Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cybernetics has robbed meaning of its stability.

Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19(Nick and Svitlana, Associate professor at the University of Western Ontario, Professor of Communications at Simon Fraser University “Cyberwar and Revolution”, Chapter Two, CS)

There is no longer a Master-Signifier that stabilizes meaning, that knits together the chain of signifiers and hinders their tendencies to float off into indeterminacy. While the absence of such a master might seem to produce a situation of complete openness and freedom—no authority is telling the subject what to do, what to desire, how to structure its choices—Žižek argues that in fact the result is unbearable, suffocating closure. A “setting of electronically mediated subjectivity [that] is one of infinite doubt and ultimate reflexifisation” intensifies “the fundamental uncertainty accompanying the impossibility of totalization” in a symbolic environment where “there is always another option, link, opinion, nuance or contingency that we haven’t taken into account” (Dean 2014, 212). Computational propaganda that aims to mystify invasions and occupations, or promote cynical disaffection from an adversary’s political system, actively weaponizes the “decline in symbolic efficiency,” but it is endemic to the whole field of cyberwar. The extreme uncertainty and opacity of cyberwar do not, however, inhibit the interpellative effects of contending cyberwar apparatuses as they summon up cybersoldiers, patriotic hackers, vigilante militias, and security-conscious digital citizens. On the contrary, the problems of verifying or disproving multiple alarms and accusations accelerates these processes and puts them into overdrive. To put this point in psychoanalytic terms, as we noted previously, commentators on Althusser have criticized the appropriation of Lacan’s theories of the subject in his account of ISAs. These critics point out that what Althusser misses in Lacan’s account is that the subject is always incomplete; it is precisely what can never be fixed by a specific subject position or identity. However, the implication of this incompletion is not that the subject remains some untouched and primordial haven of authenticity but rather that this lack drives to ever more compulsive (because unfulfillable) attempts to attain a definitive identity. Translating this into political terms, we would say that it is the inescapably incomplete, provisional, and easily falsified nature of all accounts of cyberwar that energizes the adoption of increasingly militarized, extreme, paranoid, and unshakable subject positions vis-à-vis its alleged events.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.