Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

IPR trades off with effective green technology- that’s key to solve climate change.

Jinkai Lee 20, Center for Energy, Environment and Economy Research, Zhengzhou University, “DOES INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS PROTECTION CONSTITUTE A BARRIER TO RENEWABLE ENERGY? AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS”, Cambridge University Press: National Institute Economic Review , Volume 251 , February 2020 , pp. R37 - R46, 2-5-2020, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/national-institute-economic-review/article/abs/does-intellectual-property-rights-protection-constitute-a-barrier-to-renewable-energy-an-econometric-analysis/4A4BE835821D05BFCC2BCD055A006544)/maze

The debates on the impact of intellectual property rights has been extended to the current discussion on climate change mitigation. Mass development, transfer and adoption of climate-friendly technologies and renewable energy has been recognised as essential to mitigating climate change within the required timeframe (Copenhagen Economics, 2009). The share of renewable energy in global energy use rose from 17 per cent in 1990 to 18 per cent in 2015 (figure 1), but a large proportion of this renewable energy is from traditional biomass. Considerable efforts are required to develop and adopt key technologies such as solar and wind. However, given the differences in resource endowment, economic development level and technological advancement among countries, there is need for technology and know-how transfer from technologically-advanced countries to technologically lagging countries (Ockwell et al., 2010). Technology transfer is crucial given the asymmetry in research and development expenditure between developed and developing countries as shown in figure 2. According to Correa (2013), 90 per cent of technological development is concentrated in the United States, European Union, Japan and China; and 80 per cent of all patented innovations in carbon capture, geothermal, solar PV and wind energy technologies are owned by companies from France, Germany, Japan, South Korea, United Kingdom and the United States. The TRIPS Agreement acknowledges these differences by taking into consideration “the developmental and technological objectives” of its members, while also recognising the special needs of its least-developed country (LDC) members (preamble TRIPS Agreement). The TRIPS Agreement grants their least developed country members more flexibility in the implementation of their obligation under TRIPS in order to help them achieve a strong technological base. This flexibility is not available to non-members of least developing countries. The issue of intellectual property rights is a major point of discussion in innovation and technology transfer, including clean energy technology innovation and transfer. According to Latif (2012, 2013), technology transfer and innovation are key issues in the Rio+20 United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development discussions, but IPR which are related to them are barely mentioned. Nonetheless, there has been considerable policy debate over the scope and role of IPR protection with respect to clean energy and climate mitigation technologies. Some studies argue that IPR protection serves as an incentive to innovate and transfer clean energy technologies, while others claim that IPR protection would lead to higher costs of clean technology and hinder developing countries’ access because of the exclusive rights of the patent holder (ICTSD, 2008; Kapur, 2011). Although the TRIPS Agreement provides for exceptions to the exclusive right of patent holders under its Article 30, these exceptions apply collectively and are limited in nature. The Agreement also addresses the abuse of intellectual property rights by its holders, by providing that appropriate steps could be taken where IPR would unreasonably restrain trade or affect technology transfer (Article 8(2) TRIPS Agreement) The studies that examine the effect of IPR on climate change and clean energy technology have mixed conclusions (Hascic et al., 2010; UNEP, et al., 2010), partly because of inadequate data, different data sources and different methodologies. The analysis of the impact of IPR protection on clean technology innovation and transfer is a relatively young field of research. The majority of studies approach the subject mainly from theoretical, legal and case studies perspectives (Kapur, 2011; IRENA, 2012; Copenhagen Economics, 2009). To date, the literature lacks a comprehensive empirical investigation of the impact of IPR protection on renewable energy using econometric methods. This study makes an important contribution to the literature on renewable energy development. While most studies on renewable energy development and adoption have focused extensively on the technical and economic aspects, little is known about the legal and institutional frameworks that may influence renewable energy development. This study explores legal and institutional frameworks with respect to renewable energy and focuses specifically on IPR protection. While previous studies on the subject have developed theoretical or case study approaches, this study extends the IPR-renewable energy literature by taking advantage of novel panel data on the degree of IPR protection – the GinartePark Index – and adopting fixed effect panel regression techniques. This broadens the existing literature by using econometrics techniques to analyse the effect of intellectual property rights protection on climate-related technologies/renewable energy use. The two main research questions in the study are as follows: does IPR protection hinder renewable energy development? Does reforming IPR systems have significant positive impacts on renewable energy development?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.