Imposing IPR hampers innovation and creates monopolies
Emrah Karakilic 19, holds a PhD in sociology from Goldsmiths, University of London and 20. He finished his PhD in 2016 with a thesis entitled The Limits of Cognitive Capitalism., “Rethinking intellectual property rights in the cognitive and digital age of capitalism: An autonomist Marxist reading”, Technological Forecasting and Social Change Volume 147, October 2019, Pages 1-9, 7-5-2019, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040162518316275)/maze
From this perspective, the enclosure of the common should be considered a structural fetter on the development and growth of human beings. In particular, intellectual property rights act as forms of structural restraints for the expansion and development of productive forces. They block the qualities and capabilities, that is, the very human potentiality of wage-workers. They precisely interrupt the Foucauldian circuit in which l’homme produit l’homme (man produces man). In this regard, it is fair to state that by imposing IPR, capital prepares its own social crisis in terms of established capitalist relations of production Furthermore, the enclosure through IPR hinders the opportunities for innovation, profit-making, and growth. From the perspective of neoclassical economics, Boldrin and Levine (2002, 2010) challenge the ‘common argument [that] the presence of strong intellectual property rights spurs innovation leading to higher economic growth and increasing benefits for all’ (2002: 209). By drawing on quantitative models, they analyse the difference between property rights applied to material and immaterial goods and show that IPR constitute a monopoly, ‘intellectual monopoly’, ultimately hindering free market, competition, growth, and wealth. Again, from the perspective of neoclassical economics, Lerner examines the impact of IPR policy shifts in 60 nations over the past 150 years and finds a ‘lack of a positive impact of strengthening of patent protection on innovation’ (2009: 347), which is key for profit making and economic growth. Martin (1998) inquiries into the relationship between IPR and innovation from a different perspective. By using real-life cases, he demonstrates how big companies purchase someone else’s idea to inhibit other companies from transforming this idea to an innovative product and selling it on the market as a competitor of their product. Along the same lines, Baker, Jayadev and Stiglitz’s comprehensive - policy- paper argue that ‘the current global regime of intellectual property rights is inadequate in serving the purpose of development and welfare … both in developed and developing countries’ (2017: 7). They state that ‘if the knowledge economy and the economy of ideas is to be a key part of the global economy and if static societies are to be transformed into ‘learning societies’ that are key for growth and development, there is a desperate need to rethink the current regime [of IPR]’ (2017: 7). The famous Manchester Manifesto, signed by fifty international scholars from various disciplines, underlines ‘the significant drawbacks’ of IPR in ‘its effects on economic efficiency’ (2009:2), especially in terms of ‘reducing competition and allowing large companies to dominate markets’ (2009: 4).