Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Chinese led order is incoherent and fails

Stephen 21 — Matthew D Stephen WZB Berlin Social Science Center, China’s New Multilateral Institutions: A Framework and Research Agenda, International Studies Review, Volume 23, Issue 3, September 2021, Pages 807–834, https://doi.org/10.1093/isr/viaa076 WMK

However, China’s attempts to “upload” its preferred normative vision to multilateral institutions, even its own, are not always successful. For example, while Xi Jinping initially promoted the idea of an AIIB under the principles of win-win cooperation (ASEAN-China Centre 2013), this has not been reflected in official discourses of the AIIB. The World Internet Conference offers an even clearer example. At the first meeting in 2014, attendees awoke on the last day to find copies of a “Wuzhen Declaration” pushed under their hotel room doors, which repeated key Chinese talking points on internet governance. Upon the objections of several attendees, it was not officially promulgated (Wall Street Journal 2014).

The clumsiness of such attempts at normative entrepreneurialism point toward the difficulty for China in using multilateral formats to promote normative change, let alone an alternative ideology to aspire for global hegemony (Allan, Vucetic, and Hopf 2018). This probably reflects the ideological incoherence of contemporary Chinese society, with its awkward mix of Maoist terminology, Dengist pragmatism, and increasing appeals to classical Chinese thought (Holbig 2013; Madsen 2014; Brown and Bērziņa-Čerenkova 2018). More likely is that China’s institutions will contribute to normative change simply by avoiding the overtly liberal ideas present in existing institutions that link states’ international legitimacy to their domestic affairs (Zhang 2011, 2016).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.