Framing issue---we are physchologically predisposed against emerging tech.
Thierer 14 - senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. “Permissionless Innovation: The Continuing Case for Comprehensive Technological Freedom.” Semantic Scholar. Mar 14. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Permissionless-Innovation%3A-The-Continuing-Case-for-Thierer/1744da518f1fbde038c22e04b42840019fc23bb8, AG
C: WHY DOES DOOMSAYING DOMINATE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT NEW TECHNOLOGIES?
One of the reasons that precautionary thinking often creeps into technology policy discussions is that, as already noted, our collective first reaction to new technologies often is one of dystopian dread. We assume the worst for a variety of reasons.25 In the extreme, the initial resistance to new technologies sometimes takes the form of a full-blown technopanic, which refers to “intense public, political, and academic responses to the emergence or use of media or technologies, especially by the young.”26 Some new technologies were initially resisted and even regulated because they disrupted long-standing social norms, traditions, and institutions.
What drives this fear and the resulting panics?
There are many explanations for why we see and hear so much fear and loathing in information technology policy debates today, and even some occasional technopanics.27There exist many general psychological explanations for why human beings are predisposed toward pessimism and are risk-averse to new technologies and technological developments.28 For a variety of reasons, humans are poor judges of risks to themselves or those close to them. Harvard University psychology professor Steven Pinker, author of The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature, notes:
The mind is more comfortable in reckoning probabilities in terms of the relative frequency of remembered or imagined events. That can make recent and memorable events—a plane crash, a shark attack, an anthrax infection—loom larger in one’s worry list than more frequent and boring events, such as the car crashes and ladder falls that get printed beneath the fold on page B14. And it can lead risk experts to speak one language and ordinary people to hear another.
29 Clive Thompson, a contributor to Wired and the New York Times Magazine, also notes that “dystopian predictions are easy to generate” and “doomsaying is emotionally self-protective: if you complain that today’s technology is wrecking the culture, you can tell yourself you’re a gimlet-eyed critic who isn’t hoodwinked by high-tech trends and silly, popular activities like social networking. You seem like someone who has a richer deeper appreciation for the past and who stands above the triviality of today’s life.”
30 Beyond these root-cause explanations, there are many other specific factors that contribute to the rise of technopanics and lead us to fear new technological developments. Importantly, however, each of these particular explanations builds on previous insight: Survival instincts combined with poor comparative risk-analysis skills lead many people to engage in, or buy into, technopanics.
• Generational differences: Generational differences often motivate pessimistic attitudes about the impact of technology on culture and society. Parents and policymakers who dread the changes to cultural or privacy-related norms ushered in by new technologies often forget they, too, were children once and heard similar complaints from their elders about the gadgets and content of their generation. Yet these cycles of “juvenoia”—or “exaggerated anxiety about the influence of social change on children and youth”—repeat endlessly and drive panics from one generation to the next.31
• Hypernostalgia: As already noted, many stasis-minded critics just can’t seem to let go of the past. They are too invested in it or wedded to something about it. They engage in forms of hypernostalgia and ask us to imagine there existed some earlier time that was more exceptional and valuable than the unfolding present or unpredictable future.32 Such critics are guilty of both “rosy retrospection bias,” or “the tendency to remember past events as being more positive than they actually were,”33 and a general “pessimistic bias,” or “a tendency to overestimate the severity of economic problems and underestimate the (recent) past, present, and future performance of the economy.”34 These critics fear how technological change challenges the old order, traditional values, settled norms, traditional business models, and existing institutions—even as the standard of living generally improves with each passing generation. We see this at work, for example, in debates about privacy when critics yearn for the supposed solitude of the past, or in copyright debates when critics bemoan the loss of record stores and traditional methods of experiencing music.
• Bad news sells: Many media outlets and sensationalist authors sometimes use fear-based tactics to gain influence or sell books. Fearmongering and prophecies of doom are always effective media tactics; alarmism helps media outlets break through all the noise and get heard. This is particularly true as it relates to kids and online safety, where hypothetical threats to children have often dominated media coverage.
• The role of special interests: Many groups and institutions exaggerate fears and agitate for action because they benefit from it either directly by getting more resources from government, the public, or other benefactors, or indirectly from the glow of publicity that their alarmism generates. Many companies also overhype various online concerns and then also overplay the benefits of their particular tool as a silver-bullet solution to online pornography, privacy, or cybersecurity concerns. Again, bad news sells—and, in this case, it sells products and services to fearful citizens.
• Elitist attitudes: Academic skeptics and cultural critics often possess elitist attitudes about the technologies, platforms, or new types of media content that the masses or youth adopt before they do. These elitist views are often premised on the juvenoia and hypernostalgic thinking described above. Some researchers also have an incentive to perpetuate fear because alarmist research grabs attention and attracts more funding.
• “Third-person-effect hypothesis”: When some people encounter perspectives or preferences at odds with their own, they are more likely to be concerned about the impact of those things on others throughout society and to call on government to “do something” to correct or counter those perspectives or preferences. Psychologists refer to this as the “third-person effect hypothesis,” and it explains many technopanics and resulting calls for government intervention, especially as they relate to media policy and free speech issues.35
Most technopanics blow over in time, but they can do real harm in the short term. Technopanics can encourage policymakers to adopt far-reaching controls on information flows and innovation opportunities more generally.
Worse yet, continuously elevated states of fear or panic can lead to dangerous tensions throughout society. For example, the past decade witnessed a “stranger danger” panic about hypothetical online bogeymen, leading to overblown suspicions about sexual predators online and even the general presence of males near children.46 Similarly, excessive panic over cybersecurity matters can lead to paranoia about the potential danger of visiting certain websites or using certain digital tools that are, generally speaking, safe and beneficial to the masses.47
The final reason that these fear tactics are dangerous is that they lead to a “risk mismatch.” That is, fear-based tactics and inflated threat scenarios can lead to situations where individuals and society ignore quite serious risks because they are overshadowed by unnecessary panics over nonproblems.