Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Making a generalized statement about whether psychoanalysis fails or succeeds fails - different ways to psychoanalyze

Ahmad & Nayah, 2019 (Mushtaq, assistant English professor at the Imperial College of Business Studies. Sidra, researcher at Riphah International University. “Psychoanalysis as a method of reading texts and practices: a descriptive study” Asian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities. Vol. 8(1). February 2019. http://www.ajssh.leena-luna.co.jp/AJSSHPDFs/Vol.8(1)/AJSSH2019(8.1-06).pdf /// MF)

There are at least two ways that Freudian psychoanalysis can be used as a method to analyze texts.

The first approach is author-centered, treating the text as the equivalent to an author’s dream. Freud, Masson, & Fliess (1985) identify what they call ‘the class of dreams that have never been dreamt at all – dreams created by imaginative writers and ascribed to invented characters in the course of a story’. The surface of a text (words and images, etc.) are regarded as the manifest content, while the latent content is the author’s hidden desires. Texts are read in this way to discover an author’s fantasies; these are seen as the real meaning of the text.

The second approach is reader-centered, and derives from the secondary aspect of the author-centered approach. This approach is concerned with how texts allow readers to symbolically play out desires and fantasies in the texts they read. In this way, a text works like a substitute dream.

Freud deploys the idea of ‘fore-pleasure’ to explain the way in which the pleasures of the text ‘make possible the release of still greater pleasure arising from deeper psychical sources’. In other words, fictional texts stage fantasies that offer the possibility of unconscious pleasure and satisfaction. As he further explains,

“In my opinion, all the aesthetic pleasure which a creative writer affords us has the character of a fore-pleasure our actual enjoyment of an imaginative work proceeds from a liberation of tensions in our minds enabling us thenceforward to enjoy our day-dreams without self-reproach or shame.”

In other words, although we may derive pleasure from the aesthetic qualities of a text, these are really only the mechanism that allows us access to the more profound pleasures of unconscious fantasy. Freud’s translation of psychoanalysis to textual analysis begins with a somewhat crude version of psychobiography and ends with a rather sophisticated account of how meanings are made. However, his suggestions about the real pleasures of reading may have a certain disabling effect on psychoanalytic criticism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.