The resolution relies on the creation of fake scenarios to try and “strut their stuff” rely on the creation of a crisis which requires a masculine hero to urgently address the impact – results in the creation of self-fulfilling prophecies that will result in serial policy failure that does more destruction than is helps. Emerging tech relies within the realm of fantasy – reject it, as it pushes feminist criticism to the periphery
Griffin, 2015. (Penny, Senior Lecturer in International Relations at the University of New South Wales, Australia. “crisis, austerity and gendered governance: a feminist perspective,” in feminist review 109: 49-72, spp)
While globally it seems that ‘we are more or less permanently suspended in states of crisis’ (Otto, 2011: 76), crucially for feminist analyses, accounts that abstract moments of crisis as ‘exceptional’ events dislocate crisis from the nuanced thinking that would challenge the extreme measures that distort human rights and welfare (such as austerity measures and welfare cuts). Crises embody the power to shape our conceptions of world politics but also, crucially, have the capacity to construct and govern our most intimate and everyday practices. They are significant mechanisms of everyday, contemporary governance because they generate discourses of ‘emergency’, ‘speedy diagnosis’ and ‘robust response’, authorising ‘the operation of a more hegemonic legal order’ and reducing (but not eliminating) ‘the space for political contestation and critique’ (ibid.: 80). An alternative way of reading ‘crisis’ (and not something governance mechanisms and actors are likely to countenance) is, however, to concentrate on its fictive content, with ‘the crisis’ understood as a fictive imagining of everyday events that serves particular discursive purposes. Found in media and official portrayals that have represented the crisis in terms of shock, devastation, anxiety, fear, anger and shame (see, e.g., Widmaier, 2010), the neo-liberal governance of crisis has relied intensively on the language of trauma to generate ‘urgent’, wide-ranging but surreptitious social reforms, including the rewriting of institutional power arrangements and the dismantling of protective welfare systems. The reproduction of tropes of urgency, immediacy and muscularity (what we might call neo-liberalism’s ‘conventional’ responses to crisis), mobilised through metaphors of catastrophe and disaster, has, in particular, allowed for ‘a set of otherwise controversial “responses” to receive widespread legitimation’ (Brassett and Clarke, 2012: 5). The extent to which financial risk management has been cast over the course of the twentieth century as ‘a domain of technical expertise’, removed from public debate and placed firmly in the hands of an elite cadre of fiscal ‘experts’ (De Goede, 2004: 200–207), has rendered such decisive interventions yet more realisable. Despite interesting, and critical, engagements with the use of visuality and metaphor in dominant representations of the crisis, how the use of visual and narrative metaphors of enormity, shock and devastation, and the ensuing repetition of the need for robust, or ‘muscular’, interventions, has been gendered has been little discussed. Key financial publications, including, for example, The Financial Times, The Economist and Time magazine, have regularly deployed representational practices that discriminate actively and often between identifi- able and sexed bodies as symbolic of economic success, regulation and recovery in the global political economy. Men appear across these publications in power, holding the power, bearing the burden of responsibility for crisis and resolving crisis, reaffirming the meaning of the global financial system and its practices as symbolic of white, masculine corporate power (Griffin, 2015). This is particularly important with regard to feminism’s attention to governance in its everyday forms and practices, since, by immersing the financial crisis in images of masculinity, popular and policy sources provide a subtle, but thoroughly gendered, grounding for the ideas, methods and practices instituted by instruments of governance in response to the crisis (such as the measures of austerity considered below). The below analysis thus considers how, as everyday practices of global governance, ‘crisis management’ techniques have reproduced the dismissal of ill-fitting feminist critique and co-opted more sympathetic feminist knowledges. This, the paper argues, simply confirms the longevity of neo-liberal, capitalist, imperatives in the global political economy, entrenching the power of existing economic orders and constraining the possibilities, and space, for contestation and critique based on the masculinised reproduction of financial privilege. crisis governance discourse (1): the dismissal of feminism and the social costs of austerity[:] One way to read feminism’s position vis-a`-vis crisis is to note the damaging blow that contemporary governance reactions to ‘crisis’ have dealt feminism. Crises everywhere ‘are a particularly dangerous time for feminism, and indeed for all progressive ways of thinking’ (Otto, 2011: 78). The ‘emergency’ measures initiated by the announcement of ‘crisis’ represent a shift in power away from inclusive law and policy-making towards so-called ‘expertise’ in ‘crisis management’, ‘muscular’ law-making and the entrenchment of executive power, all of which effectively push feminism ‘off the map’ (ibid.: 76–79). Governments in the developed and developing world have further entrenched the reactionary, ‘hard’ law politics of crisis management, using the rhetoric of urgency to adopt far-reaching and increasingly invasive crisis management measures. Under the guise of ‘austerity’, the IMF has even been recalibrated as an institution of worldly fiscal expertise, a notable departure from the derided figure of cookie-cutter policy-making it struck in the aftermath of the Asian and Argentinean financial crises.