Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Vote neg for a reorientation of human agency towards a co-evolutionary assemblage with technology.

Sy Taffel 19 - Senior Lecturer in Media Studies and co-director of the Political Ecology Research Centre at Massey University, PhD at the University of Bristol. “Digital Media Ecologies.” Google Books. Oct 2019. https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/digital-media-ecologies-9781501349263/,AG

Given the current forecasts for the Anthropocene, an ecological ethics emphasizes the urgent need for modifying current practices. As Cubitt (2005: 59) astutely observes, ‘Techne is the only route through which we can now sense the world, most especially the part of the world’s conversations which are not conducted in wavelengths we can hear, see or otherwise comprehend.’ Without contemporary information-processing technologies, humans would not have sufficiently developed understandings of looming ecological crises to enact urgent calls to action. This is exemplified by the fact that when considering climatic trends, we are addressing global datasets with durations measured in decades and centuries – a temporal scale far slower and a spatial scale far larger than those readily perceptible to humans.

We can only understand climate change via technological mediations which allow us to see enduring trends within noisy, chaotic and complex global climatic systems. This technocultural assemblage includes satellites that measure tropospheric temperatures, thermal drills that can extract 3-kilometre-deep ice cores from polar regions and the storage facilities that preserves these geological artefacts, and the supercomputers that are used to simulate climatic futures. Ecological ethics, then, must not advocate abandoning mediation and technology as a means of retreating to a romanticized past but instead requires reorienting modes of production and consumption towards ecologically beneficial outcomes. Only through repurposing technics along ecological lines – creating commonwealth rather than commodities – are potential solutions to ecological crises likely to become visible; there exists no option to return to a pre-industrial state before technics supposedly altered the harmonious ‘balance of nature’, as is commonly suggested by conservationist and deep ecological discourses.

Applying such an ethics to contemporary media practices means considering the ways in which media systems at varying scales create novel connections and forms of commons and public good, and at the same time involve the usage of energy and materials which close off other avenues via their ecological costs. Ecological ethics is based on praxis rather than pure reason, encouraging experimentation and creative interventions designed to produce positive biopolitical impacts. It entails realizing that while there are detrimental consequences stemming from currently produced technologies, there are bifurcation points whereby the agential capacities of assemblages afford meaningful positive changes to be made to these systems by using theoffending technologies. This is not hypocrisy, but does require a praxis that abandons an idealistic purity.

At the level of content, this means exploring how information flows have created the commodified economy of attention, problematic discourses of Big Data and the context of communicative capitalism, while investigating how ideology, cognitive frames and cognitive dissonance act as brakes which prevent subjects from altering opinions and effecting change. At the level of software, this entails considering issues surrounding licensing, software development and the types of freedom maintained by the free software movement, alongside issues surrounding surveillance, user privacy and the contemporary movement towards the commodification of web protocols as evidenced within HTML5. Within the realm of hardware, this involves examining the flows of energy and matter which comprise and maintain the physical architecture of the network society, considering the material impacts that these flows have on ecological systems at every stage in the life cycle of microelectronics devices. Across all scales this additionally requires an examination of the multiple ways that powerful actors seek to utilize existing and novel hierarchies to perpetuate privileged positions and technocultural systems that are currently leading us towards social and ecological catastrophe.

Media ecology suggests that an experimental praxis with various commons-orientated projects across the scales of content, software and hardware is necessary if ecologically resilient and equitable alternatives are to supplant current practices of mediation. While openness is often proclaimed to be the defining characteristic of commons-based peer-to-peer systems, media ecology follows Bauwens in arguing that openness alone is not enough to guarantee ecologically beneficial outcomes. Alongside openness, projects require commitments to social solidarity and ecological resilience if they are to escape reterritorialization.

Rather than an abstract mode of thought, ecological ethics emphasizes embodied acts of engagement as a method of becoming-ethical. Praxis additionally forms a model which resists contemporary processes of proletarianization, which sees knowledge becomes embodied within technologies, constituting an industrialization of memory and the externalization of communal knowledge into corporate technics. Without some degree of knowledge and experience regarding the complex and distributed processes of mediation which are increasingly central to contemporary life, we have little agency to affect and alter these assemblages along eco-ethical lines. Ecological ethics contends that such knowledge is derived from material practices rather than abstract speculation; following Deleuze, we do not know what a digital assemblage can do, but through experimentation we can produce forms and practices that can help to realize change. ‘Make a rhizome. But you don’t know what you can make a rhizome with, you don’t know which subterranean stem is effectively going to makea rhizome, or enter a becoming, people your desert. So experiment’ (Deleuze and Guattari 1982: 277). We cannot exhaustively know the capacities of systems in advance of this practical activity, so the process of activism, of creating projects, itself opens up points of critical instability and forms lines of flight that can lead to more equitable and resilient futures.

This does not, however, imply that such knowledge leads to mastery and control. Indeed, a basic comprehension of complex systems entails realizing that unilateral control is impossible. Unlike humanist accounts of agency which relegate technics and nature to the status of Cartesian automata, systems which are teleologically bound to particular pathways, media ecology contends that agency is a distributed property, existing throughout assemblages, rather than being an innate quality applying to one particular type of node. While forms of agency differ between varying types of actor, the diverse examples explored in this text have tried to elucidate numerous ways that nonhuman actants realize differential forms of agency.

Understanding the multiplicity of nonhuman agencies at play in technological systems – those associated with algorithms, codecs, file formats, operating systems, minerals, metals and energy supplies – has been posited as key to understanding ways that these ensembles, along with humans, work together to form media ecologies. Improving our understandings of the media systems we are entangled with entails comprehending various forms of nonhuman agency, how they manifest and what kinds of selection pressures they apply to the evolution of technical ensembles. Stiegler’s account of the human as being fundamentally defined by its co-evolutionary relationships with technologies, which form an exteriorized mode of distributed and collective memory is useful here, insofar as it reminds us that ‘we’ do not exist outside of our technical support systems and suggests that the varying agencies which technologies mobilize produce divergent ethical and political imperatives. This goes beyond claims that ‘technology is society made durable’ (Latour 1990), which suggests that society precedes technology (which allows the former to endure), rather than there being a mutually constitutive co-evolution of technology and society.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.