Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Solvency---AT: Arms Control---2AC

The US has no chance at successful arms control negotiations with Russia---they want to hold onto their nukes post-Ukraine.

Steven Pifer 22, former US ambassador to Ukraine and non-resident senior fellow at the Arms Control and Non-proliferation Initiative, 5/23/2022, “The Russia-Ukraine War: A Setback for Arms Control,” , RH

The Russia-Ukraine war is entering its fourth month, with no end in sight. The Kremlin seems intent on achieving a victory on the battlefield, while relations between the West and Russia plummet to new lows. One casualty: U.S.-Russian arms control negotiations.

Then, on February 24, 2022, the Russia launched its brutal and unjustified invasion of Ukraine. Washington wound down “business as usual” and suspended the strategic stability dialogue.

Resumption of those discussions almost certainly will have to wait until an end to the war, and likely for some time after that. Arms control skeptics will seize on Russia’s attack to intensify their opposition to any attempt to negotiate with Moscow.

If U.S.-Russian discussions resume at some point, the delay will have an impact. Persuading Moscow to negotiate limits on non-strategic nuclear weapons, which would bring in a host of complex questions, would have been difficult in any case. Now, however, the sides would have little time to conclude a treaty, let alone for the Senate to discuss ratification, before the U.S. political season cranks up in 2024.

Setting aside the time factor, the Russia-Ukraine war almost certainly will make it harder to persuade Russian negotiators to put non-strategic nuclear weapons on the table. The Russian military attaches great importance to such weapons, seeing them as one means to make up for U.S. and NATO conventional force advantages (to say nothing about China).

Given the abysmal performance by its military against a smaller and out-gunned foe, the Russian General Staff is likely to regard its non-strategic nuclear arsenal as more necessary than ever.

Of particular note, the Russian military has devoted significant efforts in recent years to adding to its arsenal precision-guided conventional weapons, including long-range strike systems such as the Kalibr cruise missile. They demonstrated some of those weapons in Syria.

This will make it harder to get non-strategic nuclear weapons in the negotiation. At a minimum, the price that Russian negotiators will demand, such as limits on missile defense, will increase.

The Biden administration thus has no chance to get an ambitious agreement in its first term. As for a second term, who knows what the American electorate will decide in November 2024?

Arms control offers a useful national security tool that can put guardrails on the adversarial aspects of the U.S.-Russian relationship. As Washington and Moscow find themselves at the most contentious point in their relations since the early 1980s and perhaps since the 1962 Cuban missile crisis, keeping such guardrails in place is more important than ever. Unfortunately, the Russia-Ukraine war will make doing that more difficult than ever.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.