Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their data cherrypicks limited stats to represent a whole, thus using a concept of progress to create a metastable closed-off world that they have under control. This project is violently extractive.

Bardin and Ferrari 22 – Dr Andrea Bardin is Senior Lecturer in Politics at Oxford Brookes University, UK; PhD Political Philosophy and History of Political Thought (University of Padua); PhD Political Theory (Brunel University London); Laurea summa cum laude in Philosophy (University of Padua). Marco Ferrari is Ph.D in Philosophy and Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Political Philosophy at the Università di Padova. “Governing progress: From cybernetic homeostasis to Simondon’s politics of metastability.” Sagepub. The Sociological Review Monographs 2022, Vol. 70(2) 248–263. Mar 2022. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/00380261221084426, AG

The point of government in a neoliberal perspective is neither to limit the freedom of initiative, nor to assume that social stability depends on an invisible hand, but rather to carry on a detailed regulation of liberties for the sake of the ‘spontaneous’ equilibrium of the markets. An incessant work of data extraction through ever perfected algorithms sets the conditions of possibility of the subjects’ behaviour – economic actors, ideally selfemployees – and orients it towards the preservation of the system’s dynamic stability. Social change is thus governed and reduced to the hyper-modern idea of progress, conceived as a variation within the parameters deemed necessary for the reproduction and survival of the system. All the ‘irrational’ noise that is not immediately reducible to progress thus conceived is either silenced or – once neutralised – included in the pattern as a risky and unforeseen opportunity to perfect the system’s survival (Castel, 1991; Dean, 1998; Ewald, 1991). More radically, these elements are normatively integrated in the system’s core dynamics in the form of an ethics of flexibility (Fraser, 2003) establishing the ‘good’ functioning of governmentality.

The government of progress is thus resolved in the incessant operation of protection, management and promotion of homeostatic mechanisms deemed capable of self-regulation, but in fact selected and – if necessary – substituted with others, offering a more inclusive and complex capacity of adaptation to the macro-mechanism of the market. This macromechanism is the undisputed horizon that imposes to political power the task of providing a homeostatic equilibrium functional to its progressive implementation. With its ‘soft’ determinism and immanent teleology the market thus appears to be a hypermodern version of the clockwork universe theorised in early-modern mechanical science, and the vector of a similar onto-epistemological reduction of social reality to a mathematical form. And this reduction still relies on a ‘mythical’ concept of progress alimenting an ‘illusion of simultaneity’ that hides a plurality of paths by projecting the ‘eternal present’ of the market on all possible futures.

Simondon: Progress and metastability

The connection we have established between cybernetics and neoliberalism will allow us to use Simondon’s concept of ‘metastability’ against both of them. Although acknowledging Wiener’s invention of the term (Simondon, 2014, p. 236), Simondon elaborated the concept of metastability drawing on Canguilhem’s work and in explicit contrast to the cybernetic concept of homeostasis. Metastability describes systems macroscopically stable but internally characterised by an uneven distribution of potentials and hosting processes that make that stability only apparent. Metastable systems enjoy a ‘stability far from equilibrium’ in which the aleatory ‘encounter’ with a minimal quantity of energy or information can trigger a brusque alteration of equilibrium, and lead to the invention of new structures and hence to a new ‘metastable state’. The notion of metastable equilibrium marks the project of an ‘axiomatic of human sciences’ Simondon presents in explicit opposition to the cybernetic theory of society, questioning at the same time the notion of homeostasis and the deterministic ontology the latter relies upon (Simondon, 1958/2020, pp. 697ff.). Briefly sketching Simondon’s project will allow us to outline the theory of government he elaborates in contrast to Wiener’s, and explain how this may be used as an antidote to the neoliberal conception of government and the hyper-modern condition it shares with cybernetics. Simondon’s concept of ‘metastability’, we will argue, can support an alternative understanding of progress based on the idea of government as the facilitation of normative invention.

In his social theory, Simondon expands on Canguilhem’s study of social normativity. Canguilhem’s starting point is a critical reading of the biological modelling of society adopted within the French sociological tradition. In that paradigm the sociologist is asked to define the ‘normal type’ and provide the politician, the social physician, with the task of re-establishing the ‘normal state’, independently of the way society ‘appears to itself’ (Durkheim, 1924, p. 54). Canguilhem provides a decisive critique to the organic model and a radical turn to its political implications. What he considers socially ‘pathological’ is not the deviation from normality, but, on the contrary, the very normalisation of a ‘stable’ form of equilibrium. Relying on the work of the German neurologist and thinker Kurt Goldstein, he assumes that, both organically and socially, ‘the healthy state, much more than the normal state . . . is the state which allows transition to new norms’, while ‘pathological constants’ are ‘repulsive and strictly conservative’ (Canguilhem, 1991, p. 228) and in fact typical of a form of life stuck in its own ‘narrowed milieu’ and incapable of further normative invention (Goldstein, 1995, p. 188). Simondon welcomes Canguilhem’s advice to consider society in its own terms, as ‘neither machine nor life’ (Canguilhem, 2002), and takes it a step further, also attacking the technological modelling of society theorised by cybernetics.

