Horizontal escalation is more likely than vertical escalation.
Joque, 18—PhD from the European Grad School, researches philosophy, technology and media and is the visualization librarian at the University of Michigan, go blue (Justin, “Buffer Overflow: The Space and Time of Cyberwar,” Deconstruction Machines: Writing in the Age of Cyberwar, Chapter 1, 65-66, dml)
In one sense, this military investment in “metaphysical control” and new battle spaces is a continuation of ancient strategies of deception, sabotage, and manipulation, but still this contemporary explication seems to mark a qualitatively new level of abstraction and expansiveness. As DiNardo and Hughes, two military historians and theorists, have warned, this focus on a metaphysical battle space marks a military– strategic investment in the complete inversion of the Clausewitzean formula in which politics is war by other means.70 In a 1995 article in Airpower Journal, they worry that the military focus on information warfare and subduing the enemy outside of traditional fighting lends itself to a complete military intervention into politics and civilian life. Chun’s insight that software functions as ideology is thus important in another regard: both software and ideology, along with law and economics, become sites of intervention that risk their symbolic functioning being turned against them.71
Although war spills over into all aspects of everyday life, it is decidedly not total war. It is almost the opposite: a war so constrained and reserved that it nearly goes unnoticed. As is argued in Unrestricted Warfare, growing global interlinkages, including international law, the shared biosphere, a highly connected global economy, and the threat of global thermonuclear war, serve to constrain many global actors. This is not to suggest that these constraints are always or even often effective or that they are positive forces, but they add additional costs that complicate political and military calculuses. All of these serve to put political limits on military options. Instead of vertical escalations of conflict to ever more violence, we are witnessing a horizontal escalation to ever more varied modes of conflict. As war spreads, it escalates horizontally and strategists attempt to open new domains. Thus “fighting” begins to look little like previous conflicts. For instance, the existence of both domestic and international law opens the possibility that one force would be able to limit another force’s strategic options by litigation (a strategy occasionally referred to as lawfare).72 These global interconnections have raised the cost of military escalation, often forcing states to fight within specified rules and domains for fear of upsetting the global order and unleashing potentially more destructive forces or disconnections from global spaces of flow.
Rather than a completely accessible global battle space where war would rage unhindered, we are witnessing the growth of a metaconflict where strategists, legal experts, and public relations experts are constantly attempting to define and constrain war for each side’s strategic advantage. The concept of war has now become part of war itself. As Qiao and Wang argue, the means to contemporary victory in war involve combining limited ends with unlimited means. They are careful to say that this is not total war. Rather, it is a war that weighs means and is not afraid to use any of them, but always to achieve limited rather than total ends. This must be at least part of what Virilio calls “pure war,” or elsewhere the “race to the absolute essence of war”73 as military goals become increasingly limited while strategy expands infinitely, culminating in “the war with zero deaths for the military, but also zero victories in political terms.”74 Rather than an all-out war, we are witnessing with the rise of cyberwar a war that spills outside the bounds of traditional warfare while remaining vertically constrained. This is not to say that these conflicts cannot become horribly violent; for the further afield these interventions stray, the more they may be likely to spiral out of control.