Oversight is necessary for tech policies to succeed
Davies 09 [J. Clarence (Terry) Davies is a Senior Advisor to the Project on Emerging Nanotechnologies, and Senior Fellow at Resources for the Future. Dr. Davies, a senior advisor to the nanotechnology project and a senior fellow at Resources for the Future, is one of the foremost authorities on environmental research and policy. He helped pioneer the related fields of risk assessment, risk management, and risk communication, and his work has advanced our understanding of cross-media pollution, the tendency of pollutants to move across boundaries, from air to water to land, revealing shortcomings in the legal and regulatory framework. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.359.8129&rep=rep1&type=pdf]//LP
An adequate oversight system must, at a minimum, be able to assess potential risks from a technology, minimize the chances that the risk will occur and maintain surveillance to identify risks that do occur. It should perform these functions while minimizing adverse impacts on technological innovation or market functions and while giving the public confidence that the system is effective and that it allows public opinion to be heard. The starting point for any oversight system is the ability to identify the risks that a technology may pose and to assess the likelihood and the magnitude of such risks. Such an assessment requires both general scientific knowledge and data about each specific technology and product. The relationship between science and data is complex. Without an adequate scientific framework there is no way to know what data to collect. For example, which aspects of a nanomaterial are most relevant in determining its toxicity? As noted above, more than a dozen characteristics have been suggested even for relatively simple nanomaterials. What will be needed in addition with more complex active nanotechnologies? Without better scientific knowledge we do not know what data to collect and examine. On the other hand, progress in developing the necessary scientific knowledge often depends on having a lot of data on specific materials. Only by having such data can we develop and test the needed scientific hypotheses. Oversight cannot directly improve scientific knowledge. It can, however, make clear the need for such knowledge, frame the questions that need to be answered and, through requirements imposed on manufacturers, generate the data needed by scientists. How to apply adequate oversight when the state of scientific knowledge is not adequate is one of the basic dilemmas in developing and applying 21st-century oversight mechanisms. In most cases, the science related to risk will be primitive and uncertain, but the potential risks will be serious enough so that lack of oversight will not be an acceptable option. Once information about the potential risks of a new material or product has been obtained, an adequate oversight system must be able to impose requirements that prevent adverse effects from occurring or at least minimize the risks from the new product. This can be done in a variety of ways. Restrictions may be put on the product as a condition for allowing it to be marketed. Standards may be established to prevent worker or environmental exposure while the product is being manufactured, transported, stored, used or disposed of. Restrictions or requirements may be imposed on the product after it has been marketed, or the manufacturer may be required to withdraw the product from the market altogether. Additional steps can be taken to encourage green design and pollution prevention. Because of the complexity of new technologies and the rapid pace of invention and adoption, the science will probably be inadequate to fully identify all the risks a new material or product will pose. For this reason, even more than in the past, it will be necessary to establish requirements and systems for identifying adverse effects of a product after it is in commercial use. A high degree of international cooperation will be necessary for such systems to work effectively. These oversight requirements should be applied with a constant awareness of the need to encourage technological innovation and economic growth. The “cowboy ideology” that views regulation as antithetical to free markets has proven to be false in sector after sector. Productive markets require effective regulation. However, there is an undeniable tension between the two. It is unlikely that government agencies will improve their efficiency, speed and expertise sufficiently to keep pace with technological innovation. To avoid setting up large obstacles to that innovation, oversight mechanisms will have to rely more on manufacturers to assess and control risks. At the same time, oversight will have to be structured to assure that manufacturers know what information is needed, collect the information in a reliable way and do not abuse their responsibility.