Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Space col creates two scenarios for galactic destroying wars.

Kovic, 21 [Marko Kovic is the co-founder president of the nonprofit think tank ZIPAR, February 2021, accessed on 7-18-2022, Futures, "Risks of space colonization", https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0016328720301270]/ISEE

Achieving 5. Conflict risks Conflict risks are risks that are created by the prospect of hostile actors or powers in the context of space colonization. Conflict risks are in principle not unlike conflicts that humankind has experienced throughout its Earth-based history, but they are much greater in scope and severity. The four conflict risks I focus on are depicted in Fig. 5. I identify two catastrophic and two existential conflict risks. 5.1. Secession and independence conflicts Human habitats beyond Earth are likely to remain modest in the near-term future. The International Space Station, humankind's most advanced habitat-like project so far, can accommodate six people and is dependent on supplies from Earth. More ambitious colonization projects such as SpaceX's plan for Mars colonies typically envision what amounts to very small and simple camps (Musk, 2017). Managing such simple colonization projects should be doable legally and politically. With more mature colonies, however, the picture changes. Imagine, for example, the large, self-sustaining habitat on Venus that consists of 2 billion people that I mentioned in a thought experiment before. That hypothetical habitat is truly self-sustainable, in the sense that survival on Venus is not contingent in any way on resources or other kinds of support from Earth. If prior human history is an indication, it is conceivable that the Venusians could at some point seek to change their political status. They might want to no longer be governed by Earth or Earth-based governments and instead have sovereignty to autonomously and freely shape Venus’ future. They might, in other words, seek to secede and become an independent political entity. Given prior human history of secession and independence movements, such a claim to independence in the context of space colonization could easily result in violent conflict, and given the scale of the conflict parties in this scenario, the bloodshed could be much greater than all the wars that happened in Earth's history so far. Of course, we do not know what the dominant political philosophy of the future will be. Perhaps popular sovereignty and the wish for autonomy will be fully respected and met with unconditional, enlightened understanding. But that prospect is, at best, uncertain, and the prospect of catastrophic violent conflicts seems at least possible. 5.2. Reactionary colonies Let us assume for the sake of argument that the risks surrounding secessionist claims of extraterrestrial colonies will eventually have been overcome and that there are colonies which have attained a country-like or world-like status. What should the political systems in and the moral foundations of those independent colonies look like? Ideally, they would be at least as democratic, liberal, and generally morally progressive as the most democratic, liberal, and morally progressive countries today. More specifically, independent future colonies should have socio-political systems that do not lower average wellbeing or create (disproportionately) more suffering compared to their pre-existing peers such as Earth-based countries (Or whatever the dominant polity on Earth in that future might be.). However, there is no guarantee that independent colonies will meet that socio-political and moral bar. It is possible that there will be colonies whose socio-political systems are regressive in one way or another, marked by a relative moral decay compared to the baseline of political systems and moral frameworks. I call such potential undesirable entities reactionary colonies. The emergence of reactionary colonies might seem implausible given that humankind has, very roughly speaking, so far morally improved over the course of its history.9 But reactionary colonies might actually be a fairly common future development. If humankind at some point achieves the technological means for creating colonies with relative ease, creating new colonies might be an attractive option for extremist groups and beliefs. Imagine, for example, a religious group that believes in the fundamental superiority of men over women. Such a religious group might find it difficult adhering to their flawed moral principles in a pluralistic society. Opting for colonial exodus might represent an attractive opportunity for that religious group to build a society from scratch which is based on their notions of female inferiority and subjugation. The specific risk posed by reactionary colonies is twofold. Reactionary colonies would by definition lower the average happiness and wellbeing of humankind and create unnecessary, preventable suffering. Reactionary colonies would also represent potential rogue actors that could greatly amplify the aberration risks described in Section 4. For example, a dictatorial regime that causes great suffering to its population might be tempted to expand its dictatorial ideology to other colonies. Or that dictatorial colony could be led by a psychopathic elite that enjoys letting sentient simulations suffer as much as possible. The potential catastrophic and even existential multiplicator effects of reactionary colonies are, unfortunately, numerous. 