Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Thus, when exploring how we can debate it, “we must resist deciding in favor of catastrophe or boredom, for in doing so, the entirety of cyberwar will certainly escape us. Instead, we must attempt to interrogate the history and discourses of cyberwar… as it hides in the theoretical space between war and nonwar.”

--green highlighting was already read in the tag and doesn’t need to be read twice!

Joque, 18—PhD from the European Grad School, researches philosophy, technology and media and is the visualization librarian at the University of Michigan, go blue (Justin, “Root Kit,” Deconstruction Machines: Writing in the Age of Cyberwar, Introduction, 1-8, dml)

At the start of the twenty-first century, we are faced with the increasing dependence of our life support systems on global networks and the possibility of system-wide catastrophe. From energy supplies to agriculture to the global climate, these systems are now directly exposed to global fluctuations and, with them, the possibility that a local breakdown could spread globally. We seem to be learning repeatedly that the unavoidable dark side of our networks of communication, production, finance, and information is the ever-present threat of contagion and cascading system failure.

Nowhere is the logic of this threat of global system breakdown clearer than in the expanding discourse around cyberwar. Over the past decades, a growing chorus of politicians, military strategists, computer security experts, and journalists has cited the dangers and opportunities that the subversion of digital systems provides for future conflicts. Governments are investing increasing amounts of energy and money in guaranteeing that they can attack, subvert, and monitor opponents’ digital networks, from command-and-control systems to banking to electric grids. The early outbreaks of cyberwar, such as a series of Russian attacks on Estonia in 2007, have resulted mainly in temporary inconveniences, but as militaries invest in being able to destroy physical infrastructure through networked attacks and governments attempt to subvert other states, future cyberwars threaten the possibility of massive destruction and destabilization.

Cyberwar seizes directly on the networked nature of twenty-firstcentury economic, military, and communicative power by exploiting vulnerabilities, bugs, and insecurities in the code and systems that run these networks; the more well connected and technologically advanced one is, the more one has to fear the contagious threat of both networked accidents and attacks. The military investment in cyberwar and the political, media, and economic responses to acts of cyberwar speak directly to the complicated nature of our networks and information technologies. It is here, where these technical, programmatic, and social systems begin to break down and are transformed into sites of military intervention, that we can most fully begin to elucidate what is at stake in these global networks.

DEFINING CYBERWAR

There is no easily agreed-upon definition of cyberwar. Even within closely related literatures, there exists an ongoing debate over what constitutes cyberwar. Some, such as Rid, who has written at length declaring there is no such thing as cyberwar, question whether such a concept is a helpful lens for thinking the present situation at all.1 The term cyberwar, in most invocations, refers to the notion of cyberspace and the possibility of a war carried out in this global networked space, wherein computer systems are taken over to disrupt and surveil an enemy’s communication and networked infrastructure either as part of a “kinetic” war or as a form of low-level conflict aimed at gaining geopolitical advantages. Though it is important to follow authors, strategists, legal scholars, and others wherever they happen to see “cyberwar” occurring, one particular etymological meaning will guide this inquiry. The prefix cyber- refers to the term cybernetics. Cybernetics, originating from the Greek kubernētēs (“steersman” or “governor”), is the science and study of systems, their structures, regulation, emergent properties, and possibilities, spanning disciplines from technology to biology to society. By explicitly thinking the cyber- in cyberwar as referring to systems, it will be fruitful to understand cyberwar as a war against systems: computer systems, state systems, systems of organization, and even systems of meaning.

This etymological understanding of cyberwar closely mirrors some of the earliest deployments of this term. One of the first unclassified uses of the term cyberwar comes from a 1992 publication by Arnett.2 For him, the term means the replacement of human operators with machines that decide on targets, trajectories, movement, and so on—essentially the culmination of a long history of the insertion of “intelligent machines” into the arsenal of war fighting. That same year, Der Derian used the term “in the sense of a technologically generated, televisually linked, and strategically gamed form of violence.”3 Arquilla and Ronfeldt subsequently published a paper defining cyberwar as a tactical and strategic movement whereby communication, information, and the visibility of the battlespace become the central concern. They assert that while information technology brings cyberwar to the fore, it is not necessarily a technological phenomenon. In fact, the exemplary case of cyberwar they recount is a thirteenth-century Mongol offensive against Khwarizm, where the Mongols succeeded in defeating a significantly larger army by cutting off communications and disrupting the control of forces.

