Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The expansion of war beyond physicality enables dark pure war against the planet.

Towns, 19—associate professor in Communication and Media Studies, Carleton University (Armond, “(Dark) Pure War: Virilio, the Cinematic, and the Racial,” Media Theory, Vol. 3, No. 2, 145-160, dml)

In Pure War, Paul Virilio argued that war continued beyond the physicality of the battlefield. Outside of the violence of the fight lay a violence of industrial production toward the conditions for war. Put differently, pure war signified the new ways that war was now acted out ‘in infinite preparation’ (Virilio, 2008: 29). Pure war indicated the always already active preparation for war by the state, even when war was not being physically waged.

One could say that a cornerstone of Virilio’s research has been media’s relation to unending war. A central component of pure war, for example, is information, or the gathering of data to surveil and police populations that are always under the watchful eye of the war machine. Interestingly, Virilio concerns himself less with the racial implications of those who are open to surveilling and policing and more with the expansion of policing and surveilling as practices that are applicable to ‘everyone’. Yet, his examples of war have racial undertones that he often does not fully investigate: the Vietnam War, the Iraq War, and the Italo-Ethiopian War, to name a few, all creep toward the pure war. Even as Virilio (2002) acknowledged the racial implications of the Second World War, he had less to say about the recognition that the Nazis pulled their racialized strategies of death for the European Jewish population from the US state’s approach to black and indigenous people (Whitman, 2017). Each of these wars, between white and nonwhite people or between white and white people in relation to those who could never fully be white, suggest that the wars that Virilio found most interesting were not race neutral.

What can Virilio provide for a media studies of race? I argue that Virilio’s work on pure war can be reinterpreted as a ‘dark pure war’, concerned with a militaristic, unending war against nonwhite populations. It is a dark pure war, one that structures the colony and the metropole, that lays the foundation for pure war. Dark pure war is not necessarily ‘black’ in the racialized sense, even as it often functions that way. Instead, it is black in the ‘blackening’ sense, in what Kumi Silva (2010) calls the ‘identification’ of nonwhite bodies as open to state violence. Thus, pulling from Virilio and Simone Browne’s (2015) Dark Matters, a dark pure war outlines the centrality of race to the continuance of war, even as race is the purposefully forgotten genesis of such war. This is not Michel Foucault’s (2003) ‘race war’, as Europe is not the central locale from which such war occurs. Rather, dark pure war is inseparable from Euro-American imperial, capitalistic expansionism (colonialism and racial slavery) as militarized projects toward the maintenance of white life and the conditions of black death, ad infinitum.

Virilio’s work has been called, rightly in my opinion, ‘wild and aphoristic’ (Sharma, 2013). Yet, I want to say that what Virilio may point toward is an investigation of the centrality of technologies to racialization processes. Surveillance studies (which has long investigated race) and media philosophy (which has been slower to discuss race) are put into conversation with one another here. I advance the concept of dark pure war in three sections. I start by delineating the connections between war, cinema, and information that Virilio argued were important. I then move into outlining the darkness of pure war, particularly by outlining the racialized components of contemporary policing and surveillance. I conclude by calling for a rethinking of ‘dromology’, one that moves toward including the multi-symbolic capacity of ‘race’ in discussions of war.

The Perceptions of War: Vision and the Cinematic

In War and Cinema, Virilio argued that the history of war was both theatrical and a history of transforming perceptual fields, whereby vision was increasingly the site of power. As such, the rifle’s gunsights and the camera came together to situate the world as a field of vision that could be measured, calculated, and shot. For Virilio, film functioned as a pedagogical tool, one that involved an increasing sensorial detachment from film itself. Virilio’s example is the famous myth of an audience in Paris watching a film of a moving locomotive filling the screen causing the people in the cinema to believe the train was going to drive over them:

[In] fact it was the precision of the camera-shot which first created audience panic at the Lumières’ ‘motion demonstrations’ of the train’s arrival at la Ciotat, when everyone felt that they risked being crushed or injured by the train. This kind of fear, akin to the sense of speed that people seek on roller coasters, did not disappear but simply became more pernicious as the audience learnt to control its nervous reactions and began to find death amusing (Virilio, 1989: 39-40).