5.3. Inter-colonial conflict Let us, again for the sake of the argument, assume that the previous problem of reactionary colonies has somehow been solved or avoided. Humankind has continued its path of technological development, and it has established several large clusters of colonies beyond the Solar system. Assuming that the fundamental problem of faster-than-light communication has not been solved yet, communication between the clusters lags months or even years, and physical contact between the clusters is rare since travel takes even longer than communication. The inevitable consequence of such a splintering of human civilization is that the different clusters of colonies would over time develop distinct cultures, and with only scarce and delayed contact with other clusters, a form of intergroup bias (Hewstone, Rubin, & Willis, 2002), the moral preference of one's own in-group over the out-group, would likely start to manifest. Over time, that us-versus-them heuristic could help create distinct and solidified social identities within the colony clusters (Hewstone & Greenland, 2000), and the beliefs and preferences about the outgroup colonies could become more overtly negative. Given enough time and great enough idiosyncratic development within each colony cluster, the cultural and moral connections between the colony clusters could further erode, and in their place, a sense of dread and looming danger about the others’ goals and preferences could take hold. Over a long enough period of time and great enough separation, the perception that other colonies are a threat could grow; so much so that taking preventative action and attacking and suppressing them might seem like the most rational course of action (Torres, 2018). Given the scale and the likely technological sophistication of future weapons systems, a violent conflict between advanced colonies and colony clusters would create suffering on an astronomical scale. Of course, the prospect of inter-colonial conflict is somewhat speculative (Cirkovic, 2019). But given humankind's past experiences, violent conflict clearly seems within the realm of the possible. That does not mean that such an almost immeasurably terrible conflict is unavoidable. Even the slightest probability of such conflict, however, means immense potential expected disvalue. 5.4. Hostile extraterrestrial intelligence We do not currently know whether intelligence, biological or artificial, exists beyond Earth, but it is not implausible to assume so. Coming into contact with as well as refraining from seeking contact with extraterrestrial intelligence poses risks, as I discuss in Section 4. In addition to these risks, extraterrestrial intelligence also poses a conflict risk: If an extraterrestrial intelligence has moral values that are sufficiently different form humankind's, the intelligence could de facto react to humankind and other forms of intelligence with hostility. At first glance, the prospect of a hostile extraterrestrial intelligence, be it biological or artificial, might seem farfetched. Isn’t some baseline of altruistic moral behavior to be expected of any kind of intelligence? We might intuitively associate intelligence with prosocial behavior of one kind or the other, but from an evolutionary perspective, greater intelligence is not necessarily correlated with prosocial and altruistic behavior towards other species (Raybeck, 2014). Intelligence is the generalized capability for achieving goals, regardless of moral underpinnings and considerations. After all, that is why artificial intelligence as superintelligence is an existential risk today: Superintelligence is a threat precisely because it is much more intelligent than humans but lacks any inherent sense of human preferences and moral values. Hostile extraterrestrial intelligence is a serious risk even if such intelligence is exceedingly rare in the universe. The mere possibility of hostile intelligence could result in something like a “Dark Forest” (Yu, 2015) game theoretic configuration. If benevolent biological or artificial intelligence is aware of the possibility of hostile alien intelligence, the best course of action is silence (If there might be hostile alien intelligence, best not to be noticed.). In addition, preventative action could also be a rational choice: If an alien intelligence — such as our human civilization — is being observed gradually expanding beyond our home planet, a risk averse intelligence, even one that is benevolent in principle, might find it prudent to eliminate that civilization; be it because the civilization in question might become hostile or because it might, through folly or ineptitude, draw unwanted attention to oneself. The mere possibility of fundamentally hostile intelligence could, in that sense, be enough to fuel a silent astronomical war.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.