These definitions complement each other. Der Derian and Arnett’s definitions focus on carrying out a kinetic war through the cybernetic organization of humans and technology, while Arquilla and Ronfeldt’s definition stresses disrupting all of the enemy’s cybernetic systems regardless of whether they are human, technological, or a combination. We are faced, then, with something much more expansive than war in cyberspace; rather, what these authors begin to explore in the early 1990s is an understanding of war in which one tries to construct and defend systems of communicating, knowing, controlling, and, ultimately, existing. Simultaneously, one attempts to disrupt, infiltrate, corrupt, and destroy these same systems belonging to the enemy. Arquilla and Ronfeldt state that such a strategy “may aim to confound people’s fundamental beliefs about the nature of their culture, society, and government, partly to foment fear but perhaps mainly to disorient people and unhinge their perceptions.”4

Clearly this is not completely new. Belligerents have always attempted to deceive their opponents and disrupt economies and governments. Furthermore, war has often had as a central objective the destruction of one critical system and the infiltration of another: the body and the territory of the opponent. Despite this, we can outline three critical factors that mark cyberwar as a historical shift. First, proponents of cyberwar, such as Arquilla and Ronfeldt, stress that in cyberwar, information and structures of knowing become central rather than peripheral to conflict. They say that cyberwar “means disrupting if not destroying the information and communications systems, broadly defined to include even military culture, on which an adversary relies in order to know itself.”5 Second, cyberwar attempts to disrupt not only the enemy’s knowledge but also the entire structure of knowledge. In short, cyberwar invests epistemology itself as a battlespace. Third, cyberwar seeps outside of “war” proper. In calling into question modes of knowing, cyberwar breaks down the limits of the time and space of war.

Thus the term cyberwar describes two distinct but related phenomena. On one hand, it is a strategy for fighting war, and we will include whatever is named cyberwar by strategists, legal theorists, authors, and warriors. On the other hand, we will mean a historical shift—in a sense, a global cyberwar that marks a tendency whereby the critical element in war becomes the flow of information and the fortification and disruption of systems. In making this shift, cyberwar has opened an epistemological and cybernetic battlespace wherein notions of war, enmity, and knowing become directly contestable. While these concepts have always been unstable and problematic, cyberwar seizes them as systems of direct military intervention, turning what was once a question for philosophers into a domain of the global battlespace. In its most abstract sense, cyberwar has become an event that calls everything including itself into question at the moment it arrives. It is the historical possibility that all systems may break down—or, in their military occupation, be caused to break down—but it is also possible that cyberwar may undermine itself before anything actually “happens.” Cyberwar as historical event marks a moment of radical militarized unknowability.

A COMPROMISED HISTORY

Many discussions of cyberwar, be they historical, strategic, or legal, begin not with the earliest examples or contemporary attacks but rather with a future catastrophe that demonstrates the danger of our overreliance on vast, connected, yet vulnerable systems. These catastrophes normally start with a nonstate actor or a “rogue” state hacking into key networks, destroying critical infrastructure in the United States or multiple European countries. Airplanes crash into each other, trains derail, communication channels shut down, and electrical systems are disabled. Not only are these systems forced to shut down but they are hijacked and made to spin out of control, sometimes destroying themselves so completely that they would take months to return to normal usage. These imagined scenarios often place the reader at the time immediately following the catastrophe. At this point in time, one can survey the wreckage of our technological hubris before the aftermath begins in earnest. It is the moment when the full scale of a possible collapse is revealed but not yet realized.6

Where a historical account begins in the past, it often starts with a CIA attempt to secretly destroy a Soviet gas pipeline.7 According to Thomas Reed, a National Security Council staffer, in 1982, the CIA was able to insert an intentionally faulty piece of code into a pump that the Soviet Union obtained from a Canadian company. According to Reed’s account, the pump was installed in the Trans-Siberian gas pipeline; varying pump speeds and valve settings produced extreme pressures that caused an explosion large enough to be detected by U.S. satellites. The secret introduction of a so-called logic bomb—a somewhat antiquated term for a malicious piece of code inserted into software—has been touted by a number of commentators as one of the earliest examples of cyberwar.

Although Reed, who made this story public for the first time in a 2004 book, never referred to this attack as cyberwar, this story has become something of an origin myth for those who write about cyberwar more generally.8 The event prefigures a number of issues that arise again and again in the myriad discourses surrounding cyberwar. Most important, it becomes clear how vulnerable complex systems of computation have become. These systems aggregate code written across the globe and parts manufactured outside the purview of their owners into complex networks that belie attempts to control them. Computation is exposed to the exterior places in which it is produced.

