Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Marxist theorizations of change fail to account for the ontological nature of modern capitalism – the aff’s approach is the only way to create individual value in the world of utility

Magrini 11 (James, Professor at the College of DuPage, “Working to Recover the Essence of Education for the Sake of Teaching and Teacher Education: Towards a Phenomenological Understanding of the Forgotten, Ontological Aspects of Learning” p. 4)NCF

It is evident that there is a serious problem with educational procedures emerging out of the “bureaucratic/rational choice model” that is two-fold in nature, a problem that is in fact antibiotic, as in a vicious sense of codependence. Instructors who are increasingly alienated from what might serve as legitimate, or authentic, curriculum for the preparation of teachers entering the field are slaves to institutions governed by pre-determined standards of achievement. These institutions are then filtering ill-prepared (alienated) teachers into a system that is governed in much the same way, namely, by standards and competencies established by bureaucratic agencies that are at a remove from authentic educational purposes and practices. Teachers are thus alienated in a duplicitous sense, both from the curriculum they are now forced to teach and the students who cannot relate to what is being taught. Bonnett (2001) echoes the sentiments expressed earlier when stating that the current “predisposition to regard outcomes of education as definable in advance of the process of education” engenders a deterministic system of education that obscures authentic subject-hood and we lose sight of the fact that humans are “individual centers of consciousness capable of relating to the world in ways that have personal meaning, for this is essential to human being against some sort of mechanized and depersonalized being” (p. 30). In short, there is a loss of ownership on the part of both educator and student, but beyond this, there is a loss of authentic subject-hood; ironically, by means of education, we are losing sight of what it means to be truly human. The alienation from the curriculum and authentic subject-hood of which I speak should not be conceived in terms of Marxist theory, which tends to focus on ideology and the critique of capitalism and its detrimental effects on schools. Rather, I conceive alienation and depersonalization in terms of what Heidegger (1979) calls the oblivion, or forgetting, of Being, which is grounded in the failure to ask about “the truth of being itself” and about “the way the essence of human being belongs to the truth of Being” (p. 246). This condition, which pervades the world of education, grows from the tradition in Western metaphysics and its subsequent influence on the rise of science and technology. In short, education is moving us farther away from essential issues of human dwelling as linked with our Being, and the ontological aspects of our existence. It is now to the potential recovery of this essential, forgotten ontological notion of authentic Beingin-the-world as related to education that I turn.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.