What Virilio pointed to was a transformation in perception: film produced images of objects, thus, perceptually distancing audiences from said objects, to a point where there would no longer be a need to panic at the sight of an oncoming train in a cinema. There have been a few attempts to debunk the myth of whether or not the audience was actually sent running at the sight of the train (Cooper, 2016; Grundhauser, 2016), but the fact still stands: ‘film is now second nature to us, but it was utterly shocking not much more than a century ago’ (Cooper, 2016).

Cinemas were ‘training camps’, bonding ‘people together in the face of death agony, teaching them to master the fear of what they did not know – or rather, as Hitchcock put it, of what did not exist’ (Virilio, 1989: 40). In short, cinema readied people for ‘the artificial horizon of a screen or a monitor capable of permanently displaying the preponderance of the media perspective, the relief of the “tele-present” event taking precedence over the three dimensions of the volume of the objects or places here present’ (Virilio, 2006: 66). This training did not occur overnight, but involved multiple media forms that all worked toward perceptual transformation. As such, more than cinema, Virilio is interested in the ‘cinematic’, which included and exceeded cinema, proper; he tried to track the link between cinema, war, and later ‘vision machines’, such as television, CCTV, smart devices, and drone strikes, assuring us that ‘Components of a cinematic machine have been in use over many centuries: forms of projection, moving images, immobile voyages, and visionary illuminations’ (Crary, 2009: 13). The cinema, television, and war all worked together toward distancing audiences from objects, for Virilio.

Virilio’s work on cinema also adds much to those interested in studying the Web and information. In the wake of the atom bomb, Virilio warned of a second bomb, the ‘information bomb’, which is important for pure war. Whereas the atom bomb was a war of movement, the information bomb was a war of knowledge and speed, signifying a war ‘won’ by the increasing speed of interactivity in real time. Such a bomb included and exceeded cinema, and essentially structured computer screens and the Web – both media developed during and after the Second World War, and very much because of it. This is a trajectory of transformations that cannot be said to have origins in cinema, but were representative of the impact of the cinematic:

We’re still here in the domain of cinematic illusion, of the mirage of information precipitated on the computer screen what is given is exactly the information but not the sensation; it is the apatheia, this scientific impassibility which makes it so that the more informed man is the more the desert of the world expands around him, the more the repetition of information (already known) upsets the stimuli of observation, overtaking them automatically, not only in memory (interior light) but first of all in the look, to the point that from now on it’s the speed of light itself which limits the reading of information and the important thing in electronic information is no longer the storage but the display (Virilio, 2009: 56).

For Virilio, then, the shift from ‘tele-vision’ to ‘tele-surveillance’ reflected the demands of capitalism and war. Whereas tele-vision held ‘the task of informing or entertaining the mass of viewers’ (Virilio, 2006: 59), the new tele-vision, or the ‘tele-surveillance’, was concerned with ‘exposing and invading of individuals’ domestic space, like a new form of lighting, which is capable of revolutionizing the notion of neighborhood unit, or of a building or district’ (Virilio, 2006: 59). The drone strike, then, could pinpoint a ‘target’s’ location, whether indoors or outdoors.

Thus, tele-surveillance spoke to a ‘dromology,’ a ‘speed politics’, or a politics of instantaneousness, sparked by the increasing need to entertain, monitor, and prepare others for their own monitoring. Further, it replicated the waging of war on people at a distance: ‘Making information resonate globally, which is necessary in the age of the great planetary market, is in many ways going to resemble the practices and uses of military intelligence, and also political propaganda and its excesses’ (Virilio, 2006: 62). Likewise, this spoke to what many have called a ‘slow violence’, one that disproportionately impacts the Global South (Nixon, 2011; Parikka, 2017), as a space largely viewed solely as a waste station of the Global North. War is a continual process that does not end when the last round is fired, but is also carried out via the circulation of information and propaganda in ways that penetrate architecture without necessarily physically destroying a building’s structural integrity.

