Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

[x] --- Nationalism

Huang 21 — Department of Political Science, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL Huang Q. The Pandemic and the Transformation of Liberal International Order. J Chin Polit Sci. 2021;26(1):1-26. doi: 10.1007/s11366-020-09698-0. Epub 2020 Oct 16. PMID: 33082701; PMCID: PMC7565235. WMK

Besides the challenge brought by the entrenchment of authoritarianism, the second challenge to current order stems from the exacerbation of nationalism. One of the underlying tensions of the current order exists between states seeking to assert their agency against the seemingly inexorable and homogenizing forces of globalization promoted by the liberal order. States refuse to be hollowed out by the globalizing forces and seek to assert their authority and legitimacy both within their territorial boundaries and in transnational processes. Nationalism has been a tool for modern states to legitimize their power at home and position themselves in the international arena. Besides its linkage to language and symbolism, nationalism is “a sociopolitical movement and an ideology of the nation” [69]. The pandemic provides fertile ground for nationalism to thrive in both democratic and authoritarian countries, as states reclaim their place and authority left by the retreat of globalizing forces. With help from nationalist and populist politicians, nationalism has blended with populism and authoritarianism and become stronger in both democratic and authoritarian hosts.

Confronted with the pandemic, many countries rushed to fend for themselves instead of joining together in multilateral efforts. State leaders worldwide unilaterally closed borders, restricted incoming travelers, grappled with solutions to meet their own soaring demands for medical supplies, and prepared to fix their damaged economies. States have reasserted their roles in responding to crises, guarding their sovereignty, and managing their own economies in the uncertain times, while the globalizing forces promoted by the current order are in the retreat. The self-serving calculations of national interests, in both political and economic spheres, have dominated many leaders’ thinking since the outbreak of the pandemic and are likely to continue influencing policymaking in the post-pandemic struggle for recovery. The exacerbation of nationalism has eroded the popularity and authority of international institutions that buttress the principle of multilateralism and the seemly unstoppable forces of globalization promoted by the current order. It also pushes states to make choices that are most aligned with their national interests, from both material and ideological perspectives.

As Walt argues, “The pandemic will strengthen the state and reinforce nationalism” [7]. Bieber observes that even before the pandemic, exclusionary nationalism mixed with far-right politics and populism had already overshadowed major countries around the world. The pandemic reinforces nationalism in several important ways: a “marriage” between nationalism and authoritarianism, bias against others (including ethnic minorities and other marginalized groups) presumed to be associated with the pandemic, and the rise of deglobalization and anti-globalization [70]. These changes will likely reinforce existing nationalistic dynamics. These dynamics are evident during the pandemic at both state and society levels, as well as in both democratic and autocratic settings, as exemplified by the developments in the United States and China. Both countries have been involved in escalated “narrative battle” powered by nationalism [71].

In the United States, controversial labels, from the “Chinese Virus” to the “Kung Flu”, were disseminated by President Trump as state leaders tried to find a scapegoat to blame for their own failures in responding to the pandemic. Even after the Administration wasted nearly two months responding to the crisis, many politicians were quick to defend Trump: “We don’t blame Trump, we blame China.” Senator Lindsey Graham claimed that the Chinese government was responsible for all American deaths [72]. Only a few days later, the U.S. intelligence and national security officials said that the U.S. government was exploring the possibility that the coronavirus leaked from a lab in Wuhan [73]. Trump and the Secretary of State Mike Pompeo soon joined the chorus. They ignored the assessments made by many scientists and weaponized the coronavirus for political purpose. Both the Republican Party and the Democratic Party continued to blame China in an attempt to maximize their appeal to the voters and increase their odds of winning the 2020 election [74].

While the state leaders in the US were pandering to a nationalist base, xenophobic sentiment surged across the country. Within just four weeks (March 19–April 15), at least 1497 incidents of coronavirus-related discrimination targeting Chinese and other groups of Asian origins were reported in the United States. These incidents included verbal harassment, refusal of services, and even physical assault [75]. The Pew Research Center also found that negative views of China had risen to its highest point since the center started collecting data on Americans’ views of China in 2005. About two-thirds (66%) of American adults had a negative view of the country, a significant increase of 20 percentage points since Trump took office [76].

In China, nationalist strategies were also used at the state level. Early in the outbreak, the United States was blamed by China for its failure to provide sincere and substantive support toward China and for its overaction by raising its travel advisory level, bringing American citizens back, and blocking Chinese visitors. Later, the U.S. military was accused of intentionally spreading the virus in Wuhan, a theory promoted by Zhao Lijian, the spokesperson for China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs [77]. Moreover, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced its decision to expel American journalists working for The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post, further fueling nationalist sentiment in China.

Likewise, the Chinese people’s views of the United States drastically declined during the pandemic. Before the United States stepped up its efforts to shift the blame toward China, a survey by the Eurasia Group Foundation (February 15–March 3) found that China had witnessed the starkest decline among ten countries in their views toward the United States and American democracy. Favorable views of the United States decreased by nearly 20 percent as negative views increased by 11%, compared to a 2019 report. Positive views of American democracy also declined by 15%. About half of the respondents believed that the United States had made the world a worse place in the past 20 years [78]. An article published by a Chinese nationalist tabloid reported that Chinese people had seen the harm of U.S. hegemony and the darker side of democracy [79].

Politicians from both sides are playing a dangerous game by exploiting the nationalistic feelings in their respective societies to serve their own political agendas. Both sides have politicized the coronavirus and related scientific researches, further rousing animosity between the two countries. Beyond these two cases, many other nationalist and populist leaders around the world have sought to decry globalization and “others”. The pandemic has given them the weapon they need. While Trump proclaimed on Twitter, “We need the wall more than ever!”, France’s rightist National Rally party’s leader Le Pen blamed “the religion of borderlessness” for the virus outbreak. During the pandemic, state leaders and political parties in Hungary, India, Germany, Italy, and Spain have targeted ethnic minorities and other marginalized groups [67, 80–83]. Foreign workers and F1 students were the latest victims of current U.S. administration’s populist and nationalist strategies [84, 85].

In the last decade, the world has witnessed the rise of nationalist and populist leaders in national and subnational politics throughout many regions [86–88]. The pandemic enables these leaders to rally their supporters and attack what they see as the illusion of solidarity between nations and the failure of international institutions, including the European Union and the World Health Organization (WHO). Moreover, states’ recalculations of national interests are likely to reinforce their appeals because the pandemic has exposed the risk and vulnerability of global dependency regarding the supply chains and strategic resources. As a result, the pandemic will likely prompt a renationalization of production and transform global integration to a more limited form that is oriented toward regional and bilateral engagements [89].

Even in Europe, the region that serves as “the proof that human society was becoming transnational, transcending its national stage and moving towards a global community”, confidence in globalization has declined. As we witness the “universal reversion to nationalist policies and defense of particularistic national interests at the expense of transnational solidarity”, international institutions are more likely to suffer from the pandemic [90]. The pandemic has given “a political gift for nativist nationalists and protectionists” and will have long-term impact on many aspects of globalization, including the free movement of people and goods [91]. States are able to reclaim their place and assert their authority and legitimacy within their territorial boundaries and in transnational processes. As politicians in both democracies and autocracies exploit nationalism to serve their political agendas during the pandemic, they continue to deepen the divisions and tensions between countries, hinder multilateral cooperation, and contribute to the fragmentation of the existing international order.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.