Tech’s inevitable, cat’s out of the bag, regulation stops the worst abuses
Mcintosh 10 – PhD in international studies from the University of Denver, Professor Emeritus of International Relations, Associate Professor of Political Science at Slippery Rock University. “The Transhuman Security Dilemma.” Journal of Evolution and Technology, Vol. 21 Issue 2. Dec 2010. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.187.1886&rep=rep1&type=pdf, AG
Personal and political security are at risk from the potential for abuse of NBIC technologies by States and other organizations. Left in the control of elites, these technologies could be used to create dystopian societies to rival anything in science fiction. In fact, the entire notion of personhood could be at risk. If these technologies can be distributed and regulated for the good of the community, however, they hold the promise of making a far better world. The diversity of humanity could be recognized as a value to be protected, even as people learn to see beyond external forms to the humanity within. Yet even under the best regulatory regime, the pressures of competition and the desire of each individual to improve set up the potential for a dilemma that affects not merely the interaction and security of states, but the lives and liberty of each person. This is not a danger that can be edited out of the human genome, for it is inherent in the nature of competitive interaction, coupled with the expected comparative advantage of those who choose to take advantage of the new technologies. Here, then, is the conundrum: in our attempt to remake ourselves, we will not entirely leave our old selves behind, any more than we have escaped our animal past, and nor will we escape the pressures inherent in social and political systems. The balance of factors argues that change is coming. Evolution never ends, even when it is to some extent self-directed. Yet like so many other technologies, the tools of evolution-by-design will not solve the most basic problems of human or global security. There are things we cannot or will not leave behind. Trapped by the dilemmas inherent in security and economic competition, political and security issues will continue to challenge our descendants, no matter what forms or enhancements they possess.