Yes Revisionism---Ukraine---1AR
Ukraine uniquely proves --- Russia bases their rhetoric in historical revisionism to justify invasion.
Serhan, 22 (Yasmeen Serhan is a staff writer at The Atlantic, 2-27-22, Who Is Vladimir Putin’s Revisionist History For?, The Atlantic, /alundy)
Putin is not the only world leader who has harkened back to an ahistorical past to justify his decisions in the present. Right-wing nationalists have sought to portray themselves as the primary defenders of a glorious past that their enemies would seek to deny or forget. By and seeking to cultivate a politics of , Putin has attempted the same. But in his justification for the invasion of Ukraine, Putin’s ahistoricism has bordered on delusion. Whether the Russian people or the rest of the world share in it, for now, appears to be immaterial: If there’s one audience this revisionist history is designed for, it’s Putin himself.
The evolution of Putin’s historical revisionism can be seen throughout his public statements over the years. In 2005, he famously the collapse of the Soviet Union as the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century. Two years later, Putin the aftermath of the Soviet era and the pernicious, unipolar world—one led not by Moscow, but by Washington—that it had created. Last year, in perhaps the clearest articulation of his worldview, Putin said that Ukrainians and Russians are “.” On Monday, he took that sentiment even further, declaring Ukraine to be “an inalienable part of our own history, culture, and spiritual space” whose independence was a product not of self-determination (Ukrainians resoundingly voted in favor of independence from the Soviet Union in a ), but rather “a mistake.”
Unlike his announcing Moscow’s annexation of Crimea, which was largely framed as a moment of celebration, this was an angry speech—one ostensibly designed to make Russia’s people angry too, and to justify what was to come. “In territories adjacent to Russia, which I have to note is our historical land, a hostile ‘anti-Russia’ is taking shape,” Putin said in another address ahead of the invasion. “For our country, it is a matter of life and death, a matter of our historical future as a nation.”
It’s hard to know what Putin means by historical future (which is, on its face, an oxymoron), though we can take an educated guess. When Putin speaks of Russia today, he speaks of a country whose greatness is defined by its past—namely, its imperial history and its victory during World War II—which he believes must guide its present. “Putin weaponized history by giving it a function,” Orysia Lutsevych, the head of the Ukraine Forum at the London-based Chatham House think tank, told me. As far as the Russian president is concerned, “history is the fortune teller of the future.”
Such historical narratives can be compelling, especially when they elicit the kind of nostalgic nationalism that has proved potent elsewhere, including in the United States (where Donald Trump’s Republican Party has dubbed itself the defender of ), India (where Hindu nationalists have appealed to pride in India’s past to undermine its secular present), and Hungary (where Prime Minister Viktor Orbán often the territories the country lost after the First World War). “Putin is not the only person who is old enough to have felt that sense of deep, personalized humiliation and shame that came with the loss of power of the Soviet Union at the end of the Cold War,” Keir Giles, the author of , told me. “Anything that reasserts Russia as that great power with a greater status than others and the right to a global presence and global influence in others’ affairs will be popular in those sectors of the Russian population.”
Still, it’s difficult to gauge just how big that sector is or how pervasive the narrative has been among those who don’t share Putin’s semi-mythological view of history. A recent , published the day before the start of Moscow’s military invasion of Ukraine, found that though roughly half of Russians support using military force to prevent Ukraine from joining NATO, only 36 percent support doing so as a means of forcing a reunification of the two countries. The lack of support for the latter was most clearly evidenced by that have broken out across Russian cities.
When I spoke with Denis Volkov, the director of the Moscow-based Levada Center, Russia’s last independent pollster, in early February, he told me that though the majority of Russians fear war, few would feel comfortable voicing opposition to it if it came due to fear of reprisals. Indeed, more than have already been made. Besides, Volkov said, “public opinion will be no limit to the Russian government.”
Though Putin may feel obliged to justify his war of choice to the Russian people, who with Ukrainians will share the costs of a bloody and drawn-out conflict, his revisionist history is designed to appeal to no one more so than himself. By restoring Russia’s control over its former territories, Putin not only corrects what he sees as a historic wrong but also cements his place in Russian history as the leader who restored the country to its rightful status.
The irony is that in his quest to make Russia great again, he risks achieving just the opposite. Invading Ukraine has already resulted in and has all but ensured Russia’s diplomatic isolation. Even Putin’s friends in Europe, such as and Czech President , have gone out of their way to reiterate their support for Ukraine and their commitment to a joint European Union stance.
“Putin’s views have become more and more extreme over time to the point where they are now more or less unrecognizable and have few points of contact with history as it’s understood in the outside world,” Giles said. “He’s operating in a different plane of reality and in a different century.”
Ukraine proves --- revisionism motivates invasion
Baibhawi, 22 (Riya Baibhawi, Senior news write at Republic World, 5/10/22, "US accuses Vladimir Putin of presenting 'revisionist history' in Victory Day speech," Republic World, /alundy
White House has accused Russian President Vladimir Putin of presenting a version of revisionist history in his Victory Day speech. As Putin used the occasion of Soviet victory to defend his Special Military Operation on Ukraine, US Press Secretary Jen Psaki said that his words distorted facts. On Monday, the Russian Czar addressed his countrymen from Red Square in Moscow but refrained from announcing victory over Ukraine.
Following the same, Psaki said, “But what I will say is that what we saw President Putin do is give a version of revisionist history that took the form of disinformation that we have seen too commonly as the Russian playbook.”
“You know, our view is that we should remember — and this is why I did this at the top — what this day is actually about, which is something that we have all celebrated, which is the defeat of Nazis in — after World War Two, something that Russians have celebrated in the streets for many years," she added.
'Patently False'
In his speech, Putin blamed the West for triggering the ongoing conflict in Ukraine and said that NATO threatened the security of the Russian Federation. "Russia called on the West for an honest dialogue, to search for reasonable, compromise solutions, to take into account each other's interests. All in vain. The NATO countries did not want to hear us, which means that they had completely different plans. The danger grew every day. Russia gave a pre-emptive rebuff to aggression. It was a forced, timely, and the only right decision. The decision of a sovereign, strong, independent country," Putin said. However, Psaki said that his claim was “absurd” and “patently false.”
On the other hand, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelsnkyy vowed to defeat Russia on Monday. He said, "Very soon there will be two Victory Days in Ukraine and someone will not have any." Marching on Khreschatyk Street in the country's capital Kyiv, he spoke about two victory days referring to triumph in world war II as well as Ukraine's victory in the ongoing war. The embattled leader said that his countrymen will win the war because they are fighting for their children. “We won then. We will win now. And Khreshchatyk will see the victory parade – the Victory of Ukraine!” he claimed.