Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm fails—sequencing is key. Refocusing our priorities is necessary.

Félix Tréguer 19 – PhD in political studies from the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences, associate researcher at CNRS and post-doctoral researcher at CERI Sciences Po in Paris. “Seeing like Big Tech: security assemblages, technology, and the future of state bureaucracy.” Taylorfrancis. Mar 2019. https://research.gold.ac.uk/id/eprint/24517/1/9781315167305.pdf#page=156&zoom=100,0,0, AG [language modifications denoted by brackets]

But post-Snowden controversies also show that these forms of resistance create a risk that we will overlook the pervasiveness of the institutions and technologies, of the rationalities and practices that created the problem in the first place. The risk is that all we are able to come up with are legal, technological or bureaucratic fixes to try to contain the most disturbing aspects of data-driven bureaucracies, without affecting the longer-term trend of a technological arms race that only seems to intensify the issues it was allegedly meant to solve.

Some kind of deeper resistance might be warranted. In his writings on power, Foucault once asked: “How can the growth of capabilities” – and he explicitly mentioned “techniques of communication – “be disconnected from the intensification of power relations?” (Foucault 1984, 48). Computing technologies have since become immensely powerful and yet, we are still struggling to find a satisfactory answer to this crucial question. Despite the hopes of early hackers and Internet pioneers, the decoupling of technology and power is not happening. The key question then becomes whether technology itself or law or ethics can actually be effective instruments to achieve such decoupling.

At this stage of technological development, if we feel like they cannot – at least not in the near foreseeable future – that means it is probably time to refocus on tackling the imaginaries and institutions that underlie the “growth of capabilities” itself: the blind [uncritical] faith in technological progress; the oft-repeated mantra that technology is neutral, that its negative potential will somehow be contained; places like the universities, R&D labs, ministries, start-ups, shops and factories where complex and powerful technologies are designed, produced and traded. As philosopher Jacques Ellul observed, “we set huge machines in motion in order to arrive nowhere” (Ellul 1989, 51). If it is not Thomas More’s eu-topia (“no place”) that we are fast approaching but rather a “dystopian void” (The Luddbrarian 2018), what we need is not just a technological fix, a bureaucratic patch, a principled law or even a good ethics; what we need first and foremost is to get off and stop the machine.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.