Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US regulatory policy causes Chinese tit for tat retaliation which causes divergence.

Angela Zhang 21 an associate professor at the Faculty of Law in the University of Hong Kong. An expert in Chinese law,, “Chapter 5: Weaponizing Antitrust During Sino-US Tech War”, Chinese Antitrust Exceptionalism: How The Rise of China Challenges Global Regulation Oxford Scholarship Online: July 2021, https://global.oup.com/academic/product/chinese-antitrust-exceptionalism-9780198826569?cc=us&lang=en&)/maze

In response to US hostility, China has chosen to retaliate tit- for- tat. Such a strategy simultaneously consists of a promise and a threat: if the United States does nothing, then neither will China; conversely, if the United States attacks, so will China. One of the most famous examples of this strategy is the ‘liveand- let- live’ system that emerged during the trench warfare in the First World War.46 There, it was observed that cooperation is possible even amongst antagonists. Soldiers on the frontline defied orders from their higher command and refrained from shooting at the enemy as long as their opponents reciprocated. To deter America’s aggressive strategy of stifling Chinese leading technology companies, China has a few regulatory tools at its disposal. One of them is the AML which has emerged as a powerful economic weapon allowing the Chinese authority to exercise extraterritorial jurisdiction over foreign multinationals. The coercive capacity of the AML is expected to increase, given that a pending amendment to its powers would enhance its punitive capacities.

2.1 The Folk Theorem To illustrate China’s tit- for- tat strategy, consider the following hypothetical game between the United States and China.47 In this game, the United States makes the first move, and it must decide whether it will maintain the status quo of accommodating the rise of China or take a more aggressive stance in order to deter China from acting in a way that would harm US interests. In this hypothetical game, if the United States keeps to the status quo, both countries will receive the same payoff score of 10. However, if the United States takes an aggressive approach, it will receive a score of 15 and China will obtain a score of 1. China must then decide whether to punish the United States, which will harm both itself and the United States. If China chooses to punish the United States, then both countries gain nothing. While the cooperative outcome yields the highest joint payoffs for the two countries, this equilibrium cannot be achieved in a one- shot game. If the game is only played once, then the United States’ dominant strategy will be one of aggression in which it will receive the largest advantage. In this scenario, United States will obtain the maximum payoff of 15. China will not be content but it is better off acquiescing and collecting a payoff of 1 instead of being left with zero gain. However, in reality, the United States and China are repeatedly and continuously interacting with each other in this relationship. Given that this game involves an infinite number of interactions, China will opt for a different strategy to fulfil its objectives. It will choose to punish the United States, in which case the United States will obtain nothing. In anticipation of being punished by China, the United States will modify its strategy to tolerate China’s rise, as a result of which China will acquiesce, achieving a payoff of 10 for both players. The key to maintaining this equilibrium is the implicit threat of punishment, and peace is only possible if China has the capacity to retaliate against any US aggression. This logic applied during the Cold War. In his Nobel Peace Prize lecture, Robert Aumann said: ‘In the long years of the cold war between the US and the Soviet Union, what prevented “hot” war was that bombers carrying nuclear weapons were in the air 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Disarming would have led to a war.’48

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.