Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hungary’s digital authoritarianism creates positive feedback loops of democratic backsliding

Fatma Timucin 07-08- 21, “8-BIT IRON FIST: DIGITAL AUTHORITARIANISM IN COMPETITIVE AUTHORITARIAN REGIMES: THE CASES OF TURKEY AND HUNGARY”, 8 July 21, https://research.sabanciuniv.edu/id/eprint/42417/1/10337574.pdf//cpd

The case of Hungary has garnered recent scholarly attention regarding its democratic trajectory in the latest years. As 2021 marks Victor Orbán’s eleventh year holding the position of Prime Minister, Hungary has turned increasingly authoritarian. The country has accomplished an unfortunate first, as it is the only non-democratic member of the EU since 2020 (Repucci 2020). In turn, several NGOs, international organizations, and member countries have issued demands of political sanctions on Hungary in an attempt to reverse the democratic backsliding it is facing. Orbán’s regime can be characterized by populism and national conservatism. As a distinguishing quality, Orbán openly advocates for an ‘illiberal state’ in advancing national conservatism. His shift to right-wing became apparent in his first term in office between 1998-2002. Following two elections favored the Socialist Party, resulting in a drastic change in the government. However, Orbán’s Fidesz managed to keep its popularity in later years, and coupled with the Socialist’s decreasing voter support, won the election by a landslide in 2010. The subsequent decade has solidified Orbán’s grip on power as Fidesz constituted the majority in the parliament after his coalition with Christian Democrats. This allowed Orbán to pass several constitutional and legislative reforms. The consequences of said reforms spell out a perfect example of the “executive aggrandizement” (Bermeo 2016) pointed out in democratic backsliding literature. Simultaneously, Orbán expanded his influence, blurred the boundaries of executive decision-making, and grasped the popular vote. His maintaining of popular support is linked to several causes in the literature, such as the weak democratic tradition as a result of the post-soviet context (Krygier 2019), deepening of social cleavages (Palonen 2009), and rising Euro-scepticism resulting from a clash of values (Furedi 2017). An overlooked factor of Orbán’s success lies in his gradual capture of the media network, resulting in an enormous asymmetry in pro-government and opposition narratives. Although recent scholarly work aimed to fill the gap in the literature (Fabry 2020; Serdült 2020; Zgut et al. 2020), the issue was raised only after Hungary became a competitive authoritarian regime. 41 An extensive recollection of Orbán’s attitude towards media is hard to come by. In contrast, with many of his populist counterparts, Victor Orbán openly targeted free media since he assumed office. Independent media outlets shrank in numbers and the variety of content they can offer over time. In his crusade against opposition voices, Orbán instrumentalized takeovers as well as restriction and persecution of journalists. One of the last remaining independent media outlets, Index.hu, was met with a change of staff on the grounds of political motivation (Index 2020) in Fall 2020. Calls for the EU to intervene and protect freedom of speech through political pressure were made (IPI 2020), although there is no action taken insofar. In building control over the media, the case of Hungary was specifically successful for its implementation of all three strategies at once: legislative action, financial manipulation, and political pressure (Altena 2017); and the organizational grasp of Fidesz and Orbán resulted in perpetual democratic backsliding where linkage and leverage to EU fell short (Sandoval 2018). The following chapter offers a breakdown of the building and practice of Victor Orbán’s strategies of digital authoritarianism. The case of Orbán’s digital authoritarianism is a valuable contribution to literature in showing the solidification of an increasingly aggressive pro-government media landscape. Systematic violation of freedom of speech aids populist leaders like Orbán in spreading and legitimizing their rhetoric as the one and only ‘truth.’ Diminishing opportunities in accessing alternative sources of information further contributes to democratic backsliding and creates a positive feedback loop, which is why it is worthy of scholarly attention with regards to both digital authoritarianism and populism literatures.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.