Prefer our theory of power. Modern IR analysis is distorted and the affs ideological diagram of The Stack effectively maps the digital complexities that make up the modern age of geopolitics.
Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 2019—associate professor of information and media studies at the University of Western Ontario; assistant professor of communication at Simon Fraser University (Nick and Svitlana, Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism) //ansel
CRITICISM OF ARMS, ARMS OF CRITICISM Our project requires an analysis in terms very different from those of official discussions of cyberwar, and its echoes in the media, discussions often cast in a language that assumes and imposes the inescapable necessity of a technocratic realpolitik and prepares and armors its audiences for trajectories of mounting crisis. Just as, in previous decades, we were habituated to apocalyptic prospects by an anodyne “nukespeak,” so today we are being trained to a more creeping catastrophe by a militarized “cyberspeak” that promises us resilience against hostile intrusion through social media service upgrades, improved smartphones, and the steady surrender of individual and social freedoms to enhanced powers of the security forces. This numbing discourse must be broken open and defamiliarized. The topic of cyberwar has, however, largely been ignored by critical social theorists, sometimes where one would least expect. The most ambitious and sophisticated of all recent scholarly attempts to conceptualize the scope and depth of the internet as a technosocial institution is in our opinion Benjamin Bratton’s (2016) The Stack: On Software and Sovereignty. For Bratton, the concept of a “stack” (in computer science, a collection of data elements that must be accessed in a specific order) provides a metaphor for the architecture of the internet, envisaged as a layered series of terrestrial, platform, urban, communication, interface, and user operations. The combined interactions of these different digital levels, Bratton argues, now compose an “accidental megastructure” of global governance either destabilizing or reinforcing the spatial and temporal boundaries of the nation-state. Yet what is striking is the limited attention this otherwise comprehensive, virtuoso examination of digital networks gives to that most sovereign of activities, war, and the possibility of what Bratton (2016, 298) glancingly refers to as “Stack versus Stack” conflicts, a topic that he defers as a matter for later study. This is all the more surprising because, as Bratton acknowledges in a footnote, the modeling of the internet as a “stack” of technosocial activities was pioneered within U.S. cyberwar agencies with very nonaccidental strategic agendas (441n8). One of the NSA documents released by Snowden, “Bad Guys Are Everywhere, Good Guys Are Somewhere” (Risen and Poitras 2013; Müller-Maguhn 2014), contains a diagram of the architecture of the internet in terms of an interdependent “stack” of geographical, physical network, logical, cyberpersona, and persona levels, derived from the work of national security intellectual Paul Rosenzweig (2012). The diagram is defined as a tool that enables the NSA to conceive how to scan and disrupt the operations of antagonists at multiple levels: “the stack” is a concept for cyberwar fighting. No account of networked sovereigns and subjects can now postpone reckoning with this reality, so we hope that our book can supplement Bratton’s, even though it is written in a different political register