Regional fill-in solves
Roy 19 (Dr. Indrajit Roy, Politics Department at the University of York, Junior Research Fellow at Wolfson College and Research Associate at the Department of International Development, University of Oxford, “Interview with Indrajit Roy: Human rights and the Role of Emerging Markets in the Liberal World Order,” 9-17, https://www.pep-voxjournal.co.uk/single-post/2019/09/17/Interview-with-Indrajit-Roy-Human-rights-and-the-Role-of-Emerging-Markets-in-the-Liberal-World-Order)
3. How about the US pulling out of multilateral organisations, will there be a power vacuum that might appeal to another county like China?
There might not be as much of a vacuum as we fear. For example, you have multilateral organisations such as the African Union, you have the Association of Southeast Asian Nations [ASEAN]. You have, perhaps not the western dedication to human rights, but attempts for peace harmony and security. So, you may not have a normative commitment to democracy, but one for the commitment to peace. These other models for peace, gives them a chance of developing sustainable mechanisms. I’m not trying to gloat over US withdrawal, but in a sense, I am. Now you get different parts of the world which have a chance, even though it might be messy and embroiled with conflict. There’s no reason to believe that the withdrawal of the US will lead to power vacuum, but actually might give developing powers a chance to regain normal life, for example Afghanistan. West Asia had its own civilisation for 1000s of years, it had communities and sophisticated mechanisms, much better then the alternative conflicts that the West brought. The withdrawal of the liberal international order might actually allow for the return of peace for them. Today, in a lecture on South Asia, I was showing Afghanistan in the 1970s, society was peaceful, people could go to schools, women wore skirts while walking down streets of Kabul. Not to say that wearing miniskirts is an indication of development, but the point is that people were living normal lives as human beings. This was before Afghanistan was sought to be brought into the ‘liberal world order’, before the invasion into Afghanistan which had been brought about by US-backed mujahedin. To answer your question, withdrawal of the ‘liberal world order’, or the US so to speak, from multilateral organisations may just be the best thing for emerging powers. There will be a bit of a power vacuum but not so much as to lead to a Hobbesian state of anarchy.