Optimization DA: Framework functions as an attempt to optimize our processing power in the digital age, which quantifies the self.
Theo Hug 21. Professor at the University of Innsbruck, Department of Media, Society and Communication. “Five Theses on (Dis)Comfort in the Educational Cultures of Digitality.” 2021. https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=1028699 //GJ
Thesis 2: Operative fictions of optimizing processes of learning and education correspond with poorly reflected assumptions of mathematization and of the computability of the world
Notions of optimizing processes and methods to quantify the self and others are not inventions of the digital age. From choosing a lubricant for the first rotating fixed wheels to choosing efficient neural networks in machine-learning programs, narratives and leitmotifs of optimization have been diversified and developed. An end to these traditions is not in sight, on the contrary: Computer network technologies have made available processing capacities without which developments in structural sciences and their manifold technological applications would not have been possible.
The frictions between encultured medial constellations of the twentieth century and the emerging new socio-technical configurations of the twenty-first century also affect the key topics of education, especially growing up, learning and teaching. The “optimizing spirit” (Leineweber & Wunder, 2021) that pervades the rhetoric of digitalization makes some people hope for a chance to overcome the “technological deficiency” (Luhmann & Schorr, 1982) and others worry in view of certain fuzzy ideas of applying rational measurement models to the data-driven management of learning and development processes. No matter if a narrow or broad concept of technology is taken as a starting point, or if referring to a technological deficiency is generally deemed to be out-of-place or misleading with respect to the postulates of human dignity and the development of autonomy: The increasingly refined and partly automated measuring methods open up widened scopes of calculating, monitoring, manipulating and controlling, up to re-educating entire population groups.
These enhanced and sometimes de-limited scopes at the interfaces of quantitative-empirical education research, education policy and education economy may prove of value in some regards as “operative fictions” (Schmidt, 2006, p. 4). On the other hand, in the course of becoming reality, the fantasies of optimization occasionally mutate into paradoxes of optimization (Wolf & Thiersch, 2021) – not least when the polymorphism of pedagogical “logics” is consistently interpreted and assessed in the light of machine-, market- or media logics and the self-similarity of the process dynamics does not come into view anymore. The tendencies towards rationalism of disposition are not linked to a particular rationality or version of rationalism. They concern all forms of rationalism, which characteristically tend to absolutize the determination of starting positions, assessment modalities, means, purpose, or procedures and authorities for the deliberate production of behaviors or specific circumstances (cf. Hug et al., 2007). To what an extent the algorithmic rationality opens up new scopes in this context cannot be answered at this point. The discussion of “generative realities” (Löffler, 2019) as calculated, predictable and controlled realities has only just begun.
Such tendencies can be found in the algorithm-based timing of learning technology and the AI-based production of specific qualification effects. They do not only run counter to the obstinacy of open-ended educational processes. They also contradict education-related uncertainty principles. Furthermore, they correspond with ideas that processes of learning and communication are predictable on the basis of calculations and formally schematized competency elements, without consistently considering the human capacities to differentiate between sense and nonsense, to spontaneously depart from rules in the action process, and to creatively connect Phantasie und Kalkül (Schneider, 1992). And what is more, a discomfort with the optimization discourses stems from these discourses’ lack of reflection when it comes to the limits of mathematical languages (Frey, 1967), algorithmic rationality (Mersch, 2019), and the computability of the world (Pietsch et al., 2017).