The Tallinn Manual is an ethical and juridical failure.
Barrett 17(Edward, Ethics professor in the Department of Leadership, Ethics and Law, “On the Relationship Between the Ethics and the Law of War: Cyber Operations and Sublethal Harm”, CS)
To begin, the manual’s purely legalistic assumptions—derived from applicable treaties and customary international law—can generate ethically problematic definitions of just cause. Functionally, Article’s concept of armed attack and the ethical concept of just cause are the same: they define a casus belli to which one may justifiably respond with lethal defensive force. But the related legal definitions of “uses of force” and “armed attacks” can—from an ethical perspective—lead to both overly permissive and overly restrictive conclusions. Following international law, the manual defines uses of force as acts “that injure or kill persons or damage or destroy objects.” Those of sufficient “scale and effects” are deemed armed attacks. On the one hand, this framework can be too permissive vis-à-vis property. Ethically speaking, large-scale property destruction and damage do not in themselves justify lethal defensive harm; the property in question must be lifesustaining, and this prerequisite is not intrinsic to the definition of armed attack. On the other hand, this framework can be too restrictive vis-à-vis persons. From an ethical perspective, one may respond to unjustified and culpable threats to life with lethal force if necessary; the scale of death is irrelevant. While legally limiting forceful responses to cases of armed attack–level fatalities might promote utility, it also might contravene the moral right of self-defense. This problem accounts for the “contrary view” of the United States following the International Court of Justice’s Nicaragua judgment, which asserted that “any illegal use of force can qualify as an armed attack triggering the right of self-defense; there is no gravity threshold distinguishing illegal uses of force from armed attacks.” In addition to being simultaneously overly permissive and restrictive, legal definitions of just cause can also be arbitrary because of the way in which judgments are made. What counts as harm sufficient to rise to the level of an armed attack is determined through practice, which in reality can mean that the definitions of stronger parties will prevail. Reliance on international law therefore does little to discourage wars initiated by the powerful in defense of “national interests” that merely support a desired standard of living. A dialogue between ethics and international law thus serves to provide necessary critiques of self-serving legal interpretations of both kinetic and cyber operations. A second ad bellum-related flaw in the manual involves the relationship between culpability and just cause. In assessments of whether an armed attack has occurred, the experts were “divided over the issue of whether the effects in question must have been intended.” The minority of experts asserted that espionage “unexpectedly result[ing] in significant damage” should not be considered an armed attack. On the other hand, the majority concluded that “intention is irrelevant in qualifying an operation as an armed attack and that only scale and effects matter.” According to their analysis, victims of unintentional grave harm would possess a right to respond in kind, if necessary. But from an ethical perspective, on the relationship between the ethics and the law of war majority’s position is erroneous. Culpable acts are those done intentionally, freely, and with knowledge or vincible ignorance of the relevant normative and empirical facts; and only culpable murderous acts compromise one’s capacity for justice and dignity to the degree required to forfeit one’s right to life and incur liability to lethal defensive harm. Although the response advocated by the manual’s majority would be excused if the victim were unable to know that the act was unintended, the response would still not be justified. Third, the discussion of ad bellum proportionality is problematic primarily because it misunderstands the criterion, which requires that the total expected good caused by a war outweighs the total expected harm. Instead, the manual asserts that the issue at hand is “how much force . . . is permissible once force is deemed necessary” (that is, once last resort has been satisfied), and concludes that the proportionality criterion limits this amount to “that required to end the situation that has given rise to the right to act in self-defense.” In other words, the manual stipulates that the ad bellum criterion of proportionality, instead of ensuring that the goods at stake are commensurate with anticipated harms, requires one to use only a necessary amount of force to put an end to the situation. One can easily imagine a case in which this leads to massive defensive retaliation to stop a much less harmful attack. Additionally, the entire analysis is misplaced, as the imperative to use only necessary amounts of force is an in bello issue. Fourth, the manual’s treatment of when temporary functionality losses would qualify as a just cause is self-contradictory. Like kinetic weapons, cyber weapons can physically destroy or damage computers. But because of their potential to be transitory or reversible, cyberattacks can also merely compromise functionality. While permanent losses of functionality can create the same effect as physical destruction, temporary functionality losses are unique to cyber operations and require additional analysis. Part of the manual’s discussion on functionality occurs in the in bello section that defines a cyberattack. Associating attacks on objects with damage or destruction, the majority asserted that interference with functionality would qualify as damage and thus constitute a use of force only if “restoration of functionality requires replacement of physical components.” Accordingly, a transitory or reversible loss of function not requiring the replacement of physical components would constitute neither an attack nor, by extension, a just cause. But elsewhere in the manual some experts argue that actions not resulting in physical damage would qualify as an armed attack if the ensuing negative effects were—although others still maintain that direct “harm to persons or physical damage to property” is a precondition for an armed attack. Ethically speaking, justified responses would be a function of both an attack’s culpability and overall effects. Assuming culpability, a temporary loss of the functionality of a system that was not physically damaged would be a casus belli if the event resulted in death, for example, in the event of the temporary disabling of an air traffic control system that caused mass casualties. Fifth, from an ethical perspective, although the manual’s treatment of in bello proportionality is excellent, it could be improved in one way: Since civilians on both sides retain all of their rights, one should not dismiss consequences such as loss of email or banking services from collateral damage calculations. Of course, such costs could be awarded relatively low values. Sixth and finally, the manual unfortunately adopts a purely legal approach to targeting nonparticipating civilians, arguing that cyber operations that do not qualify as “uses of force”—ones that merely inconvenience—may be intentionally directed against civilian objects such as computers. Interference with functionality is permitted if physical repair or operating system reinstallation is not required. Data, related or unrelated to functionality, is also targetable. Large-scale email blockage also does not qualify as an attack. Additionally, and as mentioned earlier, none of these harms need to be minimized or considered in collateral damage proportionality assessments. That these conclusions follow logically from their premises demonstrates the danger of purely legal approaches. From an ethical perspective, intentionally harming civilians, in addition to usually being strategically ineffective, is unjust. In peacetime or wartime, persons who have not culpably transgressed the rights of others have forfeited none of their own, and are not liable to any degree of harm—not even the inconveniences described above. Accordingly, domestic and international statutes should define these injustices as punishable crimes, and appropriate executive and legislative oversight should be implemented. And if nonparticipating civilians are to be affected by cyber operations before or during war, these effects must be minimized and weighed in the ways currently associated with, respectively, economic sanctions and dual-use objects.