Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Centralization is key to success and stability – decentralization of DOD AI will be destructive to the agency

DANIELLE C. Tarraf et al. 19, TARRAF, WILLIAM SHELTON, EDWARD PARKER, BRIEN ALKIRE, DIANA GEHLHAUS CAREW, JUSTIN GRANA, ALEXIS LEVEDAHL, JASMIN LÉVEILLÉ, JARED MONDSCHEIN, JAMES RYSEFF, ALI WYNE, DAN ELINOFF, EDWARD GEIST, BENJAMIN N. HARRIS, ERIC HUI, CEDRIC KENNEY, SYDNE NEWBERRY, CHANDLER SACHS, PETER SCHIRMER, DANIELLE SCHLANG, VICTORIA SMITH, ABBIE TINGSTAD, PADMAJA VEDULA, KRISTIN WARREN, Danielle Tarraf is a publisher at Rand Corporation, “The Department of Defense Posture for Artificial Intelligence,” June 2019, https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RR4200/RR4229/RAND_RR4229.pdf//RA

The JAIC lacks visibility. The issue of visibility is subtle. The JAIC has been designated, in the summary of the DoD AI strategy, as the focal point for carrying out DoD’s strategy, and is expected to attract and cultivate a world-class AI team. This designation and role presume a certain degree of visibility both within DoD and outside it. This visibility was lacking based on our interviews. Overall, we noted a lack of clarity among our interviewees on the JAIC’s mandate, roles, and activities. We also noted a lack of clarity around how it fits within the broader DoD ecosystem and how it connects to the services and their efforts. That was true of both DoD interviewees and our industry interviewees who had heard of the JAIC (see section “Organization: At the OSD Level” in Appendix B and section “Thoughts Across Industry: On the JAIC” in Appendix C). In addition to the lack of clarity about the JAIC’s current mandate and roles, there were many perspectives about the desired or ideal role for the JAIC as DoD embraces and scales AI. These perspectives ranged from the JAIC as a central repository of information and best practices, to the JAIC as a center of excellence that focuses on discrete tasks (e.g., building the JCF, formalizing standards for VVT&E), to the JAIC’s potential elevation to a field agency or other entity with a direct reporting line to either the Secretary or DSD.

We do not believe this lack of clarity to be simply a question of messaging. More fundamentally, it points to a lack of clarity about the raison d’être of the JAIC and how the specific roles it has been assigned support that. The confusion might not be entirely on the part of the audience. DoD needs to have a clearer view of what it wants the JAIC to be and how DoD can help ensure the success of JAIC’s mission, and therefore DoD’s vision.

The DIB’s Technologies and Capabilities Recommendation  5, cited earlier in this chapter, proposed establishing a centralized, focused, and well-resourced organization to propel applied research in AI and ML forward. The insights gathered from our industry interviews (see section “Industry: Organization” in Appendix C) lead us to believe there is indeed value in, if not strict necessity for, a centralized organization. This organization would have a mandate that goes beyond applied research and would be supported at the highest levels with long-term funding commitments to institute organizational change and scale AI across DoD. One of our industry interviewees noted that centralization at onset was key to their organization’s success, and premature decentralization of effort likely would have been detrimental (see section “Industry: Organization” in Appendix C).7

Based on the premises that (1) the JAIC is the focal point of DoD AI activity; (2) it fulfills the need for a centralized, well-resourced organization to scale AI and its impact across DoD (see above); (3) it will continue in that role for several years because of the expected timeline for AI deployment at scale across enterprise, mission-support, and operational AI; and (4) it needs to be able carry out all the roles it has been tasked with in the current strategy and establishing memo, we identified friction points that we discuss in the following paragraphs.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.