The alt is naïve primitivism that is worse than what we have now.
Bratton 21 – Benjamin Bratton’s work spans Philosophy, Architecture, Computer Science and Geopolitics, He is Professor of Visual Arts at University of California, San Diego, Program Director of The Terraforming program at the Strelka Institute, and author of several books including “The Stack: On Software and Sovereignty.” “The Revenge of the Real - Politics for a Post-Pandemic World.” June 2021. AG
There are certainly aesthetic and stylistic reasons to prefer homogenous village-scale communities to the “alienating” anonymity of the big city. Indeed, there is a direct if implicit anti-urbanism in anti-automation politics and aesthetics. Some may have forgotten that, despite their bucolic pleasures, small towns are also facial recognition–based social control systems from which many people have given their lives to escape.
For example, the petit bourgeois Primitivism of the all-organic neighborhood farmers market stands as a kind of wishful idealization of what infrastructure might be and “where things come from.” Although it provides an anodyne experience, its symbolism reeks of a Restorationist cultural politics that symptomatically prioritizes ambiance at hand over equity at scale. It is an aesthetic indulgence claiming to be an ethical politics that is claiming to be a more resilient economics. And yet, the world cannot actually “be like this always”; it is not possible for every piece of fruit to be handed to you in person.
One reason the positive biopolitics for which I advocate does not already exist is because of the persistent illusion that immediate participatory emergence is the righteous means and ends. For some who advise that mutual care efforts are not just tactical responses at the edge of the network but should be the whole of the network, the implied logical preference is for a less-systematic, decentralized, volunteerist rewilding of health care and of biopolitics more generally. To be sure, that would be a recipe for even worse disaster. Just ask Brazil.