Congressional oversight is vital to effective foreign policy---empirics
ROSS 18 [Tommy Ross is a senior associate at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. He served as Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Security Cooperation at the Pentagon and was the senior defense and intelligence adviser to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid. He has also held other senior positions in the House and Senate. https://warontherocks.com/2018/06/at-a-crossroads-part-iii-reasserting-congress-oversight-role-in-foreign-policy/]//LP
Congressional oversight of foreign policy hasn’t always been this way. A far cry from today’s marginalized and demoralized bodies, Congress’ foreign affairs committees once stood side-by-side with the presidency at the center of America’s foreign policymaking. One need only look at Henry Cabot Lodge’s famous campaign leading to the Senate’s 1919 rejection of the Treaty of Versailles and the League of Nations, on the grounds that the Senate had not been adequately consulted, to see the impact of aggressive congressional oversight of foreign policy. Or consider the heady era of the mid-20th century, when Congress faced a new international landscape shaped by two world wars and the emergence of the Cold War and mutually assured destruction. Far from shrinking from these responsibilities, Congress undertook a historic effort to write — and then re-write — the rules of the road for foreign policy. In 1951, lawmakers replaced the Marshall Plan with the Mutual Security Act, then overtook that legislation ten years later with the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, which remains the foundational statute governing U.S. aid overseas. Congress enacted the War Powers Act in 1973 and, in 1976, passed the landmark Arms Export Control Act. As congressional oversight of foreign policy gained strength during the Vietnam War, scholar Linda Fowler notes that “the Senate Foreign Relations Committee was at the vanguard of the resurgence of Congress in international affairs,” citing the panel’s establishment of a special investigative subcommittee to examine executive branch foreign policies. That subcommittee, chaired by Sen. Stewart Symington, identified a range of executive branch abuses, uncovered expansive military operations whose existence or scope had been previously undisclosed, and paved the way for the Church Committee and, ultimately, establishment of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence. It also defined for Congress a role of comprehensive, sustained oversight of U.S. foreign activities, presence, and commitments. These debates were messy, complex, and occasionally partisan, but the results were substantial. However, the 1980s and 90s saw the beginning of a dramatic decline in congressional engagement — and effectiveness — in conducting foreign policy oversight. Fowler’s work documents the decrease in oversight hearings conducted by both the Foreign Relations and Armed Services Committees in the Senate, beginning in the 1990s. Likewise, Congress’ ability to enact legislation setting out the priorities, expectations, and authorities of the State Department crumbled. This final installment in a three-part series (part I addressed defense oversight and part II examined intelligence) about congressional national security oversight argues regular State Department authorization bills — and their focus on bureaucratic and programmatic management — are essential to effective oversight. And effective oversight in this arena has never been more urgently needed: Draconian cuts to both State and the U.S. Agency for International Development proposed in the Trump administration’s 2018 and 2019 budgets present America’s foreign policy establishment with a colossal crisis. Regardless of the outcome of November’s mid-term elections, both the House and Senate foreign affairs committees will see new leadership. These new leaders will have an opportunity to set their committees on a path to reestablish their place at the center of foreign policymaking. Doing so will require a smart strategy for regaining the committees’ capacity to legislate, a renewed focus on structural and management issues impacting the foreign policy enterprise, investment in the committees’ own oversight capacity, and attention to long-simmering cross-committee jurisdictional challenges. Oversight is a profound responsibility, deeply embedded in the Constitution’s grant of powers to the Legislative Branch. Effective oversight means a serious, objective, and persistent examination of whether the Executive Branch is making use of the taxpayer resources entrusted to it in ways that are effective, efficient, accountable, and in accordance with law and congressional direction. It also means — critically, in this era of increasingly sophisticated threats and responses — helping to educate the public. To achieve both goals, it must be conducted with balance, bipartisanship, and restraint against tendencies to pursue political vendettas.