Simondon detects in Wiener’s cybernetic theory of society an attempt to reduce the complexity of social systems to the technological model of the ‘automaton’. For Simondon automata are emblematic of the hyper-modern condition – they represent a rigidly deterministic understanding of change that de facto cancels it: ‘the automaton is entirely given in its initial state, it functions but does not become’ (Simondon, 2016, p. 401). ‘Direct adaptation’ and ‘structural stability’ are the hallmarks of ‘the perfect automaton’, and ultimately rely on the same normative assumptions implicit in the concept of ‘homeostasis’ that Wiener’s technological model implicitly sets as the ultimate goal of social organisation. Simondon reverses this value judgement while questioning the epistemic value of the model itself. The very study of technical objects shows that ‘automatism’ describes ‘a rather low degree of technical perfection’ and its idea is in fact a myth rooted in ‘economic or social’ thinking rather than in technical knowledge (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 17). In social theory, the ideas of automatism and homeostasis, although describing a crucial aspect of social dynamics – that is the closure within ‘a stereotypical, hypertelic and inevolutive adaptation’ – fail to grasp the ‘constructive and creative adaptation’ of societies. While for Wiener homeostatic stabilisation defines both the core functioning and the goal of social systems, for Simondon a degree of social homeostasis is both a prerequisite of society – the ‘rate of automatism’ that grants ‘stability and cohesion’ – and a problem (Simondon, 1958/2020, pp. 422–423).

Wiener’s hyper-modern renewal of the Hobbesian myth of a political ‘automaton’ is, from Simondon’s perspective, an epistemological mistake and a political danger. Statistical mechanics hinders a proper understanding of processes harbouring a ‘margin of indeterminacy’ (Simondon, 1958/2017, pp. 147–159) that can only be understood through a ‘non-probabilistic method’ (Simondon, 1958/2020, p. 697), and the myth of the automaton surreptitiously becomes a goal whose actual realisation would destroy the very system it was supposed to save. A perfect ‘automatic’ homeostasis, far from solving the problem of social regulation would substitute the social system’s ‘tense’ metastability with the kind of dynamic stability that ultimately leads the system to exhaustion. The self-destructive goal of automatism is in fact the cancellation of any ‘margin of indeterminacy’ with the result that ‘there is no longer any possible variation; the functioning repeats indefinitely’ (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 152) until entropy consumes all the residual potentials, leading to the ‘resolution of all tensions’, that is ‘death’. For Simondon, on the contrary, a system only keeps working and developing as long as it ‘conserves the tensions in the equilibrium of metastability instead of nullifying them in the equilibrium of stability’ (Simondon, 1958/2020, p. 226).

It is on this basis that Simondon sketches his theory of government as an alternative to Wiener’s. Playing a biological model against Wiener’s normative assumption that ‘a good homeostatic regulation is the ultimate purpose of societies, the ideal that must animate every act of government’ (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 162) Simondon theorises government as an act of normative invention relying on existing social automatisms but exceeding them. An ‘act of government’ for Simondon should be ‘grounded in homeostases so as to develop itself and to continue its coming-into-being, rather than remaining perpetually in the same state’ (p. 162). Governing is ‘inventing’ solutions aimed at making the system ‘metastable’, that is open to further invention, rather than contributing to reproduce the ideal order imagined by social theory and imposed by politics as a goal.

Many critics of neoliberal governmentality, and in particular of its ‘algorithmic’ version, have been inspired by Simondon. This is evident in their stressing the importance of creating spaces of political conflict in which social invention – the ‘transindividual . . . coupling between the inventive and organisational capacities of several subjects’ (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 258) – can take place against the dominant neoliberal neutralisation of subjectivity and conflict (Rouvroy & Berns, 2013; Stiegler, 2016). The idea of ‘progress’ may appear to be embedded in precisely the stance these theorists are criticising, but we believe that Simondon’s concept of metastability allows for a different idea of progress. In neoliberalism, the market’s ‘spontaneous’ continuation is paradoxically assumed as the goal of politics, which entails the reduction of progress to a sequence of preventive social adaptations to ever-emerging ‘local’ risks within the naturalised framework of the market. Thus, the neoliberal promotion of risk-management ethics – a lifestyle informed by constant planning, resource management, etc. – is one of the most powerful ideological tools for the preservation of social homeostasis within the market economy. This government of behaviour is capable of de-activating the potential reinvention of social forms. ‘Governmentality’ thus conceived is not simply a matter of preventing the risk of a radically disruptive event, it is about governing its possibility as such. The ‘progressive’ mechanisms of social reproduction governed by the market’s open dynamics thus entirely absorbs what is a completely different kind of ‘risk’ represented by human inventiveness and imagination, which Simondon theorises under the label of metastability.

