The Western LIO model is privatization --- it’s an economic disease as per statistical evidence
*empirical comparison of Latin America with East Asia, income inequality, state investment/social safety nets, adjustment based on local characteristics
Arifin 17 (Bustanul, Professor of Agricultural Economics at UNILA, Senior Economist at INDEF and Professorial Fellow at InterCAFE-IPB and SB-IPB, He earned PhD from University of Wisconsin-Madison, “The Failure of the Washington Consensus, the Need for a New Reform and the Rise of the Beijing Consensus,” AEGIS: Journal of International Relations, 1(2), 118-130)
The Washington Consensus has brought a serious debate and critiques. The structuralist thinkers such Dani Rodrick and Joseph E. Stiglitz have explicitly mentioned strong critiques towards the Washington Consensus. They oppose the consensus offered by John Williamson and say the Washington Consensus has become a source of crisis and problem for developing and less-developed countries. Both Rodrick and Stiglitz have challenged the term which described as the fundamental policies of the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and the US Treasury Department where Stiglitz calls it as a “one size fits all” treatment of individual economies. Stiglitz said that the treatment suggested by the International Monetary Fund [IMF] and the World Bank is too simple: one dose, fast stabilize, liberalize and privatize, without prioritizing or watching for side effects (Stiglitz, 2002).
The reform package addressed by Williamson did not work out as it was intended. Based on the statistical data, the Latin American countries which mostly adopted the Washington Consensus policies have a lower economic growth than East and Southeast Asian countries opposing the Washington Consensus policies. The economic growth of Latin America reached 5.5% during 1960–1980, where East Asia achieved only 5.5% during the same period. However, during 1990–2004, the economy in Latin America only achieved 2.7%, where East Asia can reach 7.8% on that period (World Bank Statistics). Tremendous economic growth is shown by East and Southeast Asian countries when they applied contrary policies to Washington Consensus by having strong government role and nationalize many companies such as in China, Taiwan and South Korea, as well as India.
According to Stiglitz, the Washington Consensus has made a slower GDP growth as well in Latin America where they are mostly the follower of the IMF and the World Bank. On the other hand, Latin America also experienced tremendous volatility of growth and there was no stability during the 1890s period of Washington Consensus. The worst thing according to Stiglitz was that the rise of unemployment in Latin America during 1990–2004 and the declined of per capita income. Furthermore, under the Washington Consensus inequitable sharing becomes a serious concern because the Washington Consensus policies produced limited growth only and even when the growth did occur, it was not equitably shared. The equality issues are not even considered seriously from the consensus policies which later caused social and political problems in some countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America.
Dani Rodrick mentioned that the government role cannot totally be separated from economic activities (Rodrick, 2006). In developing countries, the roles of government are not only to address market failure such as controlling conflicts of interest and ensuring the soundness and safety of the financial system, but also to promote equity and provide safety nets. For structuralist, Washington consensus is considered as a failure consensus because it did not understand the limitation of the markets and it focused on very limited a set of instruments. As the consequences, the Washington Consensus ignored the industrial policies, land reform, strengthening the financial sector, improving education, Competition policy, and government issues in both public and private sectors (Stiglitz, 2005).
According to Marxist/dependency theorists, the Washington Consensus is not suitable for developing or third world countries. However, it can bring an economic disease for development and prosperity in those countries. The Marxist thinkers such as Alfredo Saad Filho and Costas Lapavitsas have seriously advocated for equality and adjust the development distribution and better social class in the society. The Marxist economists argued that the Washington Consensus categorizes the third world nations into a backdrop of the reform which makes the third world nations have a dependency on the mercy of the developed countries or western countries (Lapavitsas, 2001). They believe that the consensus proposed by Williamson is the source for greater global crisis and economic problem (Saad-Filho, 2010).
Marxist/dependency thinkers believe that the Washington Consensus is a tool to further the establishment of the capitalism. For the Marxist, this capitalism system may lead to even greater social and economic problems for the workers in developing and less-developed countries because of their low bargaining power and weak position as subject from the western imperialists. The policies in the consensus will push the developing countries and less-developed countries to adopt the capitalism system which brings them under the control of the developed countries and global financial institutions. The reform package offered from the Washington Consensus is considered by the Marxist as a worse instrument that will be used by developed and huge economic countries to expand the imperialist influence and power to the third world countries and makes them dependent for political, social and economic on western countries and international financial institutions.
