Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Overcentralization will destroy military operations at the operational level

Rosario M. Simonetti 20, Lieutenant Colonel Rosario M. Simonett is an Italian Army Marine, “Automation and the Future of Command and Control The End of Auftragstaktik?,” Journal of Advanced Military Studies, Vol. 11 No. 1, June 2020, https://muse.jhu.edu/article/796245/pdf//RA

The impact of new technologies and the increased tempo of the future battlespace may overcentralize command and control functions at the political or strategic level. Political and strategic leaders might pursue preemptive or preventive wars as a strategy to acquire asymmetric advantage over the enemy, not because they must but because they can. As a result, senior leaders may be encouraged to bypass the advisory role played by their qualified staff and undermine the autonomy of lower level commanders. The advancement of technological systems may end mission command, Auftragstaktik. Donald E. Vandergriff defines Auftragstaktik as a cultural philosophy of military professionalism:

The overall commander’s intent is for the member to strive for professionalism, in return, the individual will be given latitude in the accomplishment of their given missions. Strenuous, but proven and defensible standards will be used to identify those few capable of serving in the profession of arms. Once an individual has been accepted into the profession, a special bond forms with their comrades, which enables team work and the solving of complex tasks. This kind of command culture . . . must be integrated into all education and training from the very beginning of basic training.

2 This article explores the roots of this trend, connecting historical perspectives with implications that next-generation technology may have on command and control.

Technological innovation plays a critical role in the conduct of war. The adoption of new technologies in warfare has been instrumental in replacing roles traditionally played by humans. During the interwar period, between World War I and World War II, warfare was optimized to cope with greater distances and faster execution through increasingly complex machines. The armed forces general staffs became more sophisticated and complex to process a greater amount of information. The battlefield gradually moved away from the commander, while command and control, a critical function for warfare, moved toward automation

Current military capabilities are the result of an evolutionary trend in which technology and information have constantly played a central role. With the introduction of the network-centric warfare (NCW) concept of operations, or the employment of networked forces at all levels, commanders can now access a network of sensors, decision makers, and soldiers, which provides shared awareness, higher tempo, greater lethality, and survivability on an almost global scale.3 The development and adoption of new technologies has allowed political and strategic decision makers to control the battlefield in real time even at the tactical level. The impact of new technologies and the increased speed in the future battlespace may overcentralize command and control functions at the political or strategic level. The consequences might be detrimental to the conduct of military operations at the operational and tactical level. In addition, autonomous weapons and artificial intelligence are the next step toward the automation of warfare with critical implications for command and control.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.