Furthermore, even if unintentionally, the use of this event as the first in a series of international cyberattacks offers an answer to a question that is often asked of theorists of cyberwar: how can such an event lay claim to being “war”? Is this merely sabotage? Placing the origin in the Cold War responds to those critics of cyberwar hype who believe it is nothing more than a collection of high-tech tools in service of the ancient techniques of spying, deception, and sabotage. For the Cold War proved that wars need not be explosive and could consist of decades of low-level conflict. As Virilio says of the threat posed by nuclear weapons, “the weapon’s serious danger is not that it could explode tomorrow. . . but that for thirty years it has been destroying society.”9 The bomb’s destructive power has been felt directly through its threat. Likewise, as can be seen in the futuristic scenarios described earlier, cyberwar seems always to threaten catastrophe. Placing cyberwar’s origins in the Cold War suggests the possibility of a nonwar that is as destructive as a kinetic war. The second half of the twentieth century has demonstrated that even in the absence of a hot war, conflict can destroy governments and societies.

Furthermore, at least for those theorists and strategists of cyberwar in the United States, this origin story contextualizes contemporary cyberwar discourses in another way. Several military and political commentators writing about cyberwar as a strategic area of study were the same theorists who worked on nuclear deterrence strategy in the latter part of the Cold War. A number of authors—many of whom work for the RAND Corporation, a think tank that was created in 1948 to provide research and analysis to the U.S. military—even attempt to employ strategies learned from nuclear deterrence research to mitigate military hacking and offensive use of global networks.10 Tying the origin of cyberwar to Cold War global strategic thinking offers an opportunity for those making the transition from strategizing in a bipolar world defined by nuclear weapons to a multipolar, interconnected global economy.

While the Siberian pipeline attack’s similarity to contemporary issues surrounding cyberwar is noteworthy, the most striking aspect of the whole affair is that it possibly never happened. Following the release of Reed’s book, an ex-KGB officer with direct knowledge of the region at the time disputes Reed’s account. He acknowledged there was an explosion but claims it was at a different, smaller pipeline and was caused by specific construction mistakes, not by faulty equipment.11 Moreover, no known media reports from the time confirm an explosion, which Reed claims was the size of a small nuclear blast. Other than Reed’s account, no other documentation has been found, and the CIA has never confirmed the event.12

The origins of cyberwar in this event are seemingly impossible to verify. Pipeline explosions were common at the time, and there would have been no way for the CIA to know for certain if it was caused by their purposefully faulty equipment or accidently faulty Soviet equipment. Given our current evidence, the event is completely unknowable. Moreover, even if there was an explosion, it is impossible to verify if it was the logic bomb or a mechanical failure. Depending on one’s perspective, either the fake event or fake refutations seep into the historical record like a computer virus corrupting the system’s memory.

Thus, in a largely unrecognized way, this event is archetypal for cyberwar. Cyberwar and cybersecurity weave a complicated relationship between the knowable and the unknowable. Our networked world has become so complex in sheer technical terms that the system as a whole cannot be known from the outside. Mapping even just the public Web has become a scholarly pursuit in its own right. Computers and networks represent information as tiny bits on a magnetic disk or pulses of light across a cable that, owing to their size, speed, and complexity, are on their own essentially meaningless and impenetrable to human observers. One always interacts with abstractions and complex representations of the material reality of computing. Cyberwar, in attacking these systems, is always on the verge of being meaningless itself. Moreover, in attacking systems of knowing that guarantee information, a successful attack impairs even our ability to know if something has happened. Cyberwar is fought precisely in this space between the possible catastrophe and the possibility of nothing happening at all.

The event itself is ambiguous and our public historical record is already compromised. It could of course be argued that all history is ambiguous, constructed, and selective. What is unique in the case of cyberwar is that the whole structure of knowing and observing is opened as a site of direct military intervention. It is not only a question of interpretation and selective archives. The entire archive and our ability to comprehend the archive may be attacked at any moment. In a sense, we are dealing with a limit case of historical unknowability—not just ambiguity but a military attack on the data of history itself. Now, even if the victors write history, it may no longer be written from data they control.

Thus an effective understanding of cyberwar will only be possible by not prematurely deciding in favor of an event happening or not happening. Cyberwar operates both as a strategy and as a mediatized cultural phenomenon directly in the space between happening and not happening. It succeeds as a military strategy by never succeeding too much. It always seems to be leading us to the verge of catastrophe and at the same time to an interminable boredom where nothing will ever actually happen. Cyberwar could easily be dismissed as not really being war or violent, but what is so virulent and dangerous about cyberwar is its ability to atomize and distribute warfare into everyday life. Cyberwar succeeds so much more effectively for being either overhyped or dismissed. Ultimately, we must resist deciding in favor of catastrophe or boredom, for in doing so, the entirety of cyberwar will certainly escape us. Instead, we must attempt to interrogate the history and discourses of cyberwar by following its vacillations between these two poles as it hides in the theoretical space between war and nonwar.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.