Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

This is structured through the affects of neoliberalism, by which the critical pedagogies of militarism operate through the mundane interactions with academia, resolvable only through critical, counter-conduct performances

Zembylas 19 [Michalinos Zembylas (2019): The affective dimension of everyday resistance: implications for critical pedagogy in engaging with neoliberalism’s educational impact, Critical Studies in Education, DOI: 10.1080/17508487.2019.1617180] // jz// -ekh-]

My analysis has shown that whatever form neoliberalism is taken to be in schools and universities, the neoliberal present has important affective implications. The affective economies of neoliberalism that are produced in schools and universities create particular ‘capacities to affect and be affected’ for teachers and students alike. It is thus extremely important to develop methodological and theoretical tools that critically trace the capacities of teachers and students for affecting and being affected in their engagements and negotiations with neoliberal education, and specifically how these capacities are normalized, embodied or enable alternative counter-practices (Zembylas, 2018b). Hence, what is required is a continued critical engagement with neoliberalism’s educational impact in ways that take into consideration the affective potentialities of resistance. Considering the affective potentialities of resistance in critical pedagogy can be the starting point for alternatives visions of educational policies and practices that challenge forms of neoliberal education. I would argue, then, that what is needed in the study of resistance in critical pedagogy is what Thrift (2008) calls a micro-biopolitical approach (Thrift, 2008) which understands the complexities and ambivalences of neoliberal affects and norms that operate at the mundane, ordinary, and everyday level in schools and universities and the consequences that are produced (Zembylas, 2018b). This micro-biopolitical approach on conceptualizing resistance in critical pedagogy is valuable not only because it pays attention to the affective consequences of mechanisms and techniques of neoliberal education in schools and universities, but also because it invokes what Braidotti (2013) terms ‘affirmative critique’ (see also Staunæs, 2016). An affirmative critique in critical pedagogy, for example, is the sort of critical engagement with ideas 10 M. ZEMBYLAS and things that creates affective spaces for alternative counter-conduct practices against neoliberal education. In other words, recognizing the affective dimension of resistance in critical pedagogy creates openings for an affirmative critique that has the potential to transform teachers’ and students’ capacities to affect and be affected. In considering the approach I am suggesting here to affect and resistance in critical pedagogy, one can indeed raise several questions and concerns such as: How may critical pedagogy itself function as an ‘apparatus of power’ (Anderson, 2014) which uses affect to mobilize resistance towards certain ideologies or structures such as neoliberalism? How are these mobilizations of resistance connected to broader collective conditions and processes of resisting certain ideologies or structures at the macro-political level? How do teachers’ and students’ practices and bodily capacities reproduce or enrich certain mobilizations of resistance through their encounters? How can those practices and bodily capacities be reproductive, adaptive or resistant, whether intentionally or not? (e.g. see McKenzie, 2017). There are no definitive answers to these questions, but they must be posed to show the complexities and ambivalences emerging from attempts to link affect and resistance in critical pedagogy. Hence, I would argue that any viable theorization of resistance in critical pedagogy must not be limited to ‘conventional’ understandings of resistance but must emphasize how affects condition the ways neoliberalism emerges, circulate and are transformed by forms of resistance waged by teachers and students. Greater acknowledgment of the ways in which schools and universities play a fundamental role in the affective conduct of individuals, encouraging and directing the self-perceptions, economic behavior and socio-political actions of students, citizens, and workers (Odysseos & Pal, 2018) will renew theorization of resistance in critical pedagogy in two ways. First, by gesturing toward the particular ways in which affects come to have force and socio-political significance, critical pedagogy disconnects resistance from a psychologized perspective or a perspective that defines resistance in dualistic terms as a matter of either human agency or social structure. This would mean, for instance, recognizing that resistance is not a set of individualized actions but rather it is very much embedded in the affective infrastructures of neoliberal education. To create renewed affective relations and assemblages as counter-conduct in schools and universities, then, would essentially mean to invent new affective practices that instigate empowerment and resistance against the various manifestations of neoliberal education. As Alldred and Fox (2017) conclude: It is therefore more accurate to see power and resistance as dual fluxes that permeate all assemblages, a shifting balance that is never finally settled. Defining a certain affect as an assertion of power or an effort at resistance is less important than assessing the capacities that these affects produce. (p. 1171) For example, it is argued that ‘affective solidarity’ is necessary for a sustainable politics of transformation (Hemmings, 2012). Hemmings proposes an approach that moves away from rooting transformation in politics of identity and towards modes of engagement that start from the affective dissonance experience can produce. Although affective dissonance with the experience of neoliberalism’s educational impact, for instance, cannot guarantee a resistant mode, ‘that sense of dissonance might become a sense of injustice and then a desire to rectify that’ (Hemmings, 2012, CRITICAL STUDIES IN EDUCATION 11 p. 157). The recognition of affective dissonance as the point of departure for a possible affective solidarity among teachers and student highlights that affective dissonance with neoliberalism’s educational impact may be a productive basis from which to seek solidarity with others – not based on a shared identity or ideology, but on feeling the desire for transforming the injustices inflicted by neoliberal policies and practices. Second, the recognition of the affective dimension of resistance in critical pedagogy helps us understand the affective present in and beyond schools and universities as a series of processes and practices in ‘the everyday’ in which the focus is on the actions that are mobilized to produce something rather than on their representations or what they supposedly mean. By examining the consequences of affects at the micropolitical level, resistance can be understood in terms of the ways actions produce capacities to affect and be affected, that is, ‘in terms of the forces circulating in assemblage and the consequent capacities that are produced in assembled relations, including human bodies and subjectivities’ (Alldred & Fox, 2017, p. 1171). Calling upon theoretical insights in critical pedagogy that recognize and examine the affective dimension of everyday resistance is likely to challenge the ‘invisible’ infrastructures of neoliberal education in schools and universities. All in all, the call for a critical pedagogy to acknowledge the affective dimension of resistance marks an important and necessary moment that allows critical pedagogy to be further enriched in attempts to address the challenges faced by teachers and students in neoliberal education. Schools and universities are at a critical juncture whether and how they will be able to develop pedagogies and ideas that neither return to an idealized, pre-neoliberal past, nor expect a sudden revolution but instead resist against the self-formations involved by neoliberalism (Odysseos & Pal, 2018). What I have offered here is an attempt to illuminate the affective dimension of resistance and its implications for critical pedagogy through theoretical insights that enhance individual and collective capacity for counter-conduct in neoliberal contexts. Being attentive to the complexities and potential ambivalences in teachers’ and students’ forms of resistance enhances our analysis of how critical pedagogy more broadly, and schools and universities more specifically, are themselves implicated in transformations of neoliberal education (Odysseos & Pal, 2018).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.