Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Debate has always been constructed though the masculine feminine dichotomy. Feminine debaters are forced to distance themselves from their femininity in order to be taken seriously and be competitive within the activity. However, when they do that too much, they are too bitchy. It is a game that becomes impossible to win. Instead, we need to challenge the dichotomy, allowing feminine debaters to embrace their individual identities.

(Bjork et al 99, Rebecca S., University of Utah, Dauber, Cori, University of North Carolina, Dix, Lisa, University of tah, Hobbs, Lisa, University of North Carolina, Kidder, Beck, University of Michigan, Ouding, Jenni, University of Michigan, and Rhyne, Joy, University of North Carolina, “Women in Debate: Reflections on the Ongoing Struggle,” http://web.archive.org/web/20011012220529/members.aol.com/womynindebate/article3.htm)//RB

Debate has been an overwhelmingly positive experience for me. That is not to say that there have not been negative aspects. I think that it is important for every woman in debate to be honest with herself. We are unfortunately the victims of sexual harassment and discrimination, but I do not believe that means we are destined to inferiority. It is imperative that we fight against rigidly defined gender roles in order to become full and equal participants in the debate community--that is not to say that women must deny their femininity to be successful debaters. Instead, I think each woman should be true to her own identity; if her femininity is an important part of her psyche, then she should by no means feel compelled to deny it or try to hide it in exchange for increased debate achievements .As a Southern woman, I think the pressures I felt within the debate community were great. At the beginning of my collegiate debate career I was not very focused on the competitive aspects of debate. My partner and I would win some debates, but what was most important to me at that time was socializing with other debaters. I do not encourage other women in debate to adopt such an attitude, but I also do not think that women who have such an attitude should be stigmatized. I found that as one of the few females on the debate circuit I was accepted socially by almost every other debater I met, whether they were junior-varsity participants or one of the top first-rounds. I was able to have fun with these people and it did not seem to matter that I was often much less successful in debate than they were. In fact, I think that it was easier for them to "hang out" with me because I was not in direct competition with them. When I changed partners and became part of a first-round team, things changed. I can recall countless occasions when friends of mine virtually ignored me in discussions about debate rounds or issues and addressed all of their questions to my male partner. This kind of behavior marginalized my worth as a debater. It always amazed me that other debaters (who were my friends) could totally ignore me as a "debater"; I was only truly recognized in a social context. I think the social side of debate is important--some of my best friends are debaters--but every debater should have the opportunity to develop both the social and the competitive sides of debate.I do not mean to imply that women in debate have little hope of becoming true equals to the men of debate or that they are destined to occupy only a social role and will forever remain at the peripheries of debate success. However, I do believe that feminine women face special challenges because they seem to fit the traditionally defined gender roles of our society at large. Women are not taught to be competitive; such ambitions are reserved for men. Argumentation itself has traditionally been associated with men because they are thought to be more rational and logical than women, who are supposedly driven by their emotions. In society, these views have started to change. Women have become successful in these so-called "male areas" and I think that debate as well will increasingly come to reflect these changes. A woman can be feminine and still excel at argumentation and logical reasoning. I fundamentally disagree with those in the debate community who would urge women to become more "masculine" in order to achieve a higher level of debate success. Giving into stereotypes will only serve to perpetuate such myths. As a debater, I resisted such pressures, held on to my femininity, and still managed to have a successful debate experience. I encourage other women in debate to do the same. We must fight the pressure and be true to ourselves; there is no fundamental reason why only "masculine" women can succeed in debate.As a final note, I think that it is important for all of us to encourage more women (and minorities as well) to participate in collegiate debate. I know that many female high school debaters decide against debating in college because they feel the activity is too hostile to women. I think that this is a tragedy and that coaches and debaters alike should discourage such attitudes. After all, our society is sexist, but does that mean women should avoid becoming active participants and leaders? Of course not. In the same way, women should not shy away from collegiate debate. I can honestly say that I have acquired many valuable skills through my involvement in debate. Giving up is not the answer. Raising awareness will certainly help, but I think the key really lies with the women in debate themselves. We must decide to stay involved, encourage other women we know to participate, and most importantly, refuse to settle for anything less than real equality and complete autonomy. LISA DIXKaren Finley, one of my favorite poets, writes with power and knowledge of her experiences as a woman. Her poem entitled "I Was Not Expected To Be Talented" is for me a powerful expression of my feelings about being a woman in debate. The poem goes like this ...Just smile, act pretty, open the door, and clean the toilet. You say one day at a time well, it's a slow death! Remember the homeless, the poor, the suffering. Well, I'm suffering inside!...You know why I only feel comfortable around the collapsed, the broken, the inebriated, the helpless and the poor-'CAUSE THEY LOOK LIKE WHAT I FEEL INSIDE! They look, they look, they look like what I feel inside! You see, I WAS NOT EXPECTED TO BE TALENTED. I am using this poem to relate to my experiences in debate as a woman. I feel that it is important for me to be as honest as I can about my experiences, yet at the same time to relate a message that is positive for women who are entering the activity. The story I'm about to tell is a coming to terms about my "place" in debate as a woman. I am a policy debater at the University of Utah. I did not debate in high school, although I did do some individual events. From my experience in high school, I think individual events were sort of the "woman's place." I was not expected to be talented in debate; however, I feel that women can be VERY talented if they are just encouraged to participate. This is the reason I am writing this paper. I believe that by subverting the notion of a "woman's place" in debate, and by being able to define our own "place" as women, more women will be encouraged to participate in debate at the high school and collegiate levels.The first time I was aware of my "place" in debate as a woman was at a regular season tournament. I was at the awards ceremony listening to the top twenty speaker awards; not one of them was a woman. Women were winning awards at the novice and junior levels, but for varsity women to win speaker awards was out of the question. I thought to myself, at least we were winning some awards, but my coach quickly told me that not very many women ever win speaker awards past the junior and novice levels. I guess I am very reluctant to accept that novice and junior debate is the only "place" for women. I am not taking anything away from novice and junior women debaters; my argument is that these women deserve a chance to win on the varsity level as well. Another experience that reminded me quickly where my "place" in debate is was in a round at the beginning of last season. A male debater put his arm around me during cross examination and said, "chill out, babe." I quickly thought to myself, "I am not your babe," but I said nothing and immediately sat down. I felt very objectified, humiliated, and angry. By treating me as a sex object, that male debater quickly put me in my "place."Women in debate have to deal with a double standard. If we are not feminine enough we are thought of as "bitchy," yet if we are too feminine, we are not taken seriously. I urge all women to hold on to both. We need to construct ourselves outside of the masculine/ feminine dichotomy-we should be able to have a place in debate because we are talented. At the 1992 National Debate Tournament, my partner (who is a woman) and I noticed that there were only four women teams at the tournament (76 teams total), and none of the women teams advanced to the double octafinal round. In fact, only four women cleared at all. Not one woman won a speaker award. I am proud of those women who were in the out-rounds. I am also proud of all the women who are in debate. It is time for women to demand a "place." It is past time for women in debate to be considered talented. I feel that if women are encouraged on the high school level to start and stay with debate, we will not be the minority or the marginalized. Only then can we truly get past being placed in a subordinate position; we will be able to define our own "place" in debate on our own terms.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.