Their ev is about small arms – complicated weaponry solves their offense
Yousif 22 – Elias Yousif is a Research Analyst with the Stimson Center’s Conventional Defense Program. His research focuses on the global arms trade and arms control, issues related to remote warfare and use of force, and international security cooperation and child soldiers prevention. (Elias Yousif, "Under Caution: Assessing Arms Transfer Risk in Ukraine," Stimson Center, 3-7-2022, https://www.stimson.org/2022/under-caution-assessing-arms-transfer-risk-in-ukraine/, Accessed 6-25-2022, LASA-SC)
Of course, there is a tremendous difference between small arms that have been handed out to civilians as compared to more sophisticated weaponry provided to government forces. But the risks are real and the potential negative legacy of arms transfers need to be acknowledged and addressed. We’ve seen time and time again how arms aimed at aiding an ally in one conflict have found their way to the frontlines of unforeseen battlefields, often in the hands of groups at odds with U.S. interests or those of civilians. This is especially true for small arms and light weapons, which hold some of the highest risks of loss, diversion into the illicit market, or misuse. From Afghanistan to Iraq to Colombia, well-intentioned transfers have a habit of outliving their political contexts, and risk fueling new conflicts, being captured by illicit groups, or contributing to enduring ecosystems of insecurity. In the end, it may well be the case that a thoughtful, and dispassionate assessment of the risks and rewards of arms transfers to Ukraine offers a strategically sound case for sending more weapons to combat the Russian invasion. But the risks of these arms transfers must be considered, and, where possible, mitigated. Any weapons transfers – particularly small arms and light weapons – need to have appropriate end-use monitoring mechanisms attached. Moreover, the conduct of use stipulations must also be put in place to ensure that these weapons are not used indiscriminately or harm civilians. While the defense of Ukraine is paramount, no one is better off when arms flow with disregard for the real risks associated with arms transfers. The people of Ukraine deserve assistance, and it is the responsibility of those making arms transfer decisions to ensure that assistance is thoughtful, responsible, and strategically sound in the short and long term.