Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Decentralization’s key to airpower agility – otherwise tension between political control and military execution causes data gaps AND inefficiencies that complicate operational implementation

---AOC = air operations center, the senior element of the theater air control system

Matthew R. Voke 19, Major, USAF, 2019-11-01, “Artificial Intelligence for Command and Control of Air Power,” Air University Press, , nihara

Centralization Versus Decentralized Airpower

US doctrine prescribes the conduct of joint air operations using the principle of centralized control and decentralized execution.22 An oversimplified synopsis driving this tenet of airpower is that centralization of control enables the senior echelon commanders to control, mass, and lead forces effectively; decentralization of execution allows forces to seize the initiative, respond to uncertain and changing environments, and fosters flexibility in lower echelons.

Technological developments frequently shift the equilibrium of this tenet of airpower. Robust communications connectivity has increased the shared operations picture at all levels, but it has also enabled senior leadership involvement in the finest details of employment.23 This duality has created inherent tension between the imperatives of political control and those of efficient mission accomplishment that leaders must understand.24 Although centralized control and execution are possible in many situations, a conscious effort to delegate execution authority appropriately will ensure the maintenance of US airpower agility.

The balance of centralization and decentralization can shift between and during conflicts, and leaders must strive to increase what some call “agility” in airpower employment. The Air Force Future Operating Concept defines agility as the ability to react rapidly to situations. Agility is a combination of one’s flexibility, speed, coordination, balance, and strength.25 Decentralization generally favors flexibility and speed, while centralization generally favors coordination and strength. One’s understanding of agility might imply physical capability, but agility also includes a cognitive capability to react to a dynamic opponent, moving target, or shifting environment.26 The power of AI employment in airpower C2 lies in the cognitive speed and strength it can bring synergistically toward the goal of agility.

C2 Structure

C2 systems control joint air operations, typically built around the C2 system of the service component commander, that has the preponderance of air assets and the most exceptional ability to control them.27 The air operations center (AOC) is the senior element of the theater air control system, which ensures the effective planning and conduct of air, space, and cyberspace operations. The AOC construct may also apply when fighting with joint or coalition partners as a joint air operations center or a coalition air operations center. The size of an AOC can vary wildly between staff in the single digits to more than a thousand officers, enlisted, and civilian members. Each AOC’s organization differs, but their common goal is to match available means toward tasked military objectives. The responsibilities of the AOC typically include planning and controlling joint air operations, recommending priorities in air apportionment, airspace coordination, air defense coordination, space coordination, and cyberspace coordination.

Technological improvements in computing, communications, and information sharing have disrupted the tiered C2 structure creating disruptions from operational planning to tactical execution. AOC leadership is capable of making decisions historically conducted at lower operational or tactical echelons. Today, for example, the highest levels of operational C2 may not delegate target identification and weapons release authority, which was once only possible at the tactical edge. The relative overmatch wielded when facing less capable adversaries, and the aversion to civilian casualties and loss of life may have lulled the United States into complacency and a false assumption that future wars will take place in the same benign environments.28 Increases in efficiency and agility needed to defeat near-peer adversaries are possible through distributing control outside the AOC, decentralizing the execution of air assets, and leveraging AI’s speed and cognitive strength across multiple levels of C2.

The C2 of airpower has excellent potential to leverage AI augmentation and automation for increased cognitive agility. The next section discusses one example of AI use area in airpower C2—joint targeting. There are currently data gaps and inefficiencies within the targeting cycle that complicate the efficient transfer of critical information when planning and executing joint air operations.29 The next sections will cover how AI can prepare decision-makers with a better understanding of their operating environment, filter and fuse the fire hose of battlefield data into relevant information, and increase decision speeds.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.