Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The USFG is an assemblage. Did you not see Hamilton?

Aroney, 2—Professor of Constitutional Law at The University of Queensland (Nicholas, “Imagining a Federal Commonwealth: Australian Conceptions of Federalism, 1890-1901,” Federal Law Review, 30(2), 265, dml)

Putting these points together, Just apparently sought to show that it was necessary to have a strong federal government in which the will of the majority prevailed, but that such a government must first be formed with the consent of each of the several colonies as independent bodies politic. As the Herald had maintained, a federation comes into being by unanimous agreement of the constituent bodies politic, and they agree to confer limited functions on a central government that makes its decisions by majority rule, but the remainder of their constituent and governmental powers are retained.

Just also felt it important to draw the attention of his Australian readers to Hamilton's famous discussion of Montesquieu's classic definition of the 'Confederate Republic'. As reproduced by Just, Montesquieu had said:

It is very probable that mankind would have been obliged, at length, to live constantly under the Government of a single person, had they not contrived a kind of constitution that has all the internal advantages of a Republican, together with the external force of a Monarchical, Government—I mean a Confederate Republic.

This form of Government is a convention by which several smaller States agree to become members of a larger one, which they intend to form. It is a kind of assemblage of societies, that constitutes a new one, capable of increasing by means of new associations till they arrive at such a degree of power as to be able to provide for the security of the united body. ... As this Government is composed of small Republics, it enjoys the internal happiness of each, and with respect to its external situation, it is possessed, by means of the association, of all the advantages of large Monarchies.

A Republic of this kind, able to withstand an external force, may support itself without any internal corruption. ... As this Government is composed of small Republics, it enjoys the internal happiness of each, and with respect to its external situation, it is possessed, by means of the association, of all the advantages of large Monarchies.[47]

In Montesquieu's day, political reflection suggested that large, territorial monarchies had the advantage of external security, but they also suffered the internal disadvantage of a tendency to despotism, whereas the small republic had the advantage of a virtuous citizenry actively participating in the government, but suffered the external disadvantage of susceptibility to assimilation by larger powers. Montesquieu suggested that the advantages of each might be secured in what he called the confederate republic.

Hamilton commented on this idea in Federalist No 9. As reproduced by Just, Hamilton proposed that the 'definition' of a 'Confederate Republic' or 'Federal Government' was 'an assemblage of societies' or 'an association of two or more States into one State'. So long, Hamilton maintained, that the 'separate organisation of the members be not abolished', but rather exists 'by a constitutional necessity for local purposes', then despite their 'subordination' to an additional 'general authority' or national government created for specific purposes, the scheme remains 'an Association of States or a Confederacy'. Indeed, Hamilton pointed out, the proposed United States Constitution treated the states as 'constituent parts' of the Union, allowing them 'direct representation in the Senate' and leaving them with 'certain exclusive and very important portions of the sovereign power'.[48]

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.