Security cooperation misses the point. War is transitioning – now operates through the computational redisclosure of the battlefield and predictive preemptive systems
Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 2019—associate professor of information and media studies at the University of Western Ontario; assistant professor of communication at Simon Fraser University (Nick and Svitlana, Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism) //ansel
What this reach grasps is the “datified subject” (Cheney-Lippold 2017, 35), that is to say, the identity constituted for individuals by their activity on digital networks. This is not to suggest an entire virtual translation of the person into the network but rather the collection of digital identifiers that converge on, add to, overlay, interpenetrate, and, in some contexts, supplant the multiple social codes and indicators of which corporeal individuality is composed. There is now an extensive literature on the various corporate and state “profiling machines” (Elmer 2004) that assemble and ascribe identities from the traces of digital searching, liking, browsing, shopping, chatting, and navigating, and, indeed, from the mere act of carrying location-transmitting mobile phones. And there is a similar series of investigations into the “black boxes” (Pasquale 2015; see also Amoore 2013; Finn 2017) of algorithmic processes that, from the accumulation of “big data,” predict future activities—and of the many biases and errors that enter this process (O’Neill 2016). This literature highlights the paradox that the mass volumes of big data enable increasingly precise, personalized mapping of an individualized “data subject” (Bauman et al. 2014) according to its conformity or deviation from a series of patterns. We will follow this idea through three different registers in which war touches the “datified subject”: battlefield intelligence, civilian surveillance, and digital propaganda, focusing particularly on examples from the United States. Shawn Powers and Michael Jablonski (2015, 81) observe that origins of data profiling lie in intelligence operations, where mosaic theory, the idea that “one can piece discrete bits of information together to predict the likely intentions or actions of others,” has been a core idea. Early in the so-called war on terror, mosaic theory was applied at the CIA’s black sites and U.S. military’s detention centers at Guantánamo, Bagram, and Kandahar, where captives were often held and interrogated solely on the basis of association with other suspects (Pozen 2005). The idea that big data can generate an “individualization” of war has become increasingly prominent in cyberwar doctrine. In 2014, Charles Dunlap, a retired U.S. major general (and one of the several authors who invoke the pseudoTrotsky aphorism we started with), suggested that anticipations of cyberwar as a series of “apocalyptic” infrastructure attacks might be less important than the “hyperpersonalization of war” based on data profiles. The possibility that particularly excited him was that of targeting specific members of an opponent’s forces, “primarily the leadership cadre but also critical technicians and experts,” with the primary example being the use of drones, both for information gathering and attack delivery from the skies over Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Yemen, and Somalia.