Fantasies DA: the perm reinvests in the cybernetic dream of perfectly self-organizing markets. Refusing their fantasy of cybernetic control is both necessary and sufficient.
Halpern, 22—associate professor in sociology and anthropology at Concordia University (Orit, “The Future Will Not Be Calculated: Neural Nets, Neoliberalism, and Reactionary Politics,” Critical Inquiry, Volume 48, Number 2, Winter 2022, dml)
It is perhaps an irony of history that the answer to this problem of overinundation and data surplus appeared to be a turn to cybernetics, new models of networked cognition, and ultimately perhaps even a new model of machine learning that might indeed learn from the distributed intelligence of millions, and now billions, of people. At the same time, such technologies make it impossible to encounter the very legitimate sources of pain in contemporary societies whether induced by structural racism, poverty, disease, or environmental degradation.
This returns us to our present. If Hayek and Hebb still worried about liberal subjects and objectivity, we might ask what concerns animate our contemporary networks? Markets, and now reactionary politics, seek instability and discrimination but without diversity. Shock has been normalized to be managed through our electronic networks. Networks appear to have the power to exacerbate fantasies of individual control and paranoid imaginaries of agential patterns. If “shock” for Klein was a mechanism to destabilize systems and nations to allow the entry of neoliberal governance, we might extend her observation to recognize that now it has become a tool to maintain existing neoliberal systems and to encourage the growth and proliferation of machine learning networks and algorithmic finance.58
I opened this article by arguing that cybernetics and its affiliated communication and human sciences aspired to the elimination of political and psychological trauma through a dream of self-organizing systems and autopoietic intelligences produced from the minute actions of small, stupid, logic gates, a dream of a world of networks without limit, focused eternally on an indefinite and extendable but never-defined future that might be consumed in the present. This dream may now be partially realized, and we have to generate a new set of fantasies.
To do so does not, however, mean wishing, like reactionary politicians, to return to a mythic past. It does not denote fantasizing a Cartesian ethics with transparent algorithms and no black boxes. To do so would only be to replicate the reactionary logic of the database, where processes of distinction and inevitably discrimination are stored only to be retrieved without consciousness or history.
Nor does it mean evading the power we have bequeathed from our machines. The apparatus of the epistemology of the neural net has opened to both positive potentials—neurodiversity, plasticity, and new forms of collectivity—even as it has enhanced the financialization of life and the necropolitics of neoliberal economics. As Randy Martin has argued, rather than separating itself from social processes of production and reproduction, algorithmic finance demonstrates the increased interrelatedness, globalization, and socialization of debt and precarity. By tying together disparate actions and objects into a single assembled bundle of reallocated risks to trade, the new market machines make us more indebted both to each other. The political and ethical question thus becomes how we might activate this increased indebtedness in new ways, ones that are less amenable to the strict market logics of neoliberal economics.59
Hayek, himself, gestured to this possibility within his own thought. Markets he argued, demand difference: “From the fact that people are very different it follows that, if we treat them equally, the result must be inequality in their actual position, and that the only way to place them in an equal position would be to treat them differently. Equality before the law and material equality are therefore not only different but are in conflict with each other; and we can achieve either the one or the other, but not both at the same time.”60 With these words he stated the fundamental dilemma of neoliberalism: to be free we must be put in relation to each other. But he also wavers: Does liberty denote equal treatment, and therefore a generic law, or differential and situated treatment, which might denote planning or coercion? The response of neoliberal discourse has been to automate this relation, thus obscuring its social character, and extract value from the differences between humans while maintaining that such relations emerge evolutionarily and thus are nonintentional but natural and necessary.
Might this discourse be disrupted? Recalling the argument that difference is the foundation for freedom or liberty, can we push this neoliberal imaginary until it folds? This tension might be the source of a possible freedom through relations, if they are historically situated. The fantasy of an archive of processes of differentiation might be mobilized to new ends— mainly to recognizing the permeable, political, and situated nature of social orders. The future, I argue, lies in recognizing what our machines have finally made visible, what has perhaps always been there, mainly the sociopolitical nature of our seemingly natural thoughts and perceptions. In that all computer systems are programmed, and therefore planned, we are also forced to contend with the intentional and therefore changeable nature of how we both think and perceive our world.