The ‘risky’ politics of metastability theorised by Simondon is based on the assumption that progress conceived as the ‘invention of new goals’ makes radical novelty possible. This concept of progress is based on an understanding of social systems as inherently metastable because of the ‘fairly dangerous’ automatism characterising the human being, who ‘always risks inventing and equipping new structures’ (Simondon, 1958/2020, p. 423). This is not to say that Simondon resorts to a vitalist view on the exceptionality of life over matter or some sort of social evolutionism. Rather, he theorises ‘invention’ as an emergent property of the bio-technical nature of human beings and societies. This tendency towards invention is for Simondon embedded in the partial indeterminacy or ‘historicity’ that, in his ontology, defines all systems and processes (Bardin, 2021, pp. 36–37). At the level of human natural and social (i.e. ‘transindividual’) ‘historicity’, technical activity is not a mere vector of technological progress, it is an actual challenge to existing social norms. Human ‘progress’ takes place at the scale of the ‘metastable’ system formed by ‘human beings and the world’ and mediated by technical objects whose functioning exceeds all efforts of symbolisation (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 168). Progress thus conceived is not a triumphal march, it is the result of a disharmonious relationship between biological patterns that vary in the very long term of natural history, the quick accumulation of technoscientific innovations, and the social rhythm of culture that attempts to render these processes compatible with its institutional present (Simondon, 2010). This is neither ‘progress conceived as a march in a direction fixed in advance’, nor a process of ‘humanisation of nature’, but rather an aleatory process of ‘naturalisation of humans’ mediated by the ‘techno-geographical milieu’ they keep inventing (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 58).

This notion of progress entails a political risk because it leaves political practice without a safety net. In this open dynamic, the emergence of finality and hence of social invention is grounded on the structural lack of control of technical reality that nurtures the very possibility of human freedom: ‘Man [sic] frees himself from his situation of being enslaved by the finality of the whole, by learning how to create finality . . . as not to have to be passively subjected to a de facto integration’ (Simondon, 1958/2017, p. 119). This is what, according to Simondon, cybernetics itself teaches us, but crucially missing the point that risk cannot be recaptured within the existing social norms and mode of production. On the contrary, risk conceived as a structural margin of indeterminacy (‘historicity’) is embedded in technical activity, and a constant challenge to the whole ‘system of values’ (Simondon, 1958/2020, pp. 414–415). We believe Simondon’s concept of metastability opens in this sense to the possibility of moving beyond the paradoxical conflation of determinism and teleology theorised within the hyper-modern idea of progress, ultimately shared by cybernetics and neoliberalism, and allows to ‘think together nature and excess, technology and revolution’ (Toscano, 2012, pp. 107–108). It thus calls for an alternative theory of government.

Governing progress, in Simondon’s sense, is part of the collective effort of inventing mediations and solutions in which science and politics can play a crucial role if they do not reduce the reality of non-symbolic processes to their – also scientific – imagination. This kind of government will have more to do with the ‘invention’ of new technical and cultural possibilities than with the dreamed regulation of the existent by a philosopherking (Simondon, 1958/2017, pp. 161–163). Such inventions run, of course, the risk of failure, but this is precisely where their political value lies. Simondon’s concept of progress does not allow acts of government a safety net offered by social theory predictions. On the contrary, Simondon’s social theory certifies that not running the risk of normative invention is equal to suffering a different kind of defeat, the defeat of accepting an allegedly ‘progressive’ politics that, as a matter of fact, reaffirms the norms codified by the theory and resists radical change. This is precisely how Wiener sees progress grounded on the idea of the dynamic stability (homeostasis) of ‘local and temporary islands of decreasing entropy’, which ‘enables some of us to assert the existence of progress’ (Wiener, 1954/1988, p. 36). Instead, Simondon’s vision is condensed in an ethical formula that critically mirrors Wiener’s statement by reversing it, and postulates that ‘there are no lost islands in becoming, no domains eternally closed in themselves’ and ‘each gesture’ is an act of invention within a (metastable) network that connects past and future (Simondon, 1958/2020, p. 377). This ethical gesture is inherently political, it requires the active consideration of entropy and death as part of a system’s functioning, and the assumption of social invention as the core of an idea of progress to be formulated beyond the hyper-modern condition.

Conclusion: Governing progress

If one assumes the exhaustion of the (hyper-)modern idea of progress, one is also deprived of the theoretical background that has long informed the mechanical understanding of social dynamics, an understanding that still informs neoliberal governmentality. A critique of the concept of homeostasis that grounds this idea of progress, we have claimed, allows for a different approach. In this sense, our article firstly offers a historical contribution by exposing the onto-epistemological stance that underpins much theorisation of early modern science and cybernetics, liberalism and neoliberalism. Secondly, it aims to show that Simondon’s concept of metastability opens the path for a reformulation of the idea of progress within a framework that sees partial indeterminacy (or ‘historicity’) at the core of social dynamics and their government. From this perspective, knowing the social and acting politically means favouring the ‘metastable’ tension that enables scientific and political invention, defying the automatic defence of a mythically established social order. Governing progress therefore requires the radical endorsement of change, which includes the contemplation of death and failure as a necessary part of it, and therefore the opening of social systems to a future beyond the mere preservation of their own existence.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.