Collective resubjectivization generates material liberation.
Hall, 20—Professor of Education and Technology, De Montfort University (Richard, “Platform Discontent against the University,” The digital age and its discontents: Critical reflections in education, Chapter 7, 130-132, dml)
The proletarianization of the University is predicated upon atomized competition, which utilizes new forces of production to reshape relations between people, in order to extract value. A critical element of this is enforced separation between individuals, and the ability for individual agency to be repurposed by structural requirements. However, in order to extract maximum value, capital requires individuals to work in concert, or to collaborate as producers, distributors and consumers. This gives opportunities for cooperative re-imagination. For Marx (1866), the cooperative movement was a transformational force where it understood its relationship to labour as the point of social production. Thus, he argued that producer cooperatives, as opposed to consumer cooperatives, are a manifestation of class antagonism that can point towards ‘the republican and beneficent system of the association of free and equal producers’ (ibid., emphasis in the original). This analysis of cooperation rests on forms of self-mediation by human beings of their material activities in society. In an idealized cooperative state, activities are no longer piecemeal or solitary, or governed by capital; rather, they are governed by alternative networks of solidarity and purpose: ‘This is not possible without the community. Only within the community has each individual the means of cultivating his gifts in all directions; hence personal freedom becomes possible only within the community’ (Marx & Engels 1998: 86).
A focus on the communal and associational characteristics of cooperation is critical to Marx’s praxis, because in them he sees the individual developing the capabilities of their species (Marx 2004). As a result, a refocusing upon cooperative values and principles, grounded in the conceptual framework of the self-in-association, acts as a moment of refusal of alienated socialization, in which the producers of society are estranged from both the means and conditions of production of that society. However, discontent at the present state of things does not coalesce into a single, counter-hegemonic position, predicated upon a unified collection of alternative governing principles for life. It therefore becomes important to think about alternative forms of knowledge production and an integration with alternative conceptions of mutuality, solidarity and cooperation, such as those emerging from indigenous or marginalized communities.
Indigenous methodologies or modes of being help both to develop a fresh focus on knowledge and to reframe the idea of movement towards a more humane social production as a liminal process, engaging the body, emotions and cognition (Tuhiwai Smith, Tuck & Yang 2018). In this sensuous, epistemic opening, knowledge is rooted in people, place, philosophy, values, communities, axiologies and cosmologies, which generate ‘relational accountability’ (Wilson 2008: 77). Such accountability is mutual, respectful and dignified, and acts as a beginning for refusing the domination of knowledge from the global North imposed as progressive and rooted in an ideological, evidence-based epistemological standard. Here, cooperative techniques for social reproduction might enable forms of relational accountability between peoples and places. Moreover, in this process, they offer the possibility of liberating material forces, including technology, and connecting them to alternative conceptions of the world, in order to widen autonomy and freedom.
For Marx (1866; 1970) a cooperative revolution in the governance of technology forms a crucial strand in changing the general conditions of social production, because it redefines the subjectivity of society towards humanity and away from the commodity and the valorization of capital. If we are to do this, then a shared, associational expression of individual lives is required, in order to realize the essence of what it means to be human. Marx’s idea was that the expression of my life and those of my peers are immanent to each other, and should be mediated directly rather than through the market, private property, the division of labour and commodity exchange. This requires an alternative conception of how to integrate the forces of production into our communal being, and a liberatory conception of how those forces are subordinate to our essence and our social relations (Bookchin 2005). Beautifully, Marx (1844) argues that through such practices ‘our products would be like so many mirrors, out of which our essence shone’ as a ‘free expression’ of our lives.
At issue is how to find cracks in the system of capital, into which technologies for alternative, liberatory conceptions of society can be inserted. Dunayevskaya (1958) has argued that these need to be situated inside organizations that are beyond value-production, or they risk degenerating under competition. As a result, a re-imagination of the University has to engage with more than the cooperative possibilities of the collective ecosystems currently structured to reproduce value. A re-imagination of the potential for forces of production to enable social connection and knowledge sharing, and to liberate time for autonomous activity rather than the imposition of commodity production, comes up against structural contradictions. Thus, a re-imagination of technology as a means for liberating knowledge for a new society demands a new material literacy as a radical, pedagogical project at the level of society.
This is a transitional project that critiques the place of technology as it is currently instantiated inside the University. It critiques the relationship of the digital University, and its techniques of governance, to knowledge production and the generation of social wealth. It also critiques these relationships and techniques in terms of their ability to enable humanity to engage with global economic and environmental crises. It critiques the limitations in our collective ability to produce knowledge inside the University to engage with these crises, in part through the separation of polity and economy, such that the latter dominates the former. It critiques these limitations as they are reproduced inside organizations conditioned by the State to generate value through exploitation and expropriation. In this way, it moves beyond the fetishization of technologies and techniques, including the ways in which these are reproduced and enclosed inside institutions like universities (see Ampuja, Chapter 2, in this volume). The potential for relational accountability and the recomposition of peoples, places and technologies offer an alternative set of possibilities for intellectual work beyond the capitalized University.