Many scholars then believe that the Washington Consensus policies have failed to handle the economic structure efficiently in developing countries. The case in East Asia can be a good example where Taiwan and South Korea can show a wonderful success for their economic growth with a larger role from the domestic government by growing domestic savings and undertaking the industrial policies inside the region. It is the same like what happens in China, India, Indonesia and some other Countries in the region where the governments play a big role in the market and economic activity, as well as applies the trade system with their own characteristic and model.
The biggest critique towards the Washington Consensus came when global financial crisis starting in 2008. The developing and less-developed countries confidently oppose and reject the Washington Consensus policies and against the international financial institutions such International Monetary Fund and the World Bank for their insignificant contribution and solutions. On the other hand, the prior to the global financial crisis in 2008, the economic crisis which happened in Argentina in 1999–2002 is believed as the result of the Washing Consensus failure. During the 1990s, Argentina became a loyal follower of the Washington Consensus policies suggested by the IMF and the World Bank. However, its economy finally was collapse. Many economists and scholars believe that the cause of this crisis is due to the application of fixed exchange rate which became increasingly uncompetitive, failure to get an effective control over the fiscal accounts, and the collapse of the macroeconomic in the country.
The Need of New Reforms
The failure of the Washington Consensus has provided many lessons that can be learned by new government leaders in developing and less-developed countries to concern on their policies and international financial institutions to do a reform and create a new economic package or policies to boost global growth and development. The neo-liberalist people have to believe that the Washington Consensus has failed to give a solution for global development. However, it has given a bad experience for countries adopting the policy package from this consensus.
During the 1990s and 2000s, the international financial institutions such as the international Monetary Fund and the World Bank have suggested the Washington Consensus package for the developing and less-developed countries. In fact, this idea did not bring a successful achievement for global development. The countries that adopted the Washington associated policies experienced a bad economic growth and collapse, whereas the countries that opposed the Washington package can show a great economic growth. For instance, there is a big contrast between Latin American countries adopting the Washington package and East Asian countries which did not adopt the Washington package in some important respect. East Asian countries are slow to liberalize the capital market than the Latin America and some African countries. Furthermore, they are also slow to liberalize the trade and they adopted strong government industrial policies such as making many successful state-owned enterprises.
The differences in terms of policy account for the performance differences between Latin American/African countries and East/Southeast Asian countries. The East/Southeast Asian countries show more growth and faster growth, the benefits of growth more widely shared, and more stable although the 1997/98 Asian crisis happened, they can recover it quickly like Indonesia.
The Washington Consensus has come to the end. The question now what is the alternative one to replace and give a positive global development. Therefore, we will need a new consensus or a new reform. According to structuralist thinker such as Stiglitz, the economic package should not ignore the relationship between the economic success and the social and political stability or structure. The objective of the policies should not only concern to increase the GDP, but have to achieve a sustainable and equitable democratic development. The most important point now is to chase new reforms to finish soon and create good global governance. The reforms will work by reforming the global financial system to make it more stable and to reduce the risks facing the developing countries such as reforming the global reserve system and developing better mechanism for shifting risk (Stiglitz, 2005).
Globalization and Inclusive World Economy
The failure of the Washington Consensus has provided many experiences regarding the international development, and today in the post Washington consensus we are dealing with the globalization as a global instrument to accelerate global prosperity growth. Globalization at its simplest can be seen as the increase over time of international trade (referred to as merchandise trade) and services (Otter, 2014). Furthermore, globalization can be defined as a process of international integration through the interchange of world views, products, ideas and other aspects of culture (Al-Rodhan, Stoudmann and Nayef, 2006). Globalization is almost the same with the Washington Consensus which highlights the trade and market liberalization. Dorron Otter in his book, The Business Environment, mentioned that according to Neoclassical/neoliberal such as Adam Smith, trade will be very important to expand the market which allows bigger specialization and increases productivity at the domestic level. Therefore, the globalization based on neoliberal/neoclassical view will give good benefits: firstly, it provides a source of external funding that boosts the amount of money available to fuel trade internally, and secondly it enables further room for the expansion of markets on an international scale (Otter, 2014). The comparative advantage theory can be applied and work here totally.
