Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is an assemblage, “a number of disparate and heterogeneous elements convoked together into a single discernible formation.” That’s limited and predictable.

Handeland, 19—Master of Science candidate in International Relations, Department of International Environment and Development Studies, Norwegian University of Life Sciences (Lars, “Exploring the knowledge-politics nexus in global governance: A case study of the anti-chemical weapons assemblage in Syria (2013-2017),” https://nmbu.brage.unit.no/nmbu-xmlui/bitstream/handle/11250/2642646/Handeland2019.pdf, dml)

Originally developed as a concept by the philosopher Gilles Deleuze and his writing partner, the psychoanalyst Felix Guattari, defined assemblage in the following way: “An assemblage is a number of disparate and heterogeneous elements convoked together into a single discernible formation” (Deleuze & Guattari as cited Bueger, 2014c, p. 60). Importantly, the French word they use is agencement. Derived from the verb agencer, the noun agencement can roughly be translated into the ‘act of assembling’, and highlights the ongoing and neverending processes of shifts and transformations (Phillips, 2006). 8

The term ‘convoked’ implies that they are brought together towards a function or purpose. Indeed, “every assemblage is characterized by the process of constituting a "territory" that holds together distinct or heterogenous elements…”(Hayden, 1998, p. 96). The territory, then, comes to signify the identity of a given assemblage, which is derived from its purpose or function. Indeed, the assemblage is not “a random collection of things, since there is a sense that an assemblage is a whole of some sort that expresses some identity and claims a territory” (Wise, 2005, p. 77).

Next, understanding how assemblages ‘claims a territory’ requires a look at some of the associated ideas found in the work of Deleuze and Guattari. As such, the terms territorialization-deterritorialization, the material-expressive axis, and practices of assembling must be outlined first.

To start with, I think it is worth quoting Deleuze and Guattari at length here, giving their original formulation of an assemblage’s features:

On a first, horizontal axis, an assemblage comprises two segments, on of content, the other of expression. On the one hand it is a machinic assemblage of bodies, of actions and passions, an intermingling of bodies reacting to one another; on the other hand it is a collective assemblage of enunciation, of acts and statements, of incorporeal transformations attributed to bodies. Then on a vertical axis, the assemblage has both territorial sides, or reterritorialized sides, which stabilize it, and cutting edges of deterritorialization, which carry it away. (Deleuze & Guattari, 2013, pp. 102–103)

In other words, there are two axes in in the assemblage; a vertical axis of territorialization and deterritorialization, and a horizontal axis of components (DeLanda, 2006, p. 12). The vertical axis captures the stability of the assemblage, i.e. whether its internal stability increases or decreases , whereas the horizontal consists of elements ranging from the purely material to the purely expressive (Patton, 2006, p. 27). These four features gives the assemblage a tetravalent systematization, which signifies the means of combination (Dewsbury, 2011). Next, I unpack these two axes to discuss and assess their applicability as thinking tools for studies of international relations.

On the vertical material-expressive axis, there is the material or machinic end, which consist of matter and bodies (Patton, 2006, p. 27). On the other end there is what Deleuze and Guattari calls the collective assemblage of enunciation, a rather broad category of different expressive elements including discourses, knowledges, semiotics and gestures. Taken together, the heterogeneous elements in an assemblage include socially situated subjects, materials, objectives and different “knowledges, discourses, institutions, laws and regulatory regimes” (Murray Li, 2007, p. 266).

At the same time, assemblage thinking accentuates becoming and emergence, meaning that its ‘territory’ is never fully stabilized. In fact, a core perspective in assemblage thinking is that “structural stability is seen as exception rather than the norm” (Bueger, 2018, p. 619). As such, the territory claimed by the assemblage constantly undergoes processes that stabilize, weakens and reshapes it. In assemblage thinking these are termed: territorialization, deterritorialization and reterritorialization, respectively. This leads us to the second and processual horizontal axis of the assemblage.

