Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UN biotech regulation wrecks developing countries widening the tech gap

Miller, 96 (Henry I. Miller, Robert Wesson Fellow of scientific philosophy & public policy, Hoover Institution Consulting Professor at the Institute for International Studies at Stanford University, 7-1-1996, "Biotechnology and the UN: New challenges, new failures," Nature, https://www.nature.com/articles/nbt0796-831, LASA-CSK)

The overregulation of technology, though damaging to industrialized countries, is particularly devastating to developing countries because it acts as yet another, and formidable entry barrier to R&D. Thus, the UN's design's on biotechnology are likely to increase further the income gap between the "have" and "have not" nations, which more than doubled between 1960 and 1991. Poorly crafted regulatory proposals constitute a lose-lose proposition for the developing world. Virtually every field trial of every new biotechnology derived variant of rice, cassava, maize, wheat, sweet potato, or other plant would require an environmental assessment. These schemes would divert scarce resources to the regulation of activities that are largely of negligible risk, send inaccurate messages about risk to the public and to politicians, and impose a "tax" on innovation which is based on the excessively regulated techniques. These approaches also make new products artificially expensive to use, test, and produce: New crop plant varieties must be adapted to local conditions and the expense of testing them would become prohibitive. Thus, unnecessary case by case 834 review would diminish the degree and speed of technology diffusion to the developing world, developing countries would be prevented from participating in worldwide technological trends, and the technology gap that already exists between the industrialized and developing countries would widen further. There are bitter ironies in the demand that the developing world adopt unscientific, technique-based and anti-innovative regulatory approaches. First, the clamor usually originates from regulators or activists in industrialized countries who both regard Third-world regulation as an opportunity to validate their minority view of genetic engineering as manifesting unique risks and see prospects for becoming players on a larger stage. Second, such policies preferentially undermine research on precisely the kinds of low-value-added but important products that are most needed in developing countries- safer and more nutritious foods, improved bioremediation agents, and alternatives to chemical pesticides and fertilizers. At the same time, these poorly conceived policies exact a high cost, they are unlikely to afford any increment in environmental or public health protection

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.