Asian war decks US commitments to NATO
Binnenkijk and Townsend 2021
Hans Binnenkijk, distinguished fellow at the Atlantic Council, former senior official at US Senate Foreign Relations Committee, National Security Council, State Department, and the National Defense University; Jim Townsend Jr. adjunct senior fellow in the CNAS Transatlantic Security Program, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense (DASD) for European and NATO Policy. "The Future US Role in NATO," NATO 2030: Towards a New Strategic Concept and Beyond, (131-156), 2021.
The United States' relationship with the Alliance a decade from now will depend upon at least four variables. First, will the return to solid US support for the Alliance seen during President Biden's Summit meetings in June 2021 be sustained for the next decade, or will US populism grow and return the nation to some form of America First? The outcome is uncertain, but the resurrection of a populist United States cannot be ruled out; Europe needs to begin planning for this contingency. Second, will the military threats to the United States and its NATO Allies continue to expand? Major power threats from Russia and China appear to be on the rise, with both nations increasing their defense cooperation. North Korea and Iran appear to pose increasing nuclear proliferation risks and are drawing closer to both of these two major power adversaries. The threat of extremism from the Middle East is also likely to continue. America risks being overextended in dealing with these multiple challenges. This dynamic will require that America's global alliances thrive. But since the military challenge in Asia is greatest, the United States might again be forced to pivot much of its attention to Asia. Third, the scope of the non-military or unconventional challenges facing NATO will probably also continue to expand. These challenges include cyberattacks, disinformation, other forms of unconventional warfare, coercive diplomacy, global warming, and public health issues. To remain relevant, the scope of NATO's missions will need to continue to expand to address these non-military challenges. And fourth, with the above three factors in play, the final variable is: can European members of the Alliance increase their political cohesion and their defense contributions to meet their share of these growing challenges? The requirement is there but European willpower is also uncertain.