Perm – do both – enables a recognition that what is shared between the story of Middle Eastern conquest and Native displacement is a vulnerability that props up and defends a paternal American savior
Lubin 2008 (Alex, Professor of American Studies at the University of New Mexico, “’We Are All Israelies’” in South Atlantic Quarterly)
The comparative imaginaries that have linked the U.S. West to the Orient reemerge in the George W. Bush administration’s desire to “smoke” Osama Bin Laden “out of his cave.”25 The invocation of the Western drama of settler colonialism has always animated American thinking about and activity in the Middle East, and Bush is merely tapping into a well of affective politics that links the United States to the Middle East as well as provides sup- port for increased surveillance and the suspension of rights domestically. Yet, in the contemporary era of neoliberal globalization, the United States’ comparative rendering of the Middle East through its own settler colonial past has been multiplied and transformed into a “global war on terror.” That is, the United States’ unparalleled superpower status enables it to universalize and globalize its comparative politics into a global “clash of civilizations.”26 Comparisons animate the contemporary conflict against “terrorism” as U.S. war officials battle daily to shape the story of the Iraq war by comparing the contemporary battle against “Islamo-fascism” to the antiracist and anti- Fascist memory of World War II. In 2007, President Bush inadvertently cautioned legislators to continue absurdly high rates of war funding so as not to repeat the mistakes of Vietnam, when, according to Bush, the U.S. superpower was undermined domestically by an emasculated Left unable to endure the rigors of war. The comparative turn, hinging on the seem- ing nobility of World War II and the darkness of Vietnam, illustrates an uneasy empire’s attempt to maintain contradictions in the face of messy facts on the ground. Yet these comparisons are always fraught and invite unintended readings. Comparing Israeli and U.S. settler colonialisms seeks to shatter the patina of exceptionalism, as well as the “state of exception,” to use Giorgio Agamben’s term, that currently justifies the military, social, and cultural occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. Indeed, staking a claim for similarity—not exactness—allows us to see particular sites of state and imperial rule not in isolation but as constitutive of larger global systems and circuits of power.27 Although most settler colonies come to an end through a suc- cessful anticolonial rebellion or through the absorption of the settler colony into the mother country, the legacy of colonial rule in places like the U.S. Southwest continues to haunt the postcolonial society. Comparing occu- pied Palestine to the postcolonial U.S. Southwest reveals each location in a new light: we are able to recognize colonial rule in the Middle East as well as the colonial present in the U.S. Southwest.