Effective cross-domain strategies is key to deterrence of grey-zone strategies in land, air, sea, cyber, and space
Sweijs, T., Zilincik 21, S. 2021, The Essence of Cross-Domain Deterrence. In: Osinga, F., Sweijs, T. (eds) NL ARMS Netherlands Annual Review of Military Studies 2020. NL ARMS. T.M.C. Asser Press, The Hague. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-419-8_8, nihara
Deterrence is about convincing adversaries to refrain from certain behaviour through the prospect of costs that outweigh the benefits.1 As related in the preface to this volume by Osinga and Sweijs, deterrence has been a central tenet of strategic practice throughout history,2 even if its logic was only clearly articulated in the aftermath of the Second World War. Deterrence scholarship has since then evolved in four consecutive waves. The first, second and third wave of the deterrence literature, which emerged during the Cold War, tended to almost exclusively focus on deterrence of high-intensity aggression including most importantly the possible use of nuclear weapons alongside large scale conventional invasion.3 Lower-intensity threats which were considered mere nuisances were largely left outside of the scope of investigation.4 However, these became more important in the 1990s with the demise of the Soviet Union and the emergence of non-traditional threats such as terrorism.5 This gave birth to the fourth wave of deterrence literature that focused on the question whether deterrence would work against such threats that emerged in the 1990s and 2000s.6 Over the past decade, a new body of ideas has been emerging concerning the application of deterrence in today’s strategic environment. An important characteristic of our age is the proliferation of ways and means by which hostile activities can be perpetrated. Accordingly, strategists have started to pay more attention to the application of deterrence in new domains and to cross domain deterrence (CDD), across both traditional and new domains. This chapter appraises the contribution of the emerging body of cross domain deterrence literature to deterrence theory and deterrence practice. It explains the context in which theories of cross domain deterrence have emerged and elaborates different conceptualisations of cross domain deterrence distinguishing between two different approaches. The conclusion summarises the findings and elaborates their implications for theory and practice.7
8.2 The Origins of Cross-Domain Deterrence
The shift in attention to CDD can be explained by two principal challenges. The first challenge relates to the progressive integration and synchronization of military operations across different domains (land, air, sea, cyber, and space) and the inherent disharmony between different levels of war (strategic, operational and tactical).8 This is because military organizations aspire to better integrate physical, social and communication technologies in their ability to apply violence in the pursuit of political objectives, leading to strategic compression and cross domain warfare. Multi-domain operations concepts are being developed to guide efforts to synchronise actions both horizontally across domains and vertically across levels of war.9 In light of the cross-domain nature of the challenge, strategists are envisaging analogous responses, including CDD.
The second challenge relates to the increased salience of “hybrid” or “grey zone” strategies that feature the simultaneous employment of military and non-military instruments, typically below the conventional military threshold, in an ambiguous fashion in order to evade attribution, with the goal to exploit adversary’s vulnerabilities, in the pursuit of political objectives.10 While the analytical value of the labels as such have caused considerable debate,11 the real-world impact of these strategies poses a serious strategic challenge. Their increased salience stems from the enormous costs associated with interstate wars, which makes major military powers disinclined from waging actual hot wars against each other. These powers therefore try and find alternative ways to achieve their political objectives—in line with the original tenets of the coercive diplomacy literature. Furthermore, the increased salience of grey zone strategies also derives from the opportunities offered by new avenues to hurt opponents due to technological and societal developments because of the global wiring of societies over the past quarter century. Strategically innovative actors have been making frequent use of these avenues over the past decade to considerable effect. These developments have led scholars and strategists to start thinking about the use and utility of cross domain deterrence in dealing with adversaries employing cross domain strategies also outside the traditional military domains.
Authors from both sides of the Atlantic generally concur that cross-domain deterrence involves the use of threats in one domain to deter activities in (an)other domain(s). Some authors define cross domain deterrence exclusively in the military domains land, sea, air, cyber and space albeit at different levels of abstraction. James Scouras, Edward Smyth and Thomas Mahnken assert for example that it is the prospect of retaliation from one domain to another which constitutes the essence of CDD.12 It is worth noting that the authors seem to focus exclusively on deterrence by punishment rather than denial. James Dawkins emphasizes that CDD involves the use of specific weapons rather than mere threats or retaliation in general. His conceptualization includes both punishment and denial strategies and draws attention to the actual instruments by which deterrent effects are to be achieved.13 Despite the differences in abstraction, these authors understand CDD to operate specifically within the military domains.