Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cybersecurity is “the security of the environment formed by physical and non-physical components and characterised by the use of computers and other networked devices.” Debates about US-NATO security cooperation are more accurate when they theorize states as assemblages rather than unitary actors.

Collier, 18—Cyber Security DPhil Candidate based at the Department of Politics and International Relations, and the Centre for Doctoral Training in Cyber Security, University of Oxford, formerly worked at the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (Jamie, “Cyber Security Assemblages: A Framework for Understanding the Dynamic and Contested Nature of Security Provision,” Politics and Governance, Volume 6, Issue 2, July 2018, dml)

Refreshed thinking is required to better understand the provision of cyber security and the configuration of cyber security actors. Here, the term cyber security is defined as the security of the environment formed by physical and non-physical components and characterised by the use of computers and other networked devices. Cyber security actors, by definition, provide security in some capacity. Yet this does not mean that all actors strive to achieve a single, unitary concept of security. The prevalence of private actors means that cyber security is often provided by actors who prioritise other commercial objectives over security. Encryption disputes between the US government and technology firms show that different actors have altogether different motivations.

This makes the study of the different cyber security providers, and how they interact with one another essential. The concept of global cyber security assemblages provides a conceptual anchor that provides a means for further understanding these issues. The term provides a more appropriate concept for understanding contemporary cyber security contexts when compared to more traditional frameworks. The security assemblage term refers to new hybrid structures that are often simultaneously public and private, global and local. The use of the term is part of an emerging body of scholarship within IR literature that seeks to empirically assess complex structures where a range of different global and local, public and private security agents, interact, cooperate and compete to produce new institutions, practices and forms of security governance that cannot be captured neatly though the boundaries of nation states (Abrahamsen & Williams, 2011; Williams, 2016).

The assemblage concept therefore moves away from the traditional centre of the nation-state to multi-layered, networked configurations that are able to accommodate a range of entities including (inter)governmental, para-governmental, nongovernmental, and private organisations (Voelkner, 2013). The boundaries of an assemblage can be drawn in alternative ways to the traditional contours of national borders. They can be drawn to examine the provision of security within a territory but can also be used to examine security or governance contexts that are inherently international. The issue of internet governance, for example, comprises a global assemblage of actors, albeit one dominated by US actors (Carr, 2014). Perhaps the most defining characteristic of the assemblage concept is therefore an accommodation of the forces of globalisation and a scepticism of rigid borders and distinctions. Of course, much of the above relates closely to other terms including actor network theory; indeed, the difference between the terms is one of emphasis, rather than kind (Acuto & Curtis, 2014) with the similarities and differences between the two concepts discussed in greater detail elsewhere (Acuto & Curtis, 2014; Müller & Schurr, 2016).

For the purposes of understanding cyber security provision, it is the notion of assembly and disassembly— where actors relinquish, transfer and develop capacities and functions—that is central to the added value of the assemblage concept. As security functions emerge and are captured by either public or private actors, actors assemble greater capabilities and responsibilities. As private actors increasingly take on strategic, ethical, and foreign-policy alignment issues that were previously outside their purview, they are assembling into more political actors. Conversely, as aspects of cyber security are increasingly regulated and managed by states, other aspects of private actors’ capabilities and responsibilities are disassembling. Contemporary cyber security practices are replete with these instances of assembly and disassembly. Assemblage thinking therefore pays attention to the instability of security networks. While cyber security is provided by a vast array of actors, assemblage thinking also highlights the contestation related to the roles and responsibilities of security actors. In light of emerging and shifting actors, the point is not to demonstrate that states are stronger or weaker. Rather, the intention is to examine the complex configuration of actors that maintain contingent and multifaceted relationships with each other (relationships that cannot be captured by static and often state-centric theories). Cyber security is replete with global and local, public and private agents whose relationships are deeply competitive as well as cooperative, conflictual, and at times coordinated. While the concept of a security assemblage has been applied to cyber security in previous literature (Stevens, 2012, 2016, pp. 181–186), the argument for why and how the concept should be used and applied to cyber security remains underdeveloped—an imbalance this article hopes to correct.

These hybrid structures are clearly observed through contemporary examples with the cyber security of critical national infrastructure (CNI) in the UK a case in point. The vast majority of CNI is owned and managed by corporations—itself a broad church that includes a variety of actor types including not-for-profit community owned private limited firms, regional and UK-based firms, multinational firms (National Grid operates in both the US and UK for example, probing traditional global-local distinctions) and state-owned or quasi-state owned firms (the now approved Hinkley Point nuclear plant will be owned and managed by a combination of French-state majority owned EDF energy and Chinese state-owned China General Nuclear Power Corporation) (Ward, Pickard, & Stothard, 2016). As a collective, these corporations cannot neatly be categorised as ‘private’ given the variety of entities including the presence of both partially and fully state-owned entities. Corporations provide cyber security alongside a range of government departments, including GCHQ and its subsidiary, the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC); the Cabinet Office, the various government departments that are largely responsible for infrastructure related to their department and related institutions such as the Centre for the Protection of National Infrastructure (Collier, 2016). All of these government entities have their own identities, agendas and motivations—a reality that means that ‘the government’ is not necessarily a coherent entity at all. Adding to the plethora of actors are various international organisations and multilateral bodies. Various actors work together within this cyber security assemblage, often in unusual ways. With Chinese-based firm Huawei providing communication equipment for CNI organisations, GCHQ employees will routinely monitor, take apart and inspect the equipment supplied (due to security concerns) at a centre that is itself funded by Huawei (Rifkind, 2013; Rosenzweig, 2013).

An assemblage approach also considers the normative agendas behind the traditional categories and distinctions used in IR literature. Pursuing assemblage thinking means paying attention to the relationships between a variety of actors and the forces that impel them to act in the way they do (Lisle, 2013). The process of assemblage formation is not neutral but deeply political. Different actors have clashing views on what aspects of cyber security should be ‘public’ or ‘private’ as well as where the boundaries of these distinctions lie. Returning to the UK example, the UK 2016 Cyber Security Strategy declared that market based solutions to cyber security have ‘not produced the required pace and scale of change’, meaning that ‘Government has to lead the way and intervene more directly by bringing its influence and resources to bear’ in a move that overtly seeks to increase the government’s cyber security purview (HM Government, 2016). On the other hand, governments have also sought to relinquish both their authority and responsibility of cyber security issues within other contexts in order to avoid the backlash of security failings (Carr, 2016). This is also observed in recent US encryption disputes that reflect broader political disagreements about the agency afforded to different actors. Law enforcement organisations’ interests in accessing intelligence on devices clash with technology firms who instead seek to protect their customers’ data from government access, (albeit while simultaneously selling user data to other businesses and using it themselves for the purposes of targeted advertisements). Various government entities compete with each other for ownership of cyber security and the tax revenue that accompanies the issue. Alternative visions of cyber security are proposed within such intra-governmental competition—the issue may be framed through a military, business or criminal prism depending on the government entity that seeks to capture the issue. These tensions are mirrored at the international level where various multilateral organisations compete for relevance on the issue including the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO); the United Nations (UN) through the Group of Governmental Experts on Information Security; The European Union Agency for Network and Information Security (ENISA); the International Telecommunication Union (ITU); etc. It is this notion of contestation that further distinguishes an assemblage approach from other theoretical lenses that merely acknowledge the importance of units other than states or the increasingly blurry lines that exist between different types of actors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.