Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The digitization of the carceral state disproves the historical continuity of anti-Black oppression—it takes different forms.

Jefferson, 20—associate professor of geography and geographic information science and O’Connell Scholar in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign (Brian, “Introduction: NextGen Nightmare,” Digitize and Punish: Racial Criminalization in the Digital Age, Introduction, pg 13-16, dml)

A point of emphasis in the book is that carceral power is silently spreading through infrastructures of cellular towers, datacenters, fiber-optic cables, smart sensors, and video cameras. Carceral functionality is becoming a key attribute of the smart city. This is not meant to say that the prison-industrial complex is being wholly supplanted or that it is bound to disintegrate. Even though incarceration rates have reached their lowest points in decades, the history of carceral management is not one of a linear development. Nor is it a history of a changeless institution. Carceral space has manifested in the form of extraordinary rendition sites, immigrant detention centers, and internment camps. This book traces an emergent form of carceral space that is characterized by machines that traverse human anatomy, public housing facilities, public schools, transportation systems, telecommunications systems, and street networks in U.S. cities. The book also emphasizes that the deeper telecommunications and IT firms entrench themselves in crime control policy, the more likely it is for these infrastructures to continue to expand.

The extension of carceral management through the Internet of Things (IoT), or networks of devices that communicate with each other, is greatly influenced by the movement of capital.42 On one hand, the carceral state’s circumscription of black and latinx communities was partly catalyzed by the flight of industry from cities, which rendered entire groups deskilled and unemployable. Decades of revelatory research demonstrates how cities turned to mass criminalization to manage the enormous economic, political, social, and medical problems arising from deindustrialization.43 On the other hand, in addition to outbound industrial capital, the carceral state’s digital architecture owes its existence to inbound information capital. The infrastructure sector has emerged as one of the most important sectors in finance, knowledge, and technology industries.44 IT companies have insinuated themselves in seemingly all facets of urban life, including government agencies, private businesses, social networks, transportation systems, workplaces, and infrastructure. These companies have also nestled their way into criminal justice administration, which is reshaping geographies of carceral governance.

A central argument in this book is that the criminal justice system’s smart infrastructure is creating new geometries of carceral space. On one hand, carceral space is incredibly centralized. Extraordinary rendition sites, detention centers, jails, and prisons, which are designed to monitor, discipline, governmentalize, punish, and sometimes execute or torture those caught within their grasp, are a few examples. IT firms have penetrated these spaces. For instance, technology corporations sell geographic information systems to help custodial authorities organize cell arrangements according to demographic categories, predict inmate movements and behaviors, and identify potential escape routes (see chapter 2). Yet, on the other hand, carceral space is incredibly decentralized. Carceral geographers highlight the elaborate logistics required to shuttle humans, information, and resources across prison facilities and entire landscapes.45 Architects have characterized rural prison facilities as urban exostructures, as they provide relief to the city’s overburdened criminal justice apparatus.46 Technology firms have also infiltrated this decentralized dimension of carceral management. Wireless networks of smart cameras, phones, sensors, and tablets extend the reach of the carceral system. At the scale of the city, smart cameras and environmental sensors send alerts to patrol vehicles dispersed throughout street networks. On regional scales, real-time crime centers receive data and transmit them throughout states and, increasingly, between them. Owing to their portability, criminal justice technologies also circulate on international scales. Today there exists a global market for public security technology that traverses capitalist, communist, and socialist nations. On yet a grander scale, electronic forms of monitoring probationers depend on Global Positioning System satellites, which extend the reach of carceral technology all the way into low Earth orbit.

Taking the carceral state apart and making it less recognizable through the lens of smart infrastructure helps short-circuit illusions that it is neatly bounded in terms of geography and functionality. While the illusion of a monolithic carceral Leviathan echoes modern theories of the state that never seem to fade away, carceral statecraft is an open, dynamic, and variegated sociotechnical process of quarantining human beings. As such, our understanding of carceral state power, Katherine Beckett and Naomi Murakawa observe, “must be as capacious, complex, and adaptive as the policies and institutions involved in it.”47 The present study insists that analysis of this power’s sociotechnical substrate is also necessary to understand carceral conditions in the twenty-first century.

DESIGN OF THE BOOK

Digitize and Punish retells the history of mass criminalization by focusing on technology corporations and technology bureaus. The book’s objects of analysis are not criminalized communities but rather the computer programmers, corporate-bureaucratic intellectuals, state officials, and technologists who update the tools that criminalize them. It tells untold stories of the contingencies, failed projects, unintended consequences, and technical breakthroughs involved in constructing the digitized carceral state. It illustrates how these efforts have simultaneously augmented the carceral state and created new avenues of subverting it.

This project employs an intersectional approach to understand the nexus of carceral power, racism, and IT capital.48 The perspective was notably captured by the Combahee River Collective and Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, who demonstrated the inadequacies of understanding social hierarchy through one measure, or axis of division.49 As such, structural analysis of the relations between racial difference, technological development, and political economic mutation is necessary to understand the relevant factors in racial criminalization in the digital age. The question is not if racial criminalization behaves in a structural manner but rather how it maintains, if not increases, its structural integrity from generation to generation. This book therefore seeks to explain how information capital exploited the surge of racial criminalization near the end of the last century and, at the same time, how racial criminalization was exploited by the rise of information technology.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.