As for processes that increase hegemony among the content or elements of the assemblage, called territoritalization, this is “first to be understood as a process that defines or sharpens the spatial boundaries of actual territory” (Bueger, 2018, p. 620). For the study of global governance, territorialization refers to the process of carving out a territory of political space that can be governed. The physical boundaries of such a space can be rather fluid, spread across great distances and be located at many sites. For instance, in Bueger’s (2018) study of the counter-piracy assemblage, territorialization referred not only to the creation of a special zone in the Indian Ocean, but also to the various sites and fora all over the world where stakeholders met and developed plans for action.

Importantly, “territorialization also refers to non-spatial processes. Practices such as classifying or sorting in and out, defining which actors, objects and practices belong to the territory, and what particular role they have are also processes of creating homogeneity” (Bueger, 2018, p. 620). Indeed, in Bueger’s paradigmatic case study, territorialization also included creating consensus on which practices of governance were to be considered legitimate regarding counter-piracy efforts, which ended up being inscribed in document called Best Practices Management. Hence, the making of consensual knowledge was a crucial aspect in the process of territorialization by creating homogeneity among the vast array of relevant stakeholders.

As a result, processes of territorialization in global governance settings are infused with power when, for instance, boundaries are drawn up to delineate specific knowledges as authoritative at the expense of other ways of knowing. This is why the act of sorting out what belongs and does not belong in the assemblage directs attention to the power dynamics at play in the assemblage as territorialization can work “through shutting out contingency and entrenching one particular assemblage…over others” (Müller, 2015, p. 36). Consequently, territorialization is a crucial dimension for analysis as it highlights what might be termed the practice of inclusion and exclusion, which defines what belongs and what does not.

However, even though an assemblage could be deeply entrenched, it is never final and always vulnerable to processes of deterritorialization, which destabilize the it (DeLanda, 2006, p. 12). More concretely, the idea of deterritorialization as a process that can undo the stability of an assemblage allows this mode of inquiry to capture transformations and changes on the ‘territory’. Thus, the erosion of boundaries understood in a broad sense, such as undermining identities, are processes of deterritorialization (Alvesson & Sköldberg, 2017, p. 58).

The important point here is that for studies of expertise, the concept provides the means to account for how, for instance, knowledge claims put forwards by experts can be contested, challenged and critiqued. This can result in a destabilization of the assemblage and make it shift and transform. As such, by opening up for new relations to be established means that relations of authority can shift, thus creating ‘windows of opportunity’ where new connections can be made. Therefore, “in the process of assembling one always sees a territorialising force and a deterritorialising potential: here is where power comes to play (Lancione, 2013, p. 359).

The territory, then, can be unmade by the forces of deterritorialization and finally there is a potential for reterritorialization of the relations between components in the assemblage (Hayden, 1998, p. 96). As far as this author is aware, the notion of re-territorialization has not been widely used in the literature on assemblages in IR. The idea here is that while assemblages are inherently unstable, they also tend to reestablish themselves because they express a purpose or function. The longevity of certain institutions could be taken as an example of this. For instance, one could say that NATO expressed a purpose or function so that while the end of the Cold War initiated a deterritorialization of the NATO-assemblage, it nonetheless reterritorialized, albeit in a different form. Importantly, the idea of reterritorialization is not a synthesis of a territorialization thesis and a deterritorialization antithesis (Legg, 2011, p. 129), but aims to capture yet another transformation that the territory might undergo.

Taken together, these processes are then “the qualitative transformations of complex assemblages on the basis of proliferating relations between heterogeneous terms (Hayden, 1998, pp. 95–96). Because this is an ongoing and constant process, the assemblage is always becoming or emergent rather than a static or stable being (Wise, 2005, pp. 78–79). Hence, an analysis centered on assemblage thinking should look for the changes and transformations on a given ‘territory’, and question how the assemblage articulates relations between its constituting elements, for instance, the relationship between knowledge and politics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.