UN has opened a path for ethical AI standards – the plan infringes on UN authority
Garcia, 20 (Eugenio V. Garcia, PhD in international relations, senior adviser on peace and security, humanitarian and legal affairs of the UN, 12-12-2020, " Multilateralism and Artificial Intelligence: What Role for the United Nations?," SSRN, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3779866, LASA-CSK)
The UN Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) has been promoting a humanistic approach on ethics, policy, and capacity-building in response to emerging challenges related to AI, including philosophical reflections on what it means to be human in the face of disruptive technologies. Playing a key role in this regard, the World Commission on the Ethics of Scientific Knowledge and Technology (COMEST), an advisory body created in 1998 to give policy advice for decision-makers, pioneered workshops and roundtables leading up to the publication of a report on robotics ethics, with a view to positioning UNESCO as a valuable instrument for intellectual exchanges on this matter. 44 Furthermore, the first International Research Centre of Artificial Intelligence (IRCAI), under the auspices of UNESCO, shall have its seat in Slovenia, aiming to provide a coordination point, funding route, and exploitation accelerator for approaches to the SDGs that make use of AI.45 More recently, an Ad Hoc Expert Group of 24 members was tasked by UNESCO to produce, in a two-year process, the first draft of a global standard-setting instrument on ethics of AI. In a preliminary study released in July 2019, it was stressed that AI is not confined to a tangible location, which makes regulation of AI technology more challenging nationally and internationally. Due to their transnational character, durable solutions need to be found at the global level. A normative instrument on the ethics of AI should serve as a means of mainstreaming universal values into AI systems, which must be compatible with internationally agreed human rights and standards, and be aligned to a human-centred vision.46 Some experts believe that UNESCO’s contribution, within its mandate, could be complementary to other initiatives under way, such as by the OECD, but with a focus upon aspects that are generally neglected: culture, education, science, and communication. The definitive format of this normative document (either a declaration, recommendation, or a convention to be approved by Member States) will be decided by UNESCO’s General Conference by the end of 2021. However, a non-binding recommendation on basic principles has been considered so far more flexible and better suited to the complexity of the ethical questions raised by AI. Following internal consultations and virtual meetings, the Ad Hoc Expert Group made available online, in May 2020, a “zero draft” of its outcome document to invite commentaries by the public. In addition to values and principles drawn from or inspired by the consensus achieved in the 80+ published frameworks related to AI ethics, areas of policy action were given special attention: promoting diversity and inclusiveness; addressing labour market changes and the social, economic, cultural, and environmental impact of AI; fostering education, awareness, international cooperation, governance mechanisms, and AI ethics research and development; and ensuring trustworthiness of AI systems, responsibility, accountability, and privacy.47 The experts of the Group are especially worried about the need for a multidisciplinary, holistic approach, with due regard to human rights. They mostly agree that the UN has a significant role to play, akin to a “beacon,” empowering people and increasing participation by all sectors of society. 48 Also important, the UN Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICRI) established in 2017 a Centre for Artificial Intelligence and Robotics in The Hague, with the aim of disseminating information, undertaking training activities, and promoting public awareness. Directed by Irakli Beridze, the Centre has been active in cybercrime, law enforcement (in partnership with Interpol), criminal justice, counterterrorism, and malicious use of AI from the perspective of its mandate. In 2018, the website “AI & Global Governance” of the Centre for Policy Research of the United Nations University (UNU) began to publish online crossdisciplinary insights and “inform existing debates from the lens of multilateralism,” as a tool for Member States, multilateral agencies, funds, programs, and other partners.49 Other noteworthy activities include the following: research on AI-related technologies conducted by the UN Institute for Disarmament Research (UNIDIR); the UN Innovation Network, connecting a collaborative community within the UN system; the Innovation Cell of the UN Department of Political and Peacebuilding Affairs (DPPA), aimed at incubating and leveraging use cases in peace and security; as well as a myriad of projects developed by UN agencies to apply AI in their daily practice in the field.5