Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Oversight ensures intel is used democratically

Kibbe 10 [Jennifer Kibbe, Associate Professor of Government at Franklin & Marshall College; “Congressional Oversight of Intelligence: Is the Solution Part of the Problem?”; March 10, 2010; DOA: 6/24/22; https://doi.org/10.1080/02684521003588104; Lowell- ES]

Despite the difficulty involved, however, something must be done. The last seven years have shown that intelligence is more crucial than ever to national security, but as the executive branch and the intelligence community try to maximize the utility of intelligence in meeting national security needs, it is imperative that the congressional overseers meet their obligations as well. The importance of legislative oversight of the executive branch in general has long been recognized. ‘Quite as important as legislation’, noted Woodrow Wilson, ‘is vigilant oversight of administration’.3 In the intelligence arena, however, congressional oversight is at an added premium. The first, most obvious reason is the inherent secrecy of the subject. In other areas, such as the environment or banking, the media plays a valuable role in helping Congress monitor the actions of the federal government on behalf of the public. In the largely classified world of intelligence, in all but a few exceptional cases, the media is effectively precluded from playing that supporting role, thus enhancing the importance of legislative oversight.

A second less recognized but equally important reason that oversight is so critical to the intelligence enterprise is that, because ‘ . . . the intelligence community is constrained in its ability to convince the American public that it can be trusted and deserves their support’, Congress also plays an important role in explaining and representing the intelligence community to the public.4

A third reason legislative oversight is so important is that, done well, it helps to improve the intelligence product, whether that means collection, analysis or covert action. When administration and intelligence officials know that they will have to explain a funding choice or particular operation to Congress, it has the effect of adding a layer to their own internal vetting. This article explains the major problems with the congressional oversight system, analyzes why it is so hard to reform, and examines what constructive steps might be taken to improve the situation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.