The Marxist/socialist has difference views regarding the globalization than the neoliberal/classical views. According to Marxist/socialist, globalization will not be a solution for international development because it will create a bigger dependency of the third world countries on the developed nations or western imperialist. The globalization will drive the developing and less-developed countries to greater problems such as disparity, inequality, poverty, and unbalanced development among the countries. On the other hand, the structuralist thinkers argue that the globalization could be a good instrument to achieve global development and prosperity if there are some structural and institutional reforms and reparation. Structuralist thinkers believe that the third world countries cannot reach the level of developed nation or industrialist nations directly or soon after the world war II, but they need to catch up this level by taking the globalization to move up step by step.
Therefore, the domestic and international levels need to undertake certain strategies and policies to achieve positive development and prosperity if the globalization is to work in such a way as to build an inclusive world economy. Stiglitz argued that the domestic level should pay a serious concern to focus on the importance of equity and employment. In addition, the domestic level has to make a balanced role of government and market by promoting and regulating markets, providing institutional and physical infrastructure, and promoting education, innovation and technology. The domestic government has to play good and enough roles toward the macroeconomic sector. The financial sector should get bigger concern from the government in order to create a more stable and positive financial market, and the government has to make good and strong social and political policies as the key aspect to achieve a good and stable capital investment.
On the other side, the international level has to make some reforms in order to reach a better global development. Stiglitz said that in order to enhance sustainable, equitable, stable, and democratic development, the international level should pay a serious concern towards several aspects regarding the reformation of the global economic architecture. The global economic architecture should produce new strategies and policies by focusing on efficiency, stability, equity among countries, and ability of developing countries to pursue their objectives. The international institutions have to allow developing and less-developed countries to have bigger authority to adjust their fundamental economy, social and politic towards the globalization characteristics and system. The global economic strategies and policies have to be in appropriate with the local characteristics and models in order to allow the third world nations to achieve faster economic acceleration by having more suitable platform and economic package.
Beijing Consensus
The rise of China as the new economic super power has contributed to the change of the international economic architecture. China role in terms of economy has challenged the position of the United States as the most dominant player at the international level (Albertoni & Arguello, 2015). Its increasing development has decreased the influenced of the United States, especially among the developing countries (Turin, 2010). Therefore, many people are now discussing a new economic term called “Beijing Consensus.” The Beijing Consensus was firstly introduced by Joshua Cooper Ramo in 2004 through his paper published by the United Kingdom’s Foreign Policy. Ramo sees that the economic policies produced in Beijing have become concern for many countries and influence the international economic architecture. The Chinese economic model/ Beijing Consensus offers a different model and characteristic than the guidelines offered by the Washington Consensus.
The major aspects of differences between the Beijing Consensus and the Washington Consensus are the role of GDP, financial sovereignty, and government intervention. When the Washington Consensus puts more concern on how to maximise the liberalisation of market and gives full freedom for market, the Beijing Consensus still puts the role and intervention of the government in the market as an important aspect to drive the development. Firstly, in the Washington Consensus, the GDP is the main focus or centralisation to determine the growth of a country. However, for the Beijing Consensus, economic sustainability and the wealth distribution will also become as the important aspects. Secondly, in terms of financial sovereignty, the Washington Consensus will believe that the financial sovereignty automatically will be produced by the general development, whereas the Beijing Consensus sees that the financial sovereignty will be obtained through the policies of self–determination, because this more deliberate action to financial sovereignty will give a more secure future for economy of a country (Hubner, 2013). Lastly, the government in the developing countries are mostly having problem with corruption in the government and politics in which put those developing countries likely unstable in some cases and it can bring to risk than potential growth. Unfortunately, the Washington consensus will use general guidelines for all type of countries, whereas the Beijing Consensus will allow the developing countries to adjust the economic system in line with their local characteristics. Then, it becomes the reason for Samantha Hubner to suggest those developing countries to consider the classical liberalism and it will likely be safer to be used in developing countries because it will consider the laws of human nature (Hubner, 2013).