about the administration's policies.”63 As a 2018 Foreign Affairs article noted, “Hearings and investigations draw attention to neglected issues and can force administrations to rethink decisions. They can divert the executive branch from its priorities and focus the attention of the press.”64

The same applies to other non-legislative tools such as requests for briefings, resolutions, letters to the president and Cabinet officials, floor statements, and media interviews. 65 Even resolutions, far from serving a purely symbolic function, can frame the narrative and push the administration to care about something.66

Reporting requirements: Congress can also influence the executive branch’s agenda by requesting a report on a particular issue, such as the amount each NATO ally is spending on defense.67 The executive branch sometimes dismisses congressionally mandated reports as busy work and even a waste of taxpayer money68, but Hill staffers argued that reports force the administration to pay attention to an issue. 69 “The point is not to get the report,” one emphasized. “The point is to make a bunch of people think about it.”70

Informal authority, institutional memory, and longevity: Current and former staffers pointed out that the executive branch relies heavily on Congress because congressional staffers’ tenures last much longer than a presidential administration. Committee staff in particular have years of expertise and many relationships, which makes them an attractive source of consultation for administration officials as well as members of foreign governments.71 One staffer said that administration officials have two additional incentives (beyond simply getting congressional support for a policy) to build strong consultative relationships with Hill staffers: First, these relationships can help ensure that a policy retains support after that particular administration leaves office, since congressional staffers (especially committee staffers) stay for a long time. Second, relationships on the Hill expand administration staffers’ professional networks for future job searches. 72

The point about durability is particularly important for NATO, since allies are worried that America may again elect a president with Trump-like views on alliances. The executive branch will be eager to secure congressional buy-in on its transatlantic policy to make clear that the policy will not easily be reversed under future administrations. 73

These findings are consistent with James Curry’s research, which finds that committee leaders and committee staff have become more influential sources of expertise as the traditional legislative process has eroded.74 Committee staffers can use their influence and longevity as a source of influence with the executive branch.

Relationships abroad: Closely related, members of Congress and congressional staff have strong relationships with representatives of foreign governments. One staffer argued that congressional relationships with foreign dignitaries are underused and that behind-thescenes diplomacy with members of Congress can have an important impact.75 Foreign dignitaries are often eager to engage with members of Congress, which is a source of legislative strength.76 Again, however, there’s a balance to be struck, as interviewees emphasized that the executive branch should retain the lead in diplomatic negotiations.

Travel: An important part of congressional relationships with foreign counterparts is travel. Many experts argued that members of Congress can have a significant impact by traveling to a NATO-related location and meeting with stakeholders. 77 Lawmakers sometimes travel with congressional delegations (CODELs) to places like NATO headquarters in Brussels and the Munich Security Conference. CODELs offer a chance to communicate American priorities to foreign governments, including wielding threats of punitive action if a country is seen as not cooperating.78 To be sure, it’s difficult to get members on these trips, in part because traveling to seemingly glamorous places like Europe may come off to constituents as spending taxpayer dollars on a luxurious getaway.79 More generally, NATO is low on the list of places that are worth members’ limited time. Still, members should note that travel offers a way to have a big impact, particularly on foreign governments.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.