Dark Pure War: Surveillance and the Racial

Pure war is the continuance of war after the physicality of war is over and done; now, information functions toward the continuance of war, as a preemptive strike against enemies: ‘But war doesn’t really end, as Virilio noted, it just accelerates, approximating ever more closely to its pure form’ (Wark, 2018). Information is now a central component of war, whereby ‘Not only is architecture vulnerable to bombs, it proves defenseless against information, passing through the doors and walls of our homes, rearranging the space and time we imagine we live within’ (Wark, 2018). Indeed, ‘the capability of war without war manifests a parallel information market of propaganda, illusion, dissimulation’ (Der Derian, 2002: viii).

To rethink Virilio’s pure war as dark pure war requires thinking about not only how information is weaponized toward war’s continuance, but also the presumed racial neutrality associated with both war and information. Thus, race is the underexamined, overlooked element of Virilio’s theory. Like discussions of dark matter in physics, Browne’s employment of ‘dark matter’ is meant to point toward the ‘unseen and unperceived’ elements of antiblackness in the surveillant practices of contemporary society. She argues that ‘rather than seeing surveillance as something inaugurated by new technologies, such as automated facial recognition or unmanned autonomous vehicles (or drones)’ (Browne, 2015: 8), we can instead think about ‘surveillance in and of black life as a fact of blackness’ (Browne, 2015: 6). Thus, Browne connects surveillance theory to a dark history concerned with the measurement of bodies to see their ‘intentions’, a dark history often underexamined in surveillance studies. That history is scientific racism:

Anthropometry, or Bertillonage, was introduced in 1883 by Alphonse Bertillon as a system of measuring and then cataloguing the human body by distinguishing one individual from another for the purposes of identification, classification, and criminal forensics. This early biometric information technology was put to work as a “scientific method,” alongside the pseudo-sciences of craniometry (the measurement of the skull to assign criminality and intelligence to race and gender) and phrenology (attributing mental abilities to the shape of the skull, as the skull was believed to hold a brain made up of individual organs) (Browne, 2015: 112).

What Browne points toward is a question unasked by Virilio: what if the ‘fact of blackness’ is the structuring necessity for the new technologies of surveillance themselves? This would require that we rethink pure war as a dark pure war, which is to say that pure war holds race as central, while never acknowledging its importance to the maintenance of war.

What if we thought about Virilio’s pure war as a racial condition in the US? In short, what if we were to rearticulate WEB Du Bois’ (1994) question of, ‘How does it feel to be a problem’, as a racialized question of war? The end of the US Civil War and the end of racial slavery marked the structure of pure war as a condition, rather than a contingency, of black life. Another way to say this is that white people went to war with each other over the right to own our black bodies in the US Civil War, and it presumably ended in 1865. Yet, the replication of racial violence, what Saidiya Hartman (2008) calls the ‘afterlife of slavery’, has yet to end for black people; instead, racial violence is fundamental to what it means to be black (and white) in the US. Jim Crowism, ghettoization, deindustrialization, white flight, mass incarceration, and gentrification are remnants of dark pure war. They are post-war answers to how to deal with a ‘problem’; to call for their end is to call for the end to what many cannot let go of: whiteness. Further, with race at its center, this entails that black people are not the only ones affected by dark pure war, but are part of dark pure war’s larger assemblage.

What Virilio pointed toward, then, was that cinema and war were necessarily interconnected and assistants in the perceptual transformations that readied populations for their own continual surveillance; and just as important, such forms of surveillance have been tested on people of color prior to their implementation on the larger society. This is what Browne refers to as the ‘unseen and unperceived’ component of dark matter and what I call dark pure war: it is the necessity of the black body as an always already surveillable, commodified object, one that can normalize even the contemporary surveillance